00:00
Dealers, early access to our private dealer chat groups
00:03
Join top dealers at cdgcircles.com,
00:06
that's cdgcircles.com or hit the link in the show notes.
00:09
I'll see you inside.
00:11
Today I'm joined by Doug Gilmore,
00:12
dealer principal of Malone Ford.
00:14
After nearly two decades climbing the ranks
00:16
at Ford, Doug took the ultimate leap
00:18
buying and running a dealership.
00:20
Not only did he leave behind an impressive career,
00:22
but he bet the farm on his one shot at his ultimate dream.
00:25
A big thank you to our sponsors
00:27
for making this episode possible.
00:28
Open lane, repair 360 and cdgcircles.
00:33
And now let's get into the show.
00:39
Doug Gilmore on the cdgpodcast, Doug, welcome.
00:44
Thank you, I'm pretty sure you made a mistake.
00:47
I don't know why I'm here, but this is awesome to be here.
00:49
I did not make a mistake.
00:52
Actually, the mistake that I thought we made
00:54
was when I saw a 13 year factory guy
00:57
in the marketing department most recently, I believe,
01:02
I was like, Doug, what's going on over here?
01:03
Like, how did this happen, right?
01:05
Give me, I need the backstory.
01:07
Who did you meet while you were at Ford as a marketer?
01:09
And you're like, I need to be a dealer.
01:11
Like, what is going on over here?
01:13
How did this happen?
01:14
The best part is nobody at Ford knew
01:16
I was doing what I was doing.
01:18
So I ran everything behind the scenes
01:20
because my background was marketing, sales and service.
01:23
So I knew all the guys, right?
01:24
And I knew there'd be either a conflict of interest
01:27
or just, you know, these are all the people
01:30
that approved me are people that I know personally, right?
01:32
And I didn't want to put anybody in an awkward position.
01:34
So as I went down this path, I did it truly independently
01:38
on my own without asking for any favors.
01:41
I'm making anybody feel uncomfortable.
01:42
So when I presented an application, it was here,
01:44
here's everything, you know, you know,
01:47
sign, seal and deliver, what do you guys think?
01:49
And so it was a pretty shocking conversation
01:52
All right, so just so I understand this,
01:56
you're at Ford at the moment
01:58
and there isn't like a program, right?
02:00
Obviously there isn't like, hey,
02:02
Ford corporate, come be dealers.
02:04
So what, like, what goes through your mind?
02:07
This is a very atypical career path
02:10
to go from factory to dealer this way.
02:12
So like, what happened?
02:14
It's, well, that moment was going through your mind
02:17
as you, you know, your puckered off
02:19
because you have no idea what the response
02:21
is going to be, right?
02:22
So you're basically saying, I want to move on
02:24
and do something different.
02:27
And is there a conflict?
02:29
I didn't know Ford is going to be like, you know what?
02:31
Hey, yeah, we'll review this,
02:32
but you no longer have a job here, right?
02:34
Like that was the part that was nervous.
02:37
You know, just, you know, just made me nervous, right?
02:39
And so the initial conversations were very hard,
02:44
but the people that are at Ford were incredible.
02:46
I mean, they couldn't have been more gracious, you know,
02:49
leaders and mentors that I talked to, they were shocked.
02:52
I mean, by the second day after they submitted my application,
02:56
you know, the regional manager who also
02:57
was a good friend of mine, he was like,
02:59
Doug, they don't know what to do with you.
03:01
Like no one's done this in recent history
03:03
where they've left, you know, at Ford
03:05
where they've left the factory and bought a store.
03:07
A lot of people have left to go run stores
03:09
and go work for dealer groups.
03:11
And, you know, a lot of my friends have,
03:13
but, you know, no one had really tried
03:15
just truly buying a store while they're at Ford.
03:19
So yeah, so made for some very delicate
03:21
and interesting conversations.
03:24
So what happens behind the scenes?
03:26
Why did you do this?
03:28
Well, and so that's, you know,
03:29
and since I love you, you'll see,
03:30
because we're gonna get into all the drama
03:32
and everything else, but it's a long, you know, journey
03:35
of, you know, I'm a, you know, maybe a wanderer, right?
03:38
Like I love challenges, I love new things.
03:41
I had a stint in retail a long time ago.
03:44
I mean, not only know where to start
03:46
to kind of get you to where we're at,
03:48
but, you know, if I jumped to the end,
03:49
it was, I probably wasn't happy anymore
03:52
being like in a big bureaucratic company.
