00:00
We're doing better as a result of social media presence.
00:08
It doesn't do those three things, then it's on the chopping block.
00:11
It's in return on investment discussion.
00:26
Welcome back to another episode of The Daily Dealer Live.
00:29
I'm your host, Sam Dark.
00:29
And welcome to this space where automotive comes together
00:32
to learn, to share, and most importantly, to execute.
00:36
Thanks for choosing to be here in this moment
00:38
on Friday, December 12.
00:40
Today's show is for dealer principals and GMs
00:42
who are tired of excuses and who are focused
00:44
on that execution I mentioned.
00:47
It's true today, margins are tighter.
00:48
Use cards are harder.
00:50
OEM pressures have not let up.
00:52
And the store still winning today
00:53
are doing one thing extremely well.
00:56
They're running disciplined operations
00:58
with zero tolerance for drift.
01:00
We've got two leaders today who live in that world
01:05
Jerry Raymond, president of Jerry Raymond Automotive.
01:08
He's back and in pursuit of 100 rooftops.
01:11
He was last with us in June earlier this year.
01:14
We'll get a progress update on his progress
01:15
towards that and other things.
01:17
And then we'll have Kevin Strohniter,
01:19
dealer operator and GM of Strohniter Chevrolet
01:23
running point on used cars, FNI, culture, and accountability.
01:28
This is gonna be a real conversation.
01:30
And before we dive in,
01:31
let's jump into today's industry headline.
01:36
All right, first up today,
01:37
the U.S. Federal Reserve just cut interest rates again.
01:41
This is not a surprise to anyone watching the markets.
01:44
Lowering its benchmark rate by 25 basis points
01:47
to a three and a half to three, seven, five range,
01:49
making the third cut this year
01:51
and the lowest level in nearly three years.
01:55
That's not unsurprising.
01:56
What is, is the decision was not unanimous.
01:59
Three Fed officials dissented,
02:01
highlighting growing internal tension
02:03
as the central bank tries to balance a cooling labor market
02:07
with inflation that's still above its 2% target.
02:11
Economists are describing this backdrop as K-shaped economy
02:15
where some sectors and households are still doing fine
02:18
while others are clearly struggling,
02:21
which makes it harder for any single policy move
02:23
to help everyone at once.
02:25
Fed Chair Jerome Powell stressed patients
02:28
saying policy makers need time to see
02:30
how this year's rate cuts ripple through the economy
02:33
before acting again even as political pressure
02:36
builds to move faster.
02:38
Looking ahead, the Fed's next meeting is in January
02:40
and Powell said decisions from here
02:43
will be driven by incoming data
02:45
even as pressure from the White House intensifies.
02:47
And as a side note,
02:48
the incoming data comment is interesting
02:50
because the Fed did not have a full set of data
02:53
due to the government outage.
02:54
So there is a little bit of an attempt
02:57
to help the economy without all the facts in front of them.
03:00
And I think that's what Powell is insinuating.
03:02
Next up, auto loan delinquencies are still creeping higher
03:05
but the pace is slowing.
03:07
Transunzion now expects overall 60 day plus delinquencies
03:12
to hit 1.51% by year end
03:14
before leveling off around 1.54% at the end of 2026.
03:19
That makes this the fifth straight year
03:22
of rising delinquencies
03:24
but each increase has been smaller than the last
03:26
which could help explain why lenders haven't slammed
03:29
the brakes on credit access for those riskiest borrowers.
03:33
Instead of pulling back, lenders are leaning on refinancing
03:36
to keep payments manageable.
03:38
In Q3 alone, for example, borrowers refinanced
03:41
$3.8 billion across 121,000 loans
03:45
saving about 77 bucks a month on average.
03:49
As expected credit unions are absorbing most of this spike
03:52
controlling roughly 65% of ReFi volume
03:56
and offering the biggest rate cuts
03:58
but those savings come with a trade-off
04:00
with refinance loan terms now averaging more than 90 months.
04:07
More cars are staying in driveways longer
04:09
quietly stretching replacement cycles
04:12
and keeping buyers out of the market longer
04:14
than dealers likely care for.
04:19
And in other news next up,
04:21
a long running internal fraud scheme has surfaced
04:24
at Murgado Automotive Group in Miami, Florida
04:26
where prosecutors say a former billing clerk
04:29
and two members of her family
04:31
stole more than a million dollars from the dealer group.
04:34
This is no shade on Murgado, great group
04:38
and it's a cautionary tale I think
04:40
for all of us auto dealers.
04:42
Investigators allege Yodi Mejas
04:45
who worked at the store since 2013
04:47
began the scheme around 2020
04:50
cutting hundreds of fraudulent refund checks
04:53
tied to real customer accounts
04:55
but the checks were not made out to customers
04:57
they were made out to her husband and to her son
05:00
and typically ranged from $1,000 to $3,000.
05:04
The operation ran quietly for years
05:06
until an anonymous tip in August 2024
05:09
triggered an internet review
05:11
that uncovered more than 480 suspect checks.
05:16
Bottom line, the case is a vital reminder
05:19
that even trusted back office rules
05:21
need separation of duties, routine audits
05:23
and controls that catch patterns early
05:26
before losses quietly compound
05:28
and then my own take on this too is
05:30
at the end of the day we depend on people,
05:32
good people around us to help support this business
05:35
and it's a call to action for those good people
05:38
if you see something for heaven's sakes say something
05:41
that's a massive fraud and a hit to that group.
05:44
Apologies to them next and finally up today
05:47
according to a brand new forecast from Edmunds
05:50
the new vehicle market is poised to settle
05:52
into a steady groove in 2026
05:54
with sales projected around 16 million units
05:57
that's the SAR, which is essentially flat with 2025.
06:01
Translation, the market isn't getting cheaper
06:04
but price growth has largely leveled off
06:06
with many buyers no longer paying over MSRP.
06:10
Higher income households are still doing
06:12
most of the heavy lifting in this automotive economy
06:15
especially in the luxury segment or loyalty remains strong
06:18
and repeat buyers continue to cycle back
06:21
into premium and SUV trucks.
06:23
At the same time, vehicle affordability
06:25
is still public enemy number one, many shoppers are stretched
06:29
which keeps volume capped
06:31
even a slightly lower interest rates
06:32
offer a bit of relief on monthly payments.
06:35
What's the big picture here?
06:36
Well, 2026 auto sales will likely fall
06:39
into a holding pattern and growth will hinge on mix
06:42
finance structure and keeping well qualified buyers
06:45
in the funnel while everyone else shops more cautiously
06:49
and that is a wrap on today's industry news.
06:54
Yeah, you know, theft and fraud in this industry
06:58
in my prior role with the Swiss based insurance company
07:00
Zurich, I insured auto dealers against risks
07:04
and employee theft was always a big one
07:06
and you know, it's never the fault
07:08
I feel like it's not the fault of the auto dealer
07:10
that gets caught up in it or victimized by it
07:13
but man, you know, it just reminds you
07:15
how much dependent we are on good people around us.
07:18
Terry Ondia says yikes, which is correct.
07:23
So props to Murgado.
07:25
I actually saw him at the CEO chase event
07:27
this past week, great group.
07:29
And you know, thanks for sharing that story
07:31
in the news cycle because again,
07:33
I think it's a great reminder to us all
07:35
to watch out for that sort of thing
07:37
and a reminder to everybody watching today
07:39
our daily dealer live listening audience.
07:41
Post your comments, your questions, your feedbacks
07:44
to social media all across the CDG social media platforms
07:47
where we're being broadcast today.
07:49
We'd love to bring your comments into the show
07:52
and props to Terry for that yikes comment
07:55
because it does shape today's show
07:57
and I am pumped about today.
07:58
First up today, we have a return guest from June
08:02
one of our first episodes.
08:05
We're on 93 episode 93 today.
08:08
So joining us today, President Jerry Automotive,
08:11
Jerry Raymond, welcome to the show, Jerry.