03:55
Nothing to do with Ford.
03:57
I bleed blue, but I was on that, you know,
04:00
that kind of that bureaucratic, you know, rat race, right?
04:03
I was on the wheel just spinning.
04:05
And I was good at what I did and I had an awesome career
04:07
and I can't say anything bad about Ford,
04:09
but then the day I wasn't making the kind of impact
04:11
that I wanted to make, which is interesting, right?
04:15
Because I was working on billion dollar programs
04:16
or running teams of billion dollar sales.
04:19
So the economic impacts working at the factory
04:21
just incredible, right?
04:23
But it was that bureaucratic, you know, atmosphere
04:26
and it was no longer for me.
04:28
And I didn't know it.
04:29
I was in Vermont at a cabin on a lake
04:32
and it was in the summertime
04:34
and we were doing a celebration of life
04:37
for my father after he passed away.
04:38
And this was, you know, maybe three,
04:41
three years ago, three and a half years ago.
04:43
And I was with some good friends,
04:44
friends from graded school, high school.
04:48
And aside from my father passing away,
04:50
I mean, it was a celebration of life for that.
04:52
It was expected, no surprises.
04:54
But they're like, you're not happy.
04:55
Like, let's go and we're sitting by the water.
04:56
Like, what's going on?
04:57
I was like, what are you guys talking about?
04:58
So they tell you this.
04:59
They literally tell you this to your face.
05:02
Yeah, I was like an intervention because like,
05:04
I was like, what are you guys talking about?
05:05
I was like, have an awesome career, you know,
05:06
working all at that point in time.
05:08
I was a chief product marketing manager.
05:10
So I'm working on future vehicles.
05:12
What could be more cool?
05:13
Like, you know, future EVs and stuff like that.
05:16
And they're like, you just, we can tell.
05:19
And they got in my head and I started thinking about it.
05:22
And, you know, and then one of my buddies sent me a podcast.
05:25
So I think it was from like Peter Atea,
05:28
the doctor does all the cool like, yeah.
05:32
You know, interviews with people.
05:33
He was interviewing this guy talking about,
05:35
you get stuck in this bureaucracy
05:38
and you don't even know you're stuck.
05:40
And again, I'm not, it's the right thing for a lot of people.
05:43
But for me, and I think it's just my makeup,
05:45
it was they're like, no, we see you more like building things,
05:49
you know, making an impact and things like that.
05:54
And so, and honestly, being a dealer has always been
05:58
in the back of my mind.
05:59
It's always something I joke to my friends.
06:00
When I retire from Ford, I'm going to be a dealer.
06:02
I worked with dealers for, you know, for years with Ford.
06:05
I had a lot of field jobs, right?
06:06
Had a stint, you know, running a family dealership
06:09
for a few years, turning it around.
06:11
So something I was like, I knew the dealer world.
06:15
It wasn't, you know, foreign to me or like, oh, hey,
06:16
I'm just going to go, you know, whimsy, you know,
06:19
jump into something I had no idea about.
06:22
But they're like, I think it's time.
06:24
And so, you know, fast forward a few days after I was like,
06:27
you know what, I think they're right, you know,
06:29
and they're kind of, you know, breaking that mold for me.
06:31
There was an ad from the Dave Canton group.
06:35
And I'm sure you've heard of them
06:37
and they're huge, one of the biggest, you know, M&A firms.
06:39
But Dave was, he had a dealer,
06:42
I think it was an accelerator program.
06:45
So it's basically the ad was for,
06:46
hey, if you're like a GM or something,
06:48
you've always wanted to own your own dealership,
06:51
So I picked up the phone and I called them
06:53
and I said, I'm probably not at all what you guys,
06:57
you know, are looking for.
07:00
but I've always dreamed about owning a dealership.
07:02
I was like, what do you think about that?
07:04
And the guy was completely shocked
07:06
because usually he's talking to GMs and sales managers.
07:09
And he goes, you know, most people,
07:11
he's like, my job is pretty much to screen most people
07:13
and help them understand why this probably
07:15
isn't the right move or, you know,
07:18
their ability to do something like this.
07:20
He's like, you're a different story.
07:22
And he's like, I need to have some other people call you.
07:24
And so next thing I know, I'm getting a call,
07:27
you know, from Ivan Raskin
07:28
and he's from Biltmore Consultants.
07:30
So they're like the white label firm,
07:31
M&A firm that Dave Kannon hired to manage this.
07:35
And, you know, and Ivan was like, this is fascinating.
07:37
Now he's a former like corporate guy, GE, you know,
07:41
consultant for Hyundai Kia, now he does M&A,
07:43
but his firm, and they still do it today,
07:45
they help first time dealers.
07:47
Like they're the guys that know how to do
07:50
the unique financial engineering
07:52
and know exactly what the factory is looking for.
07:54
And so I started talking to Ivan and he's like,
07:56
I think there's something here if you're willing,
07:58
basically if you're willing to go on the journey,
08:00
he's like, this is a long journey.
08:01
And I was like, I know.
08:02
And that's the thing, like I had approved a lot of myself
08:05
on the other side of the fence.
08:07
I've been through them, I've helped dealers go through them.
08:09
You know, and if anything, I probably realized, you know,
08:13
I realized I knew enough about it to realize
08:15
if I ever wanted to buy a dealership, I would need help.
08:17
You know, I think a lot of people the first time you're like,
08:19
no, I can do this, I can figure it out.
08:23
And it's complicated for someone who knows a lot about it.
08:25
And a lot of that complications
08:26
is just managing all the resources, you know,
08:29
from the right accountants, the right lawyers,
08:32
you know, the right insurance agents on, you know,
08:36
how do you set up, you know, an SBA loan,
08:38
the right banks, right?
08:40
So you went SBA route?
08:42
I went the SBA route, yeah, Connor Duncan from Live Oak.
08:46
Now granted, like again, this is why it's good
08:47
to have intelligent people on your team.
08:50
People much smarter than me is that
08:51
I wouldn't have known to reach out to Connor,
08:53
but Ivan had already had a relationship with Connor.
08:56
He knew it would be a good fit for Connor.
08:57
So we reached out to Connor Duncan at Live Oak
08:59
and put me in touch with him and helped me set up
09:01
with an SBA loan, which was way more financing
09:04
that I thought I'd be eligible for.
09:05
But again, why smart to just bring in people
09:07
that know a lot more than you think, you know.
09:11
So a couple of questions there.
09:13
First of all, you were working at the factory,
09:16
you purchased the four dealership,
09:18
clearly some testament to the durability of the brand,
09:22
your belief in the brand.
09:23
What is it that led you to believe in the future
09:27
of the brand to put your own money, you know,
09:29
to put your name in SBA loan
09:31
typically requires a personal guarantee, right?
09:34
So that's a very strong belief in the brand.
09:38
Why did you come out of there
09:40
and like what led you to have that strong belief
09:43
Cause you could have gone for any brand technically, so.
09:46
I mean, the good and bad about an SBA loan
09:47
is that you can stretch the loan over 20 years.
09:49
So, I mean, my conviction is really out there
09:52
on the far horizon.
09:54
So I can't ever get into like, you know,
09:57
what I'd know about like future products,
09:58
but I worked on future products, right?
10:00
Like I could see the vision behind the scenes
10:03
of what Jim Farley's taken to the board of directors
10:05
and, you know, people like Jim Bombeck
10:08
and what they want for the company, you know,
10:10
what they're trying to plan five and two,
10:11
I believe in it, right?
10:12
You know, I grew up with Ford,
10:15
I've had family in Ford, my uncle worked for Ford.
10:17
So I do believe blue and it's not that I'm at all opposed
10:20
to, you know, acquiring another franchise,
10:22
but I was very clear to Bill Moore and Ivan's like,
10:25
hey, I'm going to buy a dealership
10:26
because they had other stores for me.
10:28
They're like, hey, we can get you in a store today.
10:30
I said, no, if I'm doing this as Ford is for me.
10:34
And again, and it's, you know,
10:35
sometimes that's the irrational part of it, right?
10:37
Like, so there was an irrational part for me.
10:39
I was like, no, I'm going to, I'm doing it with Ford.
10:42
But I do believe in the company.
10:43
I believe they've got the right products, the right lineup.
10:46
You know, they've got the right leadership
10:48
and beyond somebody like a Jim Friley,
10:49
like the next tier leadership is awesome at Ford
10:51
and Andrew Frick or Jim Bombeck.
10:53
I mean, these guys are incredible in the depth
10:55
that they have and what they bring in their, you know,
10:58
their years within the auto industries.
11:00
This episode is brought to you by Open Lane,
11:02
recently voted the most preferred digital wholesale
11:05
marketplace by dealers.