08:13
Hey, nice to be back, are ya?
08:16
It's awesome to have you back.
08:17
Thanks for being here.
08:18
So when you were last here,
08:20
you were hot in pursuit of 100 dealerships.
08:23
You were almost four years in.
08:25
Now December 15th, we'll mark your fourth anniversary.
08:30
How's the pursuit of 100, Jerry?
08:32
Man, you know, it's a lot easier to say it
08:36
than actually to do it, right?
08:37
I mean, it's a fun time though.
08:40
It goes back to it.
08:41
It's funny what you're saying.
08:42
It's all about the people, right?
08:43
So you have to have a great team
08:45
or surround yourself with a great team.
08:46
Got the best processes, procedures in the world,
08:48
but without a great team to execute what you wanna do,
08:52
it's never gonna work.
08:53
But it is pretty cool to come up on four years
08:55
on the 15th is when we officially open our first store.
08:58
So congratulations to everyone
09:01
that's been involved with me and our group.
09:04
That's pretty cool.
09:05
So you've had Chevy stores.
09:07
You had a Stilana store, bought and sold.
09:10
What type of activity have you had since our last show?
09:12
You were at three stores then.
09:14
Have you grown since?
09:15
Yeah, we actually were able to get another one.
09:17
We closed on a Ford store, which is pretty cool
09:20
because that's where I first started selling cars.
09:22
Probably about five miles away.
09:24
We got our first Ford store.
09:25
So happy to be with Ford.
09:28
Hopefully make a name with them.
09:30
And then we're actually in pursuit of another one
09:32
as we speak, and that's coming to a close.
09:34
It's actually kind of already closed
09:36
and we'll be opening up probably sometime
09:37
in the spring of next year.
09:40
It's ready to close, but it's still top secret.
09:42
Can you talk about it or no?
09:44
It's a major metro market
09:47
where huge playing potential, huge playing volume.
09:50
So we're really excited.
09:51
I think it's gonna put us our name,
09:53
our group up there with the other big dogs.
09:56
So we're really excited to keep on growing.
09:59
Again, with growth does come as challenges
10:01
as we learn every day.
10:03
So it's not always rainbow and butterflies, right?
10:07
So as we grow, we learn.
10:09
We don't always do things right,
10:10
but as long as we win, more than we lose, right?
10:14
So talk to us about that, Jerry.
10:16
Coming back to the news today,
10:17
Murgado, victim of a massive internal fraud
10:21
by a longtime employee.
10:23
I mean, a million dollars to lose on fraudulent checks.
10:26
How do you think about that
10:27
when you're looking to grow and scale
10:29
and grow so quickly in size?
10:32
How do you protect against that?
10:34
Yeah, you know, it's tough because you, again,
10:37
you always put in procedures, you put in policies,
10:40
two-step verification, two check centers,
10:43
whatever the case may be,
10:45
you always have to put those into place.
10:47
But again, it just goes back to the old saying,
10:50
it's all about your people.
10:51
If you have the wrong people,
10:52
it's never going to work out.
10:54
You can have people that you think are doing the right thing,
10:56
you can have the procedures in,
10:58
but again, if you don't have the right people,
11:01
or if you don't have that culture,
11:03
again, sometimes you just don't know and you just get burnt,
11:05
but again, it all goes ties back to the people.
11:07
So what do you have to do?
11:09
You really have to take your time of finding the right people.
11:13
You know, we could go,
11:15
it's okay to go without that position
11:17
maybe for a certain amount of time,
11:18
but if you rush into something
11:19
and just pick someone to fill that position,
11:22
I guarantee it's not going to work out
11:23
as well as if you were just taking your time.
11:25
So it kind of goes back to that.
11:26
It's about the hiring process.
11:28
It's about the people.
11:29
It's trying to find the right fit for your organization.
11:32
So you're expanding quickly as an organization.
11:34
You want to get to a hundred and want to add rooftops.
11:36
You're on the eve of a major acquisition.
11:39
As an owner, as a successful dealer,
11:42
walk us through your thought processes.
11:43
You acquire this new group.
11:45
How do you go in and find the right people?
11:47
How much change do you do initially?
11:50
And what does that change look like, Jerry?
11:52
Yeah, you really have to take your time
11:54
to find the right leader, right?
11:56
So we spend countless hours
11:59
trying to find that right person.
12:01
We go through lots of resumes.
12:03
We do a lot of phone interviews from that phone interview.
12:07
We know we do a lot of teams interviews
12:08
and then in-person interviews.
12:10
So we really try to find the right person
12:12
to lead the helm, right?
12:13
So again, you know, I've come from a sports background.
12:16
So in order to build the championship team,
12:19
you have to have that culture.
12:20
So you really have to have the person
12:22
that is leading your group
12:24
or leading that particular store buy into the culture.
12:28
So give me the top three things you look for
12:31
in a great leader, because it's easy to say culture.
12:34
It's easy to say right,
12:36
but what does that mean to Jerry today
12:38
in December of 2025?
12:40
What am I looking for in that time of year?
12:42
Yeah, it's about the experience.
12:45
It's about your attitude and it's about your attitude.
12:48
So you know, attitude goes twice.
12:49
It's 100% about your attitude.
12:51
You might not have all the right answers,
12:53
but if you're willing to find the right answer
12:55
or know how to get to the right answer
12:56
or do what it's willing to take to get
12:59
to find that answer and to make it work,
13:02
you can't teach attitude.
13:03
You can teach a lot of things in life,
13:04
but you cannot teach attitude and dedication.
13:07
So attitude is definitely on the top three twice.
13:12
So as you're searching for that GM,
13:13
I get this question a lot when I speak to panels.
13:15
I was in Canada speaking to a bunch of Lexus dealers
13:17
who are like, what's the top thing you look for in a GM?
13:20
So you gave us attitude, attitude.
13:22
What's the one thing you're looking to avoid, Jerry?
13:24
What's the biggest red flag?
13:27
The biggest red flag for me personally is,
13:30
if I'm looking for a GM and I'm looking at their resume,
13:34
they jump around a lot.
13:35
And again, there could be valid day reasons for that.
13:37
But if we have a jumper going from store to store
13:40
every year, typically it's not gonna work for us.
13:42
If you have that person that's stuck where they're at
13:45
and they're trying to get to that next step,
13:48
Or even if you could have that person
13:50
that was let go from their current position
13:53
and things happen, they have something to prove
13:56
or they have a chip on their shoulder, I love that.
14:00
So it's not so much about a lot of people
14:05
always say the right thing on interviews.
14:07
If you're a general manager or been general manager before,
14:09
you usually know what to say
14:10
and you really don't know until they're there
14:12
in the store working,
14:13
but you can tell by someone's attitude
14:16
or if they have that chip on their shoulder, right?
14:18
So those are the kind of things that I look for
14:20
because everyone's gonna say the right thing
14:21
for an interview, my personal opinion.
14:24
So great comments from online.
14:25
So Kevin Stuckey 06 says,
14:29
congrats on the continued success.
14:32
Correct, the right people are everything.
14:35
Colin Kubik says your attitude determines
14:37
your latitude, great point, Jerry.
14:39
And then Kevin pops back up.
14:41
Sports culture always comes up multi-tasking
14:44
at its finest, somebody put a quarter in the merry-go-round,
14:48
LOL, so that's funny.
14:51
You know, one thing that's a red flag to me,
14:53
and I agree with you, it is tough sometimes
14:56
to hire and to interview because people,
15:00
we're all in sales, we know how to sell ourselves,
15:02
we know how to sound really good, right?
15:04
And what you have is you have your track record
15:07
to rely on and to explain.
15:09
And a big caution to me is that GM candidate
15:13
has been in a few different places
15:15
over five, six years, whatever,
15:17
and they've got a story
15:18
for why they didn't succeed in every single one.
15:21
I don't want the story about why you couldn't succeed.
15:24
I want the story about where your success was
15:26
and how you would have doubled down on it, right?