11:06
They've been busy using the power of people and AI
11:09
to build a more confident wholesale experience.
11:12
Open Lane condition reports now feature AI powered
11:15
and inspector confirmed exterior damage detection,
11:18
high quality engine audio recordings
11:20
and OBD two codes decoded into plain English.
11:23
If you've never used Open Lane before
11:25
or it's been a while since you have,
11:27
you're eligible to earn up to $2,500 in buy
11:30
or sale fee credits.
11:32
Learn more at openlane.com slash CDG
11:34
or click the link in the show notes below.
11:36
I think that question is especially important
11:38
given the fact that you worked at,
11:40
I saw on lots of EV marketing
11:43
and that was a pretty, you know,
11:45
tumultuous time for Ford EVs, right?
11:48
Things have gotten better and the market has changed
11:51
and shifted and credits have gone away.
11:53
And so I would say in some sense it's more stable now,
11:56
but again, you were working at Ford during this time
11:59
on, you know, EV marketing and it's just surprising to me
12:05
or it's, I mean, wow, to go from there,
12:07
I see you're smiling.
12:08
I mean, it's to go from there to acquire a Ford dealership.
12:12
It says something at least in your long-term, you know,
12:15
So a lot of my history with Ford too,
12:18
but I mean, outside of like the product side, right?
12:21
Was being in the field, right?
12:23
I've been a marketing manager in the field.
12:25
I used to be the business development manager
12:27
for Quicklane in the central market area,
12:29
which is like Texas and Oklahoma going around,
12:32
helping dealers set them up and operate them.
12:34
You know, going to FDF meetings on the marketing side,
12:36
talking to dealers about,
12:38
hey, what are we gonna do for tier two advertising?
12:40
All the way up to, you know,
12:42
eventually as a regional manager in the Northeast,
12:44
you know, overseeing 130 dealers,
12:46
you know, helping them grow,
12:47
working on their allocation, their service growth,
12:50
their customer satisfaction.
12:52
So I spent a lot of time in the field working with dealers.
12:55
And the funny thing was is I always looked back
12:58
and I was so much working, I always found it fascinating.
13:00
Like I wasn't going,
13:01
I was the kind of regional guy going,
13:03
tell the deal, hey, this is how you're gonna run your business.
13:05
I mean, I just wanted to go in and just talk to people.
13:07
I mean, I just love learning from these dealers
13:11
And if I could give them a nugget of wisdom,
13:13
and it usually wasn't something that I was smarter than them.
13:15
I was like, hey, I've seen a few other stores
13:17
trying this, this, and this,
13:18
because I could bring that,
13:19
almost that 20 group worldliness a little bit to them.
13:22
And they're like, hey, yeah, I hadn't thought of that,
13:23
but let me go check it out, right?
13:25
But it was learning.
13:26
Like you had Fred beans on once, right?
13:29
So I used to call him Fred.
13:32
And I love seeing Fred.
13:34
Every time I would see him,
13:35
it was so educational.
13:37
And I just love going to see Fred to sit down
13:39
and like take somebody like that,
13:41
that should know everything, right?
13:44
He's been doing it for, I don't know, Fred's in his mid 80s.
13:47
He's been doing it since the 50s,
13:49
started out with a gas station
13:50
and now he's got whatever, 30 stores
13:52
and one of the biggest parts guys in the country.
13:55
And he's so, to this day, he's still curious, right?
13:58
Like he's still learning about the business.
14:01
And I'm in there, he's shown me all his books on Audible
14:04
that he's reading as he's driving around
14:05
and he's used to escape, right?
14:07
But he's learning and he's sharing my nuggets.
14:10
And after I bought this store,
14:12
like I didn't know I had all this excess,
14:14
used in parts inventory, obsolete inventory.
14:18
And like, I'm just going to offload this now
14:19
and take the bite up front
14:20
so I can free up the space for my parts team
14:23
and just start clean.
14:24
But I couldn't get off of $50,000 of this whole person.
14:27
So I was like, you know what?
14:28
I'm going to give Fred a call.
14:29
I haven't talked to him in three years.
14:30
He probably doesn't even know, remember who I am.
14:32
I called him like at five o'clock at night.
14:34
He picked up like on the second ring.
14:36
He's like, Doug, how you doing?
14:37
I was like, oh my gosh.
14:38
He goes, I'm in a board meeting right now
14:39
with my, you know, wholesale distribution team.
14:42
But yeah, I saw you calling.
14:44
I was like, well, I was like,
14:45
I'm so sorry to interrupt you Fred.
14:46
No, what do you got?
14:46
I just bought a dealership.
14:48
And he's like, and I'm like, he was like, really?
14:50
And I start talking about what I'm doing.
14:52
I was like, I'm stuck on this obsolete inventory.
14:54
But I, I forget I just asked you if you knew anybody
14:56
I should call or how I should handle it.
14:58
He goes, I'm sending you over, you know,
15:00
I'm going to have the head of my, you know,
15:01
parts distribution center give you a call
15:03
and then we'll see what we can do.
15:05
And then he starts talking to me.
15:06
I was like, hey, how about your sales process?
15:08
I don't really have a sales process yet.
15:09
Fred, I just bought this store.
15:10
He goes, I'm going to send you over my sales process.
15:12
And he goes, what do you think about, you know,
15:15
you know, you know, single price, you know,
15:17
one vehicle price and all this other stuff.
15:20
I think we're still negotiating.
15:21
He goes, I'm still negotiating too.
15:22
He goes, I don't like one price.
15:24
He goes, Doug, I don't like one price, you know,
15:26
because it's not the right price for every customer.
15:27
I mean, he's just thoughtful and energetic,
15:30
but it's something that I learned from all dealers, right?
15:33
Like it's, because I've met a lot of dealers that, you know,
15:36
within two seconds are just telling you,
15:37
they know how it is, right?
15:40
A lot of those guys, I don't know,
15:41
he's the guys that have grown.
15:43
And the lifelong learner.
15:45
That was definitely the impression I got.
15:48
I had of him, you know, after he was on my podcast
15:50
and, you know, I've known of Fred for,
15:52
I grew up in this area near Fred,
15:53
near the Doyle's town and, you know, area.
15:56
But Fred is just such an incredible operator
16:00
and the enthusiasm, like you said,
16:03
the attention to detail.
16:04
It's very, very just incredible to watch from the side.
16:09
I got to ask you, and I want to talk more about your entry,
16:13
like you said, your kind of first initial days, months,
16:16
or weeks, months in the dealership,
16:18
but from your vantage point now,
16:20
you've been a dealer now for several years
16:23
and what is the factory getting wrong?
16:26
I bring on dealers all the time here and I ask them,
16:28
I say, hey, like, what would you do differently
16:30
or how do you operate with the factory?
16:32
But I don't really bring on many factory guys
16:34
or former factory guys in your case and say,
16:36
you know, what would you like the dealers
16:38
to do differently and why?
16:39
So you've seen both sides now at length.
16:43
And so what does the factory not understand
16:46
about dealers or dealerships?
16:48
What do you think, if anything?
16:50
The first one, and they've now fixed it,
16:52
was the importance of like a good field team, you know?
16:56
And, you know, during COVID, a little before that,
16:59
and this was a prior regime, you know, different leadership,
17:01
they cut way back, you know,
17:03
on the reps that call them the stores, right?
17:05
They cut them back and put more dealers
17:07
in the call centers and whatnot.
17:09
And then, you know, the few reps that were left
17:10
just had so many stores, you know,
17:14
and Ford sales and shares started falling, right?
17:16
And customer sat fell off.
17:18
And, you know, and dealers were frustrated
17:20
because they didn't have, you know,
17:21
the help they needed when something's going on
17:23
with the customer or the vehicle they're looking for
17:26
or something in service or parts, right?
17:29
And I feel like the OEMs or the best field teams
17:32
are the ones that kill it, right?
17:33
And Ford had that for years.
17:35
I mean, I think I was always so proud.
17:36
I felt like Ford had one of the best field teams,
17:38
the best partnerships with dealers.
17:40
I would see, you know, like,
17:42
I would be in dealer council meetings
17:44
when I was a regional manager
17:45
and Andrew Frick would be leading them.
17:47
And he is a dealer partner through and through.
17:49
And it was, if the, you know,
17:51
we had a rational conversation
17:53
and things that we were going in that management of us
17:55
to say, hey, you know what,
17:56
this is probably not gonna happen
17:57
or in the budget or whatever.
17:59
But we found a rational way talking about it
18:02
Andrew would take it back and be like, no, we'll find a way.
18:04
You know, like a true partner of the dealers.
18:06
Then I felt like we've lost that for a little while.
18:08
And now Ford is getting it back, right?
18:10
They built up the field team.