15:28
Have you run into that where people are able
15:30
to quickly say why they didn't succeed?
15:33
I don't wanna hear it.
15:34
Yeah, that goes back to the resume.
15:36
Oh, well, it's always this person's fault
15:38
or that person's fault.
15:39
You know, if you start to hear that a lot
15:41
of someone else's fault, it's usually your fault, right?
15:43
So, you know, we look for accountability
15:45
and even if it was your fault, you know,
15:46
I'd love to hear you say that, hey, sorry,
15:48
it was my fault and I messed up.
15:50
Own it, I messed up in this situation,
15:52
but you know, I learned from that
15:53
it's never gonna happen again
15:54
because without failure, there's no growth, right?
15:57
Or without growth, there's no failure.
15:59
You can look at it either way.
16:00
So you grow from those experiences, right?
16:03
If you truly did grow from it.
16:05
So, you know, there's all kinds of different ways
16:07
to deal with failure.
16:12
Why is it so hard for so many leaders to say,
16:14
hey, I failed in this element.
16:15
Here's why and here's the takeaway lesson I learned.
16:20
It is, but you know, they're not really leaders.
16:22
That's, you know, they're not really leaders.
16:24
That's why it comes down to a leader
16:25
will take accountability
16:27
and they'll be the first to point the finger at themselves.
16:29
They'll be the first to say, hey, I messed up.
16:32
You know, a lot of things that we use
16:33
when you come into our dealership or our group,
16:36
it's always about we, it's never about I, it's we, we, we.
16:39
So, you know, that's one thing that, you know, we teach,
16:43
you know, it's never I, it's never him,
16:45
it's never me, it's never her, it's we, you know,
16:47
we win as a group, we fail as a group, you know, it's us.
16:50
So, you know, that's one thing that I look for
16:51
in the little word tracks that people say
16:54
because it helped, you know, playing sports, you know,
16:56
when you won championships, it's we, you know,
16:58
it's never I, the great ones always say, we, we, we,
17:01
Yeah, yeah, that is absolutely 100% true.
17:06
So, we always ask the same question to begin.
17:08
We've kind of gone a little bit around
17:10
because we started with the news,
17:12
but how's business in your neck of the woods right now?
17:15
Yeah, I mean, business is good.
17:17
Obviously it can always be better.
17:18
You know, we're focusing a lot on our current customers.
17:22
You know, we're, I think the one thing with us
17:25
that we learned is, you know, we have the business, right?
17:28
You know, so we have the customers,
17:29
we have the opportunities, but, you know,
17:31
what are we doing with the opportunities
17:33
and the customers that we currently have?
17:35
So again, everyone's always looking for more and more and more,
17:38
but you know, what are we doing with our current business?
17:40
You know, what are we doing with our fixed operations?
17:42
What are we doing with our current sales?
17:43
Our leads, our customers calling in.
17:45
So business is good, you know, it could be great,
17:50
but we're in the process of trying to do a better job
17:54
of the customers that we currently have.
17:56
Again, I think that's a big opportunity with us,
17:59
you know, with the fixed operations,
18:00
especially trying to get the absorption level up
18:03
as high as we possibly can
18:05
to really bring in the customers that are calling in already.
18:09
It's submitting leads, you know,
18:10
trying not to lose them from to other makes or models
18:13
or to other dealers.
18:14
So business is very good.
18:18
but you know, we're always trying to make it better.
18:21
All right, so as you're working to capitalize
18:23
on the business you have,
18:24
I think that's a sentiment that many dealers have right now.
18:27
You're looking in fixed ops,
18:28
you're looking at your current owner database.
18:30
What's a specific strategy?
18:32
You're implementing in your stores
18:35
to help maximize fixed ops and your current database.
18:39
Yeah, you know, I don't get into really stats that much,
18:41
but you know, it's, you know, this business to me,
18:45
it's so, it's so simple, right?
18:48
So customers are calling in all the time
18:50
and you walk through your dealerships,
18:52
you hear your phone ring all the time, right?
18:55
I mean, it's, I swear it,
18:56
but the phone, everyone's always saying,
18:57
oh, I'm answering the phone,
18:58
I'm answering the phone,
18:59
but the phone rings 24 or seven
19:02
and people are calling in to give you business
19:03
or to ask questions or opportunities, right?
19:06
So that's something that I've been really focused on.
19:09
We've been really focused on the last 30 days
19:12
is trying to better handle our call volume
19:14
so we don't miss those drop calls.
19:16
We don't miss those opportunities.
19:19
And of course, there's AI out there.
19:21
There's more people.
19:22
There's all kinds of things that we could be doing
19:25
better of a job of.
19:26
We're just trying to figure out what's works for us.
19:28
So we don't miss those opportunities,
19:29
but that's a major thing with us.
19:32
And I think a lot of dealers out there,
19:34
you know, you walk through your showrooms,
19:35
you walk through your service departments
19:37
and I swear the phone never stops ringing.
19:39
You know, but who's answering the phone?
19:40
Like if someone's answering the phone,
19:41
okay, someone just got the phone's ringing again.
19:43
I mean, it's a great problem to have,
19:45
but you know, it's a bad problem
19:47
that people are calling in
19:47
and you can't answer those questions
19:49
or you can't get a hold of them.
19:50
So I think that's a really big focus item for us
19:53
is to better deal with our call volume
19:56
and making sure that we're not
19:57
experiencing drop calls.
20:00
And supporting that viewpoint is data recently from CDK.
20:03
We recorded an industry spotlight podcast recently.
20:05
CDK was showing that the average wait time,
20:08
get this, Jerry, the average wait time,
20:10
not the high, not the low, was, I think it was,
20:13
and I don't have the stat in front of me,
20:15
it was somewhere between five and 10 minutes.
20:17
Can you imagine waiting on the phone for,
20:18
let's say, eight minutes to talk to somebody?
20:21
You would hang up, right?
20:22
I would hang up in 10 seconds.
20:23
I mean, it's great. I would hang up.
20:25
Do you believe that CDK stat?
20:29
It's a problem in the industry, right?
20:31
You know, it's a huge problem.
20:32
I mean, it's a problem.
20:33
I mean, like this business is common sense.
20:36
And how many times have, you know,
20:38
you called your own dealership?
20:39
Just, I mean, I do it all the time.
20:41
I mean, I do it all the time.
20:43
And then I go in and say,
20:45
hey, I just called.
20:46
So what just happened, right?
20:47
So I do that all the time, literally,
20:48
but this business is common sense.
20:51
There's nothing like, it's just common sense.
20:53
It's just the people like,
20:55
just think about how you want to be treated.
20:57
It's like you're learning this in kindergarten,
20:59
my son's in first grade.
21:01
The golden rule, treat others how you want to be treated,
21:03
But if you're on the phone for five or 10 minutes,
21:06
listen to an AI bot or listen to this person
21:08
and put you on hold,
21:09
do you want, no one wants to do business like that.
21:12
And if you do, it's just like,
21:14
oh man, I have to sit on hold with them.
21:16
You know, like, this is my only option
21:18
because I'm trying to get an appointment.
21:19
I'm trying to get to service.
21:20
I'm trying to get a sales call.
21:21
I mean, so you're forced to do it,
21:25
but you don't want to do it.
21:27
So if we could change that whole entire mindset of a customer
21:30
or if we just fix it, you know,
21:33
don't even change, just fix it at our locations,
21:35
it's amazing what's going to happen.
21:37
So I interviewed a while back,
21:39
the fixed ops head of Longo Toit,
21:42
a biggest Toyota dealership in,
21:44
maybe in the world,
21:45
but definitely in the United States,
21:47
huge fixed operations business.
21:49
The service director there,
21:50
he said, look, if a customer has to call you,
21:54
You win by reaching out to the customer first.
22:00
is there anything you're implementing
22:02
in your service drive business
22:03
to better answer those calls,
22:05
respond to customer needs,
22:06
whether it's AI, data tech,
22:08
what systems or platforms are you using?