18:12
You've got people like Rob Caffle, head of sales.
18:14
I mean, he is a dealer guy through and through.
18:19
When you say a good field team, how do you define that?
18:22
Like, because a lot of factory people
18:23
do listen to this podcast
18:26
and a lot of dealers complain about the manufacturer
18:28
and listen, dealers aren't perfect.
18:30
Manufacturers are not perfect.
18:31
It's at both sides, it's, you know, it's flaws.
18:33
But what's a good field team?
18:36
Like, what's your definition of that?
18:37
For any factory person listening, that might be curious.
18:40
It's the support and a lot of it,
18:42
it's not the individuals, right?
18:43
There's always great individuals in the field,
18:45
but do they have the resources to help the dealers, right?
18:48
And when the field team is, you know,
18:50
they're cut of their resources,
18:51
they have no budgets for customer sat.
18:54
Or again, one rep has, you know, 20 plus dealers
18:57
that the poor young man or woman's got a call on, right?
19:01
Straight out of college, right?
19:02
Or they've cut back on their training.
19:04
You know, it's hard for them to provide value.
19:06
But then when you get, you know, right now,
19:08
like my rep maybe has, my sales rep might have 10 or 12 stores.
19:12
I've got a service rep, you know, the same thing.
19:14
They're learning the business, but they're there to help, right?
19:16
So we got a question and I push this on my team every day.
19:20
I was like, have you reached out to your rep yet?
19:22
You know, we call those sales rep and you call them
19:24
and they might not have the answer.
19:25
But what it is is they got the resources
19:27
to get the answer to help you out.
19:30
Yeah, I mean, it's, you know,
19:31
and some of the ones that are consistent like Toyota,
19:34
I always, I'm so jealous, right?
19:35
But I always hear Toyota, like the Toyota factory
19:38
and that partnership with the dealers is just fantastic, right?
19:41
It's less about forcing programs on the dealer
19:43
and more about how do we partner together
19:45
and just, you know, you know, get rid of the roadblocks
19:48
and just help make the customers happy.
19:50
And Ford is back there.
19:51
So, I mean, Ford did the full U-turn on that,
19:54
which is awesome because that's always...
19:56
Yeah, and I'm not asking this question exclusive to Ford.
20:00
I think a lot of it will be from the Ford perspective
20:03
because you were there, but I think in general.
20:05
Okay, so putting the field team aside, that's one thing.
20:08
I believe you said you had another thing.
20:10
What else comes to mind as like a misunderstanding?
20:13
So, what you misunderstand is the consistency with products
20:16
and how important it is to dealers, right?
20:19
And the EVs is the most glaring example of that, right?
20:23
Like, there's a lot of ICE vehicles, not just Ford, right?
20:26
And you can name pretty much most manufacturers
20:28
where all these vehicles are getting, you know, chopped
20:31
from the cycle plan because they've got all these EVs coming.
20:35
Well, now the EVs aren't coming, you know,
20:37
and all of a sudden the cycle plan and your portfolio
20:39
is starting to look a little weak
20:41
on what you've got to offer for customers.
20:43
But for a dealer, a dealer needs a full family of vehicles
20:46
to offer for a customer, right?
20:48
And you can't pick and choose because you start
20:51
If you're picking and choosing, you're like,
20:52
well, these are truly our highest margin vehicles.
20:54
Well, that might work in California or Michigan,
20:57
but does it work in Florida or Minnesota?
21:00
You need a full diverse set of vehicles
21:01
because certain ones are gonna sell better
21:03
in different parts of the market, you know?
21:05
And so, and again, now Ford's focused on vehicles.
21:08
I mean, I think, you know, I've heard a lot from friends
21:11
that have Stalanta stores, right?
21:12
Like they came up real short on a lot of vehicles for a while.
21:15
Now they're leaning back into like Tim Kaniscus,
21:18
I mean, which is awesome.
21:19
I mean, but just to think how far Jeep and Ram fell off,
21:22
I mean, those are iconic brands.
21:24
Like how could they fall when they did?
21:26
I mean, it's good for me and my local market,
21:29
but I mean, in general, I love the auto industry,
21:31
so I'd love to see great brands succeed.
21:34
What was your perception on foreign vehicles
21:38
or potential, I know Chinese vehicles is a bit further out,
21:42
but when you were at Ford and moving them to buy a Ford store,
21:48
did disruption go through your mind, right?
21:51
Like will Ford be here for another two decades?