22:11
We're actually making a major overhaul as we speak
22:15
and we've been doing so much research again.
22:18
This is also goes back to, you know,
22:20
how we talked about,
22:21
don't implement something just to implement it.
22:24
Implement something that everyone buys into
22:26
you want to find the right person,
22:29
find someone that you like,
22:31
find that right person.
22:32
It goes no difference for what we're trying to implement
22:34
in our service department or fixed ops departments.
22:39
get multiple calls,
22:40
multiple demos with multiple things that you think,
22:43
pick your free favorite,
22:45
pick your two favorite,
22:46
have those conversations with your staff,
22:48
things of that nature
22:50
and then go from there to implement that.
22:51
But we are 100% implementing something
22:55
into our service departments that are fixed ops
22:57
to better what we're talking about right now.
23:00
That's the major thing with us right now.
23:01
But again, we're taking our time doing it
23:04
and we're pretty close to picking one or two,
23:07
narrowing it down to one or two,
23:09
but we haven't made a decision yet,
23:11
but it's 1000% coming.
23:13
So I was on a panel recently
23:15
and I was asked the question,
23:16
how do you decide when you're thinking about AI
23:19
how do you pick a winner in the space?
23:22
And I think that's a good question.
23:24
How do you pick a winner
23:25
if you're looking at several different companies?
23:27
Man, it's funny that we're having this conversation
23:29
because I've been doing this for the last 45 days.
23:33
So, you know, how do you do it?
23:35
It's like anything else, right?
23:37
I want something that does it different.
23:41
I'm going to tell you a little bit
23:42
about my mindset, my secrets, I guess per se, but,
23:45
you know, hopefully these vendors are all listening right now
23:49
because we're going to give them the secret sauce.
23:51
I know, this is a secret sauce and for other people,
23:54
I mean, AI does such a great job
23:57
when someone calls into your store.
23:59
They do such a great job
24:01
when someone's coming in for the most part, right?
24:04
But we talk about lead times,
24:06
but what can it do to, you know, be proactive?
24:10
That's what I want.
24:11
That's what we're looking for.
24:13
What's it trying to do to be proactive
24:16
It's not about, I mean, if someone's calling in,
24:18
they're already calling in.
24:19
How do we make them to not call it
24:21
just like the Toyota fixed ops guys?
24:24
How do we make it so that they're getting in contact,
24:28
checking on their cars, checking on their appointments,
24:31
knowing their service before we call them?
24:33
That's what I'm looking for.
24:36
So, that's, you know,
24:36
I probably said too much for my secrets,
24:38
but you know, that's what it is.
24:40
Does that tool exist today, Jerry,
24:42
in a way that's suitable to you?
24:47
You know, I think a lot of it is text messages.
24:51
I don't, I think that's the age that we're in
24:54
I think the emails, they all get lost.
24:56
Phone calls, no one answered their phone calls.
24:59
If you don't know a number, it goes to voice mail.
25:00
So I really, everyone reads a text message.
25:02
You can be sitting right there.
25:03
You're probably reading a text, you know,
25:04
why you're doing it.
25:05
Yeah, text messages is the way to go.
25:07
There needs to be some kind of software
25:09
for the Silicon Valley.
25:10
I mean, this is a billion dollar idea
25:11
if you can do it well, right?
25:12
But all the AI right now
25:14
is currently programmed to kick in while,
25:17
obviously someone calls in.
25:19
How do you different from being proactive
25:22
or being really good at being proactive at it?
25:25
That's what we're looking for.
25:27
We're in a now business.
25:29
We're in a proactive business.
25:31
I mean, how many times do you hear people say,
25:33
oh, you don't want your salespeople
25:34
or anyone just sitting there, you know,
25:37
just waiting for someone to come in.
25:38
You don't want your service advisor
25:40
just sitting there waiting for someone to come in.
25:42
You want them to be proactive.
25:43
Well, AI is 10 times more than us.
25:45
It should be 100% more proactive than us.
25:49
So, you know, I think there are just,
25:50
a lot of people are just getting into
25:52
that proactive aspect of AI.
25:54
And I think the next person
25:55
who really can control that will actually,
25:57
I mean, it's a, that's the,
26:00
that's not in the future, it's the present, right?
26:02
I mean, it's not in the present, it's the past.
26:03
That's just what we need.
26:05
So you've cast this vision for proactive outreach
26:07
in your fixed ops to win.
26:09
You're looking at different tools in the marketplace
26:12
to gauge whether or not they actually do that.
26:14
Are there any red flags when you make
26:16
that vendor selection in the AI space
26:17
that would say, stay away from this company
26:20
or be careful about this solution.
26:22
It's not going to work or whatever.
26:24
You know, for me, it's all about attitude.
26:28
So again, I keep on saying this.
26:30
It's going about the attitude.
26:31
So if I'm sitting there talking to someone
26:34
who doesn't truly believe in their product,
26:36
who isn't passionate about their product,
26:38
who isn't, has a great attitude about their product,
26:42
and they're just on these calls,
26:43
like, oh, just going through the motions, I'm done.
26:46
You know, I'm done.
26:47
I want the people that truly believe in their product,
26:49
hey, this is the best thing in the world.
26:51
That's what really gets me excited.
26:54
You know, that's what sells me.
26:55
And again, that's what really gets me engaged
26:59
So I don't know if that's the right answer
27:01
that you're looking for,
27:02
but it's the attitude of someone presenting with their AI.
27:05
That's really, you know,
27:06
someone passionate about what they're doing.
27:09
And you can tell if someone's passionate or not,
27:11
but you know, if they believe in their tool,
27:13
if they think their tool is great,
27:14
if they know their tool is great,
27:15
if they know that their tool will help increase
27:18
what I'm looking for,
27:19
or it will eventually help, right?
27:21
That's what I'm looking for, too.
27:23
All right, I want to share a perspective of mine
27:24
and get your take on this.
27:26
So I was recently at this Chase CEO event,
27:28
and they had an economist up.
27:30
And listen, they said,
27:31
don't share a lot of what you've learned here,
27:32
but I'm going to share it anyway.
27:33
So this guy was super smart.
27:35
He said two things.
27:36
He said, number one, in his opinion,
27:38
he's like, look, AI technology
27:41
is going to keep the US out of a recession.
27:43
It's going to be such an economic boon
27:46
to multiple different industries, automotive as well.
27:49
But he also said AI is going to be a separator.
27:51
There's going to be two types of people in the world.
27:54
Those that are masters of AI that understand it,
27:56
that implement it, that utilize it to up their game
27:59
in the way that their business functions.
28:01
And there will be slaves to AI
28:02
that don't understand it, that fight it,
28:04
that probably just run alongside it.
28:08
And that is kind of cool to me in your role,
28:11
because you're learning it, you're understanding it,
28:13
and then you're ultimately going to make a selection.
28:16
And choosing the right one is important.
28:18
What's your take on that?
28:19
That it will avoid a recession
28:21
and that there's basically two people,
28:23
those who understand it and those who don't?
28:25
You know, the recession aspect,
28:27
I don't really believe in because you always hear about,
28:29
you know, there's always going to be a recession.
28:32
You know, I don't listen to that.
28:33
I was saying there won't be because of that.
28:36
Oh, that's even better.
28:37
That's about, you know, but again,
28:39
I don't believe in that stuff,
28:40
but what I do a thousand percent AI
28:43
is going to 1,000% separate people.
28:46
It's like, you know, back in, again, I'm younger.
28:49
So again, 23 years ago when the internet
28:51
came out in the car business, people like,
28:52
oh, wow, it's just a, whatever, it could be,
28:54
that's, we're in that.
28:55
We are currently in that right now.
28:57
And that's what, this is what it is,
29:00
probably 30, 35 years ago, wherever it was
29:02
when the internet came back in the car business.
29:04
AI is out there doing so much and it's been out there
29:08
doing so much on other companies.
29:10
But again, it goes back to the car industry
29:13
is just such an old school business, right?
29:15
So again, maybe it doesn't take on as fast,
29:18
but I'm telling you, AI is not even the future.
29:20
It's not the present.
29:23
And we got, if you know how to master,
29:25
if you know how to do it, I mean, you're going to go,
29:27
I mean, the sky's the limit.
29:28
I truly believe that.
29:30
I truly believe that statement.
29:31
If you can master it, it's going to help out greatly.
29:34
So in support of your comments, Kevin Stuckey
29:35
pops into the comments in a couple of different things.
29:38
He says, being in the trenches all day, week and month
29:40
with four AI vendors, it's a lot of work,
29:42
but extremely rewarding for your guests and team
29:45
when you customize it the way you want everything handled.
29:47
And then he goes on, those who use AI
29:50
will replace those who don't.
29:52
And then Dan C, great comment, always cautious
29:54
when a vendor has had numerous CEOs over the past few years.
29:57
And I do agree, particularly in that world,
30:01
And you know what's interesting?
30:03
I also judge a little bit by the quality of the field.
30:06
And you mentioned that, right?
30:07
You've got to have good people.
30:09
But there are so many of these newer AI-type companies
30:12
that just don't have a good field force that
30:14
can connect and communicate and bring people
30:16
into the vision of what it does.
30:18
And I think that's a point of failure right now
30:21
in the market as well.
30:23
Yeah, I mean, that's a totally great point.
30:24
Because I mean, there's lots of the Silicon Valley AI coming
30:27
out trying to create AI for what we need.
30:30
And they're not really in the business,
30:31
but they're trying to come out to what we need.
30:34
And then make it, you know, just do a quick turn around,
30:36
sell it, boom, they make their, I don't know,
30:38
whatever the case may be, they make the money.
30:40
But the AI that's truly going to work for this business,
30:43
it's going to be someone that fully understands
30:45
the business, partnering up with someone
30:47
that fully understands how AI works.
30:50
And together, they're going to specialize
30:52
in the automotive space.
30:53
And they're going to make something truly spectacular
30:55
that's really just going to hit home for everyone.
30:58
I mean, that's, you know, it's the passion.
31:00
It's the passion of the car business,
31:01
meaning the passion of the AI.
31:03
Together, collaborate and they're going to create
31:05
something special whenever that happens.
31:07
That's what I think we're waiting for.
31:09
All right, so let's transition from your excellence
31:11
in fixed ops, the announcement you're going to make soon
31:14
about how you're going to get that proactive outreach
31:16
using digital technology to use cars, new and used cars.
31:19
So there's been a slight softening in the star.
31:21
There's a ton of inventory pressures.
31:23
A lot of people are talking about narrowing
31:25
and compression margins.
31:27
The dealerships that hold consistent pricing discipline
31:31
So in your view, what operational discipline
31:34
separates winners from second place stores today?
31:38
And you can't say attitude.
31:40
Because you've already used that one.
31:42
No, honestly, I don't think a lot of people
31:48
are just so spoiled from the COVID days.
31:50
And it made a lot of dealers bad dealers.
31:53
It made a lot of good dealers, good dealers.
31:56
Great dealers, we're the great dealers still.
31:58
It's about your people and your processes in your business.
32:01
It's your processes.
32:02
So we have to go back to, this is back to the car business.
32:06
It's not back to just having the desk manager
32:08
to sit behind your desk, pencil and deals,
32:12
customers come in and they just want to buy cars.
32:13
It's about actually going out there and working it.
32:15
So you have to work your processes.
32:17
You have to constantly come into work to work,
32:20
whether it's if you know that you need pre-onimatory,
32:22
what are you doing to go out there
32:23
and find that pre-onimatory?
32:25
It's really about isolating your issue.
32:28
If you need inventory of new,
32:29
if you need inventory of pre-owned cars,
32:31
if you're too heavy in new cars,
32:32
if you're too heavy in used cars,
32:34
if you don't have enough,
32:35
you got to identify the problem
32:37
and then find the solution.
32:39
So maybe some people are too heavy in new cars right now.
32:42
So, okay, you know you're heavy.
32:43
Where are you doing to upload those
32:44
to create better foreplay expense?
32:46
If you know that you need more pre-owned cars,
32:49
what kind of processes or what kind of vendors
32:51
or what are you doing with your staff
32:53
to get the pre-owned cars?
32:55
Are you just one of the options
32:56
or are you utilizing Facebook Marketplace
32:59
or are you utilizing whatever you think that you should be
33:01
to create that gap?
33:04
So I think it just,
33:05
it comes down to finding, identifying the issue
33:08
and then finding the solution to that issue.
33:09
But first you have to know what the issue is.
33:12
So I don't know if that's the right answer
33:13
but I think the car business
33:14
is back to a normal car business.
33:16
So you have to work at it.
33:18
You know, the people that work at it,
33:19
you gotta work at it.
33:20
And again, it's about the culture of the business.
33:24
You got that in because it's right.
33:27
That is ground zero for it all.
33:27
All right, last couple of questions here.
33:29
Use car acquisition you touched on.
33:31
It is a differentiator in today's marketplace.
33:34
New cars, sales are where they are.
33:36
Use cars, that profit is made at purchase, not at sale.
33:40
What's your best source of use car acquisition today
33:43
and how are you leaning into it coming into next year?
33:47
your best source is always gonna be trades, right?
33:49
I mean, that's 100%.
33:50
That's always what you try and do.
33:51
But, you know, if we do need cars,
33:54
again, you know, we go out there and we hit the auctions,
33:58
we buy the same brands, I should say,
34:01
and we get those, we certify them
34:03
and try and get the trades that way.
34:04
So again, it's going out there buying cars
34:07
in order to get the trades.
34:08
We know that we're not gonna make good deals
34:10
or typically make good purchases,
34:12
buying outside the auctions.
34:15
But again, you know,
34:16
we try and get the trades on those.
34:18
I know a lot of people say the service drive
34:21
and every yes, that's 1,000% correct
34:23
and you're still trying to do that,
34:24
but the quickest, easiest thing,
34:26
realistic car business-wise is going to the auction,
34:29
getting the cars, the same brands that you sell,
34:32
bring it to you, flip them as fast as you can,
34:34
no matter what it is,
34:35
and get the trades and build your inventory that way.
34:38
So you sort of dismiss service drive
34:41
and it is kind of the rage right now.
34:43
Why do you push that aside?
34:46
You know, I don't think I dismiss it.
34:47
I just think, you know, a lot of people talk about it
34:49
and they don't do it, right?
34:50
So that's one thing that I'll never,
34:52
you'll never hear me say is,
34:54
I just don't say something to say it.
34:56
You know, yes, I know the service drive
34:57
is a phenomenal place that we shouldn't be able to get cars,
35:01
But it's hard, yeah.
35:02
We don't do it, you know,
35:03
because we don't want to be those people
35:05
like you constantly sit, you know,
35:06
trying to sell your customers every time they come in.
35:09
You don't want to put pressure on your customers
35:10
every time they come in.
35:11
You don't want them to feel like
35:13
they're trying, they're putting their guard up.
35:15
So that's why we don't do it as much
35:17
as maybe others should.
35:18
Sure, we interact with everyone in service.
35:21
We always say, hi, if they ask questions,
35:22
certainly we present offers,
35:24
but do we go out there and say,
35:25
hey, I could buy your car today for this?
35:27
Or hey, what do you think about it?
35:28
It's just, it's a sales pitch
35:30
that people know that you're coming into the,
35:32
the, you know, into the dealership.
35:34
Maybe people don't want to hear it.
35:35
So again, there's other ways to do it.
35:37
You know, again, that's about the customer experience also.
35:40
We try and make our customer experience.
35:42
We want people to come into our stores
35:43
because they like coming into their stores.