21:55
Like what kind of thoughts went through your mind?
21:57
And do these existential thoughts cross your mind?
22:00
Because I'm genuinely curious, you know?
22:02
Like the EV program has cost a lot of money for Ford.
22:05
They've invested billions and billions and billions.
22:08
You know, they've gotten a lot of flak for that,
22:11
for better or worse, that's just a reality.
22:13
And so does just the staying power of the brand,
22:17
I know I asked you in the beginning, you know,
22:18
why so much, why go after a Ford store and you answered that,
22:21
but I'm still trying to understand if being in the factory
22:26
and seeing potential existential threats,
22:28
you know, other brands rising,
22:31
if that went through your mind as something to be,
22:34
you know, of concern in the near term.
22:37
Without, all right, so maybe this will help frame my answer too.
22:40
So for someone like me who's worked in the factory, right,
22:43
had a great career, which is, you know,
22:45
and I nothing can say bad about it,
22:46
but I'm not making, you know, dealer money, right?
22:50
Where I'm just going to go buy a store, right?
22:52
So for me to buy a store.
22:53
I'm not making dealer money.
22:54
I gotta make a shirt, I gotta make a shirt
22:58
and give it to people like on the pod.
22:59
I'm not making dealer money.
23:03
Cause as you know, you'll see to buy a store,
23:06
I mean, even a small store is expensive.
23:08
And especially when the factory says, you know,
23:10
we want to see, you know, 50-50 debt to equity ratio, right?
23:13
Like, so you just got to show,
23:15
you got to show the money in your bank account.
23:16
Yeah, I got a huge SBA loan,
23:18
but I still had to show 50% of that as equity, right?
23:21
And for me to come up with that kind of equity meant
23:23
leveraging everything, right?
23:25
Like, like, I think this is funny to say,
23:26
because my dad was a no kidding cattle dealer.
23:29
Like, I bet the farm.
23:30
Like I leveraged our house by, you know, 401K,
23:34
the kids college funds.
23:35
I took a HELOC credit card debt, everything, knowing thou.
23:40
I was going to have 30 to 60 days of once I made my decision,
23:43
you know, to leave for to do this,
23:45
that everything's bet and then is a slim margin of error
23:49
to start paying it off, right?
23:51
Like, does that debt accelerate fast enough
23:54
that I don't make it in the first, you know, couple months?
23:58
So not like, so this is what's going through my head
24:00
as I'm thinking about, is this the right bet to make, right?
24:04
And so it's one of those things that,
24:06
so I bet the farm, I rolled the dice.
24:08
And but part of that is, is, yeah,
24:10
I was looking kind of out of the future.
24:12
And Ford is one of those brands that's going to survive.
24:15
It gets a lot of, so this is part of it is,
24:19
and this is controversial.
24:21
I mean, because there's going to be a lot of, you know,
24:22
probably you pie the analysts from Wall Street listen
24:24
and who knows, but the Ford family still has
24:27
a tremendous amount of control and influence at the company.
24:31
A lot of people do not like that.
24:32
I think it's a good thing
24:33
because it gives it that long-term vision.
24:36
They're willing to make hard decisions for the future
24:40
to endure and they're willing to make decisions
24:42
that not only just impact the bottom line,
24:45
but also decisions that impact, you know,
24:48
the employees, the communities, the country, the world, right?
24:51
I mean, it's incredible to kind of see that, you know,
24:56
when you put it together and you hear something
24:57
like a Bill Ford talk or an Elena Ford
24:59
to see their passion for the dealers,
25:01
see their passion for the communities,
25:02
not only for dealers, but, you know,
25:04
where the factories are located,
25:06
the importance of having a manufacturing base
25:08
in the United States, you know, for our own, you know,
25:11
you know, economic security, right?
25:13
You know, and so not only with things like that,
25:17
but then it gives that long-term vision is, you know,
25:20
we're gonna have great products in the future.
25:23
I mean, because that's what we are, right?
25:24
And usually Ford, whenever Ford makes some mistakes
25:27
and they're backs against the wall, they always bounce back.
25:30
I mean, and it's been shown over and over again,
25:32
even in recent history.
25:34
And so, yeah, I think there's other, without a doubt,
25:36
because I mean, one of my jobs in product marketing
25:39
was studying all these brands, especially China.
25:41
I mean, I was working on products for China
25:43
with our China team.
25:44
So I was up, you know, late at night and early in the morning
25:47
just to deal with the time changes.