35:45
They don't want to feel like they're constantly being sold
35:47
or constantly switching.
35:48
If someone wants to do something, you know,
35:50
you have those conversations in the service drive
35:52
or having a cup of coffee, they're going to tell you,
35:54
just talk to people, just talk to them.
35:56
If they want to know something, you can probably sniff it out.
35:59
So that's my kind of philosophy on that.
36:01
Again, is it right or wrong?
36:02
Or am I a bad dealer because of it?
36:05
Is there opportunity that I'm missing?
36:06
I'm sure there is, but you know, we look at other things.
36:09
Yeah, I think there is opportunity,
36:11
but I agree with you.
36:12
I think one of the challenges in our industry
36:14
is it's disjointed a little bit.
36:16
Imagine being a service customer
36:17
and you go into a service drive for an appointment
36:20
and you get the text about the appointment,
36:22
you get the text with the video MPI,
36:24
you get a separate text with a trade-in offer for your car
36:28
and you intended to be there for 60 minutes.
36:30
You've been there for two and a half hours
36:31
and now they want to trade your car out, right?
36:33
Like, I think what the industry needs
36:37
is something that's more unified
36:39
that doesn't have a bunch of disparate systems
36:41
that are reaching out and trying to do,
36:43
I mean, you set a proactive outreach
36:45
in different channels, right?
36:49
A thousand percent.
36:50
So Yoga Cars backs this up online says,
36:52
you need a simple tool for service drive
36:54
that will have soft approach
36:55
and let customers raise their hand, not go after them.
36:57
Let them come to you, which makes sense, right?
37:01
So maybe that's one of the tools.
37:03
Maybe that's one of the tools you're looking at.
37:05
All right, so as you continue to grow, Jerry,
37:08
and this is the last question,
37:09
what brands are you looking for next?
37:12
What do you want to add to the portfolio
37:13
that you maybe do or don't have currently?
37:16
You know, we love everyone.
37:18
You know, I love my current brands.
37:19
I love our partners and our manufacturers.
37:21
I love all the relationships that we have built thus far.
37:26
There is no brand make model that we won't sell.
37:29
So that question is, you know, sky's the limit for us.
37:34
In order to get them all, you gotta love them all, right?
37:36
So, you know, we have a great relationship
37:38
with a lot of the manufacturers
37:39
and you know, I don't think that's a,
37:42
we want everything.
37:43
So as you think about growing,
37:44
you think about acquisition,
37:45
you think about winning in 2026.
37:47
What's one thing that keeps you up at night
37:49
that you're trying to solve for?
37:51
Besides the proactive outreach.
37:53
One thing that keeps me up at night,
37:55
I don't sleep at night, you know?
37:57
Spoken like a true dealer.
37:59
We don't, I literally, you know, it's funny real fast.
38:02
But you know, I send emails at like 3 a.m.,
38:03
2 a.m. all the time to my team.
38:06
And they know like to answer the morning,
38:08
But you know, I think that the biggest,
38:10
the biggest challenge is just making sure
38:12
that you got the right team in place
38:13
and you had the right leaders.
38:15
Again, you don't want to worry about your story.
38:17
I want to focus on the next one.
38:19
I don't want to have to focus on the store
38:21
and not performing the way it should be performing.
38:24
If it's, if I'm up night worrying about my stores,
38:27
that means I did a shitty job
38:29
hiring my general manager.
38:30
And that's shame on me, right?
38:31
So I think that's the major thing.
38:33
It's just, you know, that's what keeps you up night
38:35
is I'm a wrong choice, find the right leader.
38:39
And it takes a long time
38:40
to pay the consequence of that wrong choice.
38:41
All right, let's talk cars.com.
38:44
Today's episode is brought to you by cars.com,
38:47
the number one most recognized marketplace brand,
38:50
helping your dealership show up
38:52
and stand out to the most valuable car shopping audience.
38:56
We appreciate cars.com supporting today's content,
38:59
including that fascinating conversation with Jerry Raymond
39:02
as he seeks and continues to pursue the 100 rooftop.
39:06
I love his focus on culture, hiring the right person.
39:09
I've personally seen that I can vouch for it
39:11
and it'll be fun to have him back
39:13
and learn a little bit more about what he chose
39:14
as it relates to proactive service outreach, AI and all things.
39:19
So we'll definitely get him back.
39:20
So thank you, cars.com.
39:22
Appreciate you being on.
39:24
All right, next up today, we turn to our next guest,
39:26
dealer operator of Strohniter Chevrolet, Kevin Strohniter.
39:30
Welcome to the show.
39:32
Hey, how are you doing, Sam?
39:34
Kevin, did I get it?
39:36
You got it right, you got it right.
39:37
Kevin in the green room gave me tips
39:39
on pronouncing his last name, which was awesome.
39:42
So all right, first up,
39:43
we always ask the same question, Kevin.
39:46
How's biz and as part of that,
39:48
tell us a little bit about yourself,
39:49
Strohniter Chevrolet there in Hopewell, Virginia.
39:53
Yeah, so I'll actually go the reverse of that.
39:58
I'll tell you a little bit about myself.
39:59
So we are a single point Chevy dealer.
40:03
Next year we'll be celebrating 60 years.
40:05
I'm third generation owner of Strohniter Chevrolet.
40:09
My father's actually still here at the store
40:12
and I have a brother here in the business as well.
40:17
My grandfather started it 60 years ago.
40:19
So I've been very, very blessed to be in this area
40:23
and I'm blessed to be a part of the automotive industry.
40:28
That's a little bit of a background about me about us.
40:32
Business is challenging, certainly at the moment.
40:36
Challenging, it's tough to come out of a situation
40:45
where every dealer's been through this,
40:48
where it seemed like business was rolling
40:54
and we could sell cars quickly and easily
40:59
to now inventory is stacking up
41:01
and we're back to the cutting the prices
41:05
and margin compressions.
41:07
And it just makes things a little bit challenging,
41:11
I enjoy the challenge.
41:12
I enjoy the learning to overcome the daily struggles
41:20
of how do you do all the things to keep your business going
41:24
and keep everybody happy,
41:25
keep everybody employed and grow.
41:29
So you mentioned some of the challenges with growth,
41:32
all the things we mentioned even in our beginning.
41:35
You know, with the news that used vehicles
41:37
are at inventory highs, right?
41:40
Average listing prices, can you believe this?
41:43
For anybody that's been in the industry a long time,
41:45
average used car listing prices over $25,000,
41:48
$25,000 seven according to Cox
41:50
and new vehicle prices are still up there.
41:54
How are you optimizing price versus turn
41:58
You mentioned that a little bit.
41:59
Yeah, and that is difficult.
42:03
We've made the decision that most dealers,
42:06
least dealers in our area I'll say have not made,
42:09
which is we have to,
42:12
you have to look at the price point of your local market.
42:16
I've got friends their average used car prices is 40 grand.
42:21
That's their market.
42:22
I've got the average used car price in my market
42:26
is probably around 19 to 20,
42:29
20, you know, that's my market.
42:31
So I think you have to just look at your market,
42:36
what's gonna move in your local market?
42:38
I think our average at the dealership right now,
42:41
we fluctuate back and forth between 21 and 22,000.
42:45
Average cost of sales of a used car.
42:48
And so it's, you know,
42:51
we have to look at what are you likely to move
42:55
in your market to keep the doors open
43:01
and keep your salespeople selling cars
43:03
and keep your service lane open.
43:06
We made the decision several years ago,
43:08
actually kind of right at the beginning of COVID
43:10
that we're just gonna go all in on used cars
43:13
and excuse me, I apologize,
43:17
go all in and we're going to make sure
43:20
that it is the one thing,
43:23
since it's the one thing as far as sales,
43:25
it's one thing we can control.
43:27
You can't really control, to an extent,
43:31
you can control what you get from the manufacturer,
43:33
but in the most part,
43:34
you can't control what you're getting
43:37
from the manufacturer.
43:37
You have constraints,
43:39
you can only order what they want you to order,
43:42
when they want you to order those types of things,
43:43
but used cars, you have so much control,
43:46
you can fluctuate with the market.
43:49
You can get rid of them quickly
43:50
if you don't want them, those types of things.
43:53
And so we decided we're gonna go all in on used cars.
43:58
What's your best acquisition source right now?
44:01
And what's your strategy for acquiring that?
44:03
Because you mentioned your average list price
44:06
on used cars is less than the market average.
44:09
So that adds a layer of complexity to it.
44:11
Yeah, yeah, so best or our most common source,
44:17
those are the different questions.
44:22
So currently we are buying a lot from auctions.
44:29
What we have to do to keep our inventory levels
44:33
where we want them to be, it's not our best source.
44:37
Jerry mentioned this earlier,
44:38
and by the way, I took like two pages of notes
44:40
from Jerry, it was a very, very good.
44:42
I love it, he was good.
44:44
Yeah, he's really good.
44:46
But the best sources, as he said before, is always trade-ins.
44:52
And I think it's trade-ins and then it's streets purchases
44:56
and service lane if you can pick up there
44:59
and then it's auctions last.
45:02
The reality is though in the market that we're in
45:07
where you have lower car prices in our market
45:13
and the demographics kind of dictate that
45:18
in our particular market,
45:19
that means the trade-ins are less and less and less.
45:23
So we're having at the moment,
45:26
our most commonly used source is auction,
45:29
but we're having this,
45:31
are making it really, really big push
45:33
on street purchases, buying off the street
45:37
in particular Facebook marketplace.
45:39
We're gonna really hammer that this year.
45:41
My goal is to get 80% of our inventory
45:44
coming from trades and street purchases
45:48
and only 20% from auctions.
45:50
How are you gonna do that?
45:51
Cause I think there's a lot of dealers out there
45:53
that feel the way you feel.
45:55
They're like, look, I don't wanna be hostage to the auction.
45:58
I wanna get that vehicle, I wanna get at the price,
46:00
I wanna get it and I want less recon
46:02
and the path to that is trade-ins
46:05
and it's service drive and it's probably private marketplace
46:09
but getting there is another matter.
46:11
What are your steps to achieving that?
46:13
So honestly, my biggest step is find successful people
46:17
and do what they do.
46:18
And I've got some really good friends
46:21
in the industry who are doing it.
46:24
And I'm studying what they do.
46:26
Somebody here, I think you're gonna have on sometime soon,
46:32
or Bob Ruth Ford, Rob Ruth and Rob Dill,
46:35
they do an excellent job studying what they're doing,
46:40
talking with them, learning their strategies.
46:45
Good friends with people who used to run,
46:48
or used to be high up in the Dan Cummins organization
46:52
out in Kentucky, they did a lot of street purchases there.
46:55
So I'm learning, I'm studying, I'm learning
46:58
and we're just going out there and trying things.
47:00
We're just, it's really, it's about relationship.
47:04
You get out there, you get relationships
47:08
with these people, you have to be willing
47:11
to give everybody an offer.
47:13
You have to be willing to maybe stretch a little bit.
47:18
I think most people wanna, on their street purchases,
47:23
I wanna hit a home run like you do on a trade-in,
47:25
it's not gonna be that way.
47:27
Why is it not gonna be that way?
47:29
Well. I think some dealers are afraid
47:31
of going all in on street purchases,
47:33
which I don't understand
47:34
because that's the best acquisition source.
47:35
The funny part is, I've talked about this multiple times
47:39
with my management team.
47:43
The funny part is we'll go to auction
47:45
and we'll pay 90% to market for an auction car.
47:52
And then once you pay the fees
47:54
and you pay the transportation,
47:56
you get it here, you own it for 93, 94%.
47:59
Why not pay 90% for somebody from a car off the street?
48:03
And then you don't have the fees
48:04
and you don't have the transportation,
48:06
you don't have all that other stuff.
48:07
And I don't know why there's this disconnect
48:10
of we're not willing to pay up for a vehicle off the street,
48:14
but you're gonna have to be
48:16
because those people who think about it,
48:18
the person that's trading in their vehicle,
48:20
they're bringing in the vehicle to trade in,
48:22
they're bringing it to one place
48:25
or they might go to three or four dealerships at most,
48:27
but they're bringing it to one place
48:29
and getting a valuation of their vehicle.
48:32
Now they've gone on the KBB
48:33
and they've gone on the NADA,
48:36
they go on these different sites
48:38
and looked at it with a bag of their vehicle,
48:40
but you can kind of control that a little bit.
48:42
The person who is out there
48:46
putting their vehicle out for sale,
48:49
they don't like the number
48:51
that the dealer has given them on the trade in.
48:53
They don't want the number
48:54
the dealer's given them on the trade in.
48:55
So your margin is not gonna be as big,
48:58
but it's gonna be way better
49:00
than what you're getting at the auction
49:01
because you're skipping all the other fees
49:03
and all the things that you're paying to Mannheimer
49:05
to any of the other places that you're going.
49:09
And clearly, by the number of offers you see
49:12
that come into your dealership from Carvana and CarMax,
49:14
they've figured it out.
49:15
It's a game of putting an offer
49:17
on every single vehicle that comes into their sphere
49:20
and orbit and Automotive,
49:22
historically has been afraid of doing that
49:23
because you don't wanna offend the customer
49:25
with a low number because you're giving a low number,
49:29
Now your strategy is to put a number on
49:31
as much as you can, right?
49:32
Yeah, and the reality, this is the tough part too,
49:37
is as humans, we want instant gratification
49:41
and the reality is you're still gonna be seven to 10%
49:44
of the vehicles that you're putting bids on
49:49
that you're gonna actually get
49:50
and you just gotta be willing to push through it
49:53
and push through it and push through it
49:54
that, hey, I'm not gonna get nine out of the 10 cars
49:57
I put bids on, but the one I get
50:01
is gonna be better than the ones that I get at auction,
50:06
so you just keep pushing and keep pushing and keep pushing.
50:08
So as you're looking to shift from auction
50:11
to private market, service drive, and trade-ins,
50:14
is there any technology or any tools or vendors
50:17
that you're utilizing to help achieve that shift?
50:20
Yeah, a couple things, so I do use VINQ,
50:24
I use VINQ's VBC Vehicle Buying Center, use that.
50:30
I'm working currently with a man named Daryl Steed,
50:35
I don't know if you've heard of Daryl,
50:36
he's out of California, a smart wolf, smart wolf services,
50:42
I can't remember, the ending of his company name,
50:45
but Daryl is many, many years in vehicle acquisition,
50:49
so we're looking at that, we're constantly on,
50:55
I'm using KBB ICO, those types of things
51:01
for people who are looking to sell their car,
51:04
car gurus sell my car, leads, those types of things,
51:08
but really the big thing that I'm really gonna focus on
51:15
is I'm just gonna go out there
51:17
and not necessarily worry about the technology of the vendors,
51:23
the technology is there, the customer's already
51:25
using the technology, it's called Facebook Marketplace,
51:28
they're putting their cars out there,
51:30
it's called the Auditrader,
51:32
where they're already putting their cars on Auditrader
51:34
to sell their vehicle, they're doing it,
51:37
you don't need technology, you just need to actually
51:40
go out there and pay attention and contact these people.
51:43
So how are you doing that?
51:44
Are you doing it through salespeople,
51:46
through managers, do you have somebody
51:47
dedicated to it posting ads,
51:49
or what's your strategy there?