25:49
There's incredible, incredible, you know,
25:52
car companies in China, just with their tech
25:54
and what they're doing.
25:57
But, you know, some of the questions are,
25:58
and it's hard to see the full transparency.
26:00
Are they all profitable?
26:01
I mean, like, there's a lot of SEO, you know,
26:04
kind of going into that, you know, state-owned,
26:07
you know, financing going into that,
26:09
where, you know, are they there yet, right?
26:13
So it was great tech.
26:14
Is it gonna work everywhere?
26:15
You know, a lot of them have already gone under,
26:18
a lot have survived, a lot are incredible,
26:20
like BYD, which is, you know, a very cool company.
26:24
And honestly, just brings, we need that competition, right?
26:28
You know, like, if Ford was the only brand,
26:30
I mean, the products would be boring, right?
26:33
Like, so to me, it's good competition.
26:35
We don't have that competition though,
26:36
but we don't have any, you know?
26:38
No, we absolutely don't, that's why,
26:40
but I think having that globally,
26:42
we will at some point, I don't know when,
26:44
but I don't know how long you can kind of keep out
26:47
global brands like that, because they're global,
26:49
they're in Europe, they're in South America.
26:51
So Jim Farley has said he drives, you know,
26:54
a Chinese brand vehicle.
26:55
I forget which one specifically, you probably know,
26:57
but he said, you know, it's just phenomenal.
27:00
He said he hasn't seen anything like this,
27:01
or not to quote him, he tweeted this, I believe,
27:04
but it's something super impressive at, you know,
27:06
half the price point.
27:09
You're right, we don't know the economics of it.
27:12
It is state-funded to a certain extent,
27:15
and maybe they don't need to be profitable.
27:18
Maybe this begs into a larger, you know,
27:20
a different type of vision to where profitability
27:22
is just not the goal.
27:25
And so, you know, I don't think that's like,
27:28
I don't think it's a strong,
27:30
or it's just, we couldn't rely on that
27:33
because you just, you can have companies out there
27:36
that will just not be profitable for decades
27:38
just to, you know, win the market share
27:40
as the Chinese brands have done.
27:42
If you go to, you know, Europe,
27:44
and you go to certain countries in Asia,
27:47
I mean, it's just, you know, I don't want to say Africa,
27:49
which I haven't been, but I've heard, South America,
27:52
I mean, you see these things everywhere.
27:54
So it's pretty incredible.
27:57
I mean, you know, we were so fearful
28:00
of new brands coming in, right?
28:02
But I mean, think of like, you know, the Koreans, you know,
28:06
like, and it's a little before my time,
28:07
but you think of when Hyundai Kia first
28:09
were coming to the US, I mean, and it, you know,
28:11
it looked like, you know, funny looking Mercedes
28:14
or whatever, look at them now.
28:16
Incredible, gorgeous, you know, world-class products.
28:19
I mean, but it's just driving us all to be better.
28:21
I mean, so things like that are coming.
28:24
I mean, it's, it's whether it's a year,
28:26
five years or 10 years.
28:28
I thought about this actually, what you just said,
28:29
and I'm probably going to butcher this
28:32
so someone is going to, someone who's just smarter
28:34
and while research right now is going to, you know,
28:36
listen to this and do some researching.
28:38
But when I think about how these brands
28:41
were able to enter the US, you know,
28:43
penetrate the markets and other brands have,
28:46
and the domestic brands flourished alongside them over time.
28:49
And again, they're bumps along the road.
28:51
I think of a couple of things, right?
28:53
Which is without seeing the numbers,
28:55
like immigration was under rise significantly, right?
28:59
And like, say up to the, I don't know,
29:02
I'm not even, I'm not even going beyond the year 2000,
29:05
but let's just go up to the year 2000.
29:07
So you had rising immigration, so more, more, you know,
29:10
more people, you also had a net positive birth rates
29:17
not that you don't have today, but last I saw,
29:20
I want to say on X was like birth rates
29:23
have been, you know, plummeted significantly
29:24
over the last two decades.
29:27
And so that of course results in reduced demand
29:31
and it takes time, but I'm just,
29:32
I'm just kind of putting these pieces together
29:34
and I was saying like is vehicle demand going to rise
29:37
or is it going to decline?
29:39
And how that is, how is that as a factor
29:41
going to impact these manufacturers in the future
29:45
and the ability for additional manufacturers?
29:47
Okay, so