51:50
So right now I have one dedicated person
51:53
as we're learning and growing,
51:55
we have one dedicated person that he is helping us
51:58
create our processes, he's a very analytical young man,
52:01
has no business or no background
52:04
in the car business whatsoever,
52:06
I wanted somebody who didn't because somebody
52:10
who has background in the car business
52:11
could be tainted a little bit,
52:13
so I've got one person focused,
52:16
the goal is to get him into that 30 car a month range
52:22
and then add another person,
52:24
and then get that person, both of them,
52:26
into 30 cars a month, add another person,
52:29
and just little by little do add people
52:33
as we go along, it's a little bit of a slow process,
52:39
but again, like I said, the biggest thing
52:44
is spending time with people who have already
52:46
accomplished what I want to accomplish,
52:48
learning from them, and say,
52:51
hey, what are you doing here,
52:52
and building relationships where they don't mind
52:56
helping me out, so that's the biggest thing.
53:00
So transitioning away from used cars,
53:03
we wish you luck as you undertake this,
53:05
I think you're spot on, you've got to make it happen,
53:07
and it's interesting too, Jerry, super smart guy,
53:10
I love that he's as pragmatic
53:12
as he is on service drive acquisitions,
53:14
because it's a buzzword in the industry
53:15
and it's something most people just, they suck at,
53:18
they don't do well at it.
53:20
And you've got to be super deliberate to do it,
53:23
and then to his point, you can't over communicate
53:26
to a customer, you're just going to piss them off,
53:28
and that'll make it even worse.
53:31
Let's transition for a minute into FNI,
53:33
you've got a great background.
53:36
In your opinion, where does FNI create
53:37
the most customer friction in today's processes,
53:40
and how do you keep product penetration strong
53:42
without, to Jerry's point, feeling pushy,
53:45
like some dealers are on the service drive
53:47
on that used car acquisition?
53:50
So we've had an FNI growth in the past about four years,
53:59
where we, honestly, we were absolutely miserable in FNI.
54:07
What is miserable number wise?
54:10
It's almost embarrassing to say.
54:11
We were right around $800 a copy.
54:14
Yeah, yeah, recently, right?
54:16
That was about four years ago.
54:19
Yeah, which is half of Publix by far.
54:23
To right now, we fluctuate back and forth
54:28
between $2300 and $2600 a copy.
54:31
How'd you make the shift?
54:32
That's a big shift, that's a big mindset cultural shift.
54:35
So a couple of things, number one,
54:39
we had to change the mindset of our sales management team
54:47
that, hey, you're gonna get paid all in,
54:50
front and back, not just front,
54:51
you're gonna get paid all in on these vehicles,
54:53
and our goal is we are gonna set FNI up to do well.
54:59
Now, we're gonna do it in an ethical and moral way,
55:08
but we're gonna set them up.
55:09
We're gonna, we're not,
55:11
it's not the front against the back,
55:14
which is the mentality in so many dealerships.
55:18
We're not gonna do that, it's gonna be, we're a team.
55:22
Was that your mentality before that it was a competition
55:25
and everybody was kind of fighting against each other,
55:27
and that's how you ended up with that.
55:29
I don't think it was, it wasn't so much as a competition,
55:36
it was just not a collaboration, it just wasn't.
55:39
I had literally changed pay plans and said,
55:42
hey, we're gonna change,
55:43
and you're gonna, instead of being paid you on the front
55:47
and you on the back, we're gonna be paid,
55:51
you're gonna be paid on the whole kit and caboodle.
55:54
And that way you understand
55:55
that this is not just about your,
55:59
what is good for you is about what's good for the store
56:02
and what is good for this person is also good for you.
56:05
Market pressure took you to that point
56:07
where you said, I've gotta make a change.
56:09
I need to go from 800 to the two plus.
56:12
Well, obviously the compression,
56:16
the margin of compression on the front,
56:17
that's a huge piece of that.
56:21
The, I think to, I saw that my managers were,
56:33
they were, it was tough for them
56:36
because they didn't wanna take a deal
56:37
because oh, I'm losing,
56:39
I might have to lose money to take that deal.
56:41
I might have to lose a little bit on the front,
56:42
I might have to do this.
56:43
Well, what if we could make that money in the back
56:47
and you get paid on not just the front,
56:49
you get paid on the front and the back.
56:51
And then how would you feel about taking that deal
56:54
that you wouldn't take before?
56:56
Well, yeah, I feel a whole lot better about that.
56:58
Okay, so let's do that.
56:59
Let's change the way we think about this
57:01
so that we can sell more cars.
57:05
And by the way, not having a service contract
57:08
in those deals like you were getting at 800,
57:11
like that cost service business, right?
57:13
The retention alone is a,
57:15
has it made over the past four years
57:17
since you began that journey?
57:19
Has it made a measurable impact on your retention
57:21
and fixed ops revenue and growth through the...
57:24
Yeah, yeah, we've luckily,
57:26
we have been always very, very blessed in our fixed ops.
57:29
We've had a really good reputation in our community.
57:34
We've had a lot of, a whole lot of loyalty
57:38
over the years from our customers and repeat business.
57:40
So we've been very, very blessed in that area anyways,
57:43
but it certainly has made a massive boost
57:47
in our overall revenue in the service department.
57:52
And do you have a vendor or a partner
57:54
that helps you or consults with you in the FNI world?
57:57
Yeah, so I've got two in particular,
58:01
and I say two in particular,
58:04
I've got a bunch obviously,
58:06
but we work with a group out of North Carolina,
58:10
the Sterling Group, which is a Brown and Brown company.
58:15
We, and they're amazing.
58:17
Chris Carter and Tyler and his group,
58:20
they're absolutely amazing people, top-notch service.
58:23
So I throw that out there.
58:27
And then, but the guy that really,
58:30
I really got to give a ton of credit to
58:33
is a man named Saka Dyson.
58:35
Are you familiar with Saka?
58:36
Oh yeah, yep, you know, I don't know him,
58:38
but I've heard about him online.
58:39
We probably need to have him on the show.
58:41
You know, I think he's got a good strategy
58:43
as it relates to FNI and thinks well.
58:45
So Saka, that going with Saka has really,
58:51
it's really what started to really move the needle for us.
58:56
And it was, go ahead.
58:58
I was just gonna say, Kevin, go ahead,
59:00
wrap up and then we got to close here.
59:03
Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, that's fine.
59:05
The idea is with Saka, the big thing is,
59:09
it's not about product, it's about presentation,
59:12
it's about knowing your customer, loving your customer.
59:16
So there's a whole lot more I can tell you about that,
59:19
Delivering value at a high value.
59:21
Kevin Strohn-Sneider, we gotta have you back,
59:23
cause it'd be interesting to hear the rest of the story.
59:24
Dealer operator of Strohn-Sneider,
59:26
Chevrolet Enrichment Virginia,
59:27
thanks for joining the show
59:29
and sharing your perspectives today.
59:30
We appreciate you being here with us.
59:31
Thank you, appreciate it.
59:34
You know what's crazy is time goes by so quickly.
59:37
Like I lose track of it quickly.
59:39
We had such a great conversation today
59:41
between our two guests
59:42
and I'm grateful to both of them for being on today
59:45
and sharing their perspectives
59:47
on all things used car acquisition, fixed ops
59:50
and growing everything.
59:52
It has been a fun conversation today
59:55
to be sure a couple of closing comments.
59:57
Dancy says, does Kevin participate in a 20 group?
00:01
And if so, does that impact some of his decisions?
00:06
Kevin, you can put that in the show notes
00:08
if you want out there.
00:10
But we appreciate those perspectives.
00:14
Since I'm solo today,
00:15
I'm trying to find my outro thing here.
00:18
We'll get there in just a second.
00:19
I'm finding it, I'm getting there.
00:22
But we appreciate everybody that's been on.
00:23
We appreciate you, our Daily Dealer Live audience.
00:26
You will be back on Monday this weekend.
00:29
We've got the Ziggler year end holiday party.
00:32
We appreciate everybody for watching Daily Dealer Live
00:34
Monday, Wednesday, Friday, 1 PM Eastern.
00:37
If you like the show, hit subscribe, hit like,
00:40
share it with your friends,
00:42
and we'll see you back on Monday, 1 PM Eastern.
00:45
Thanks for being here, everybody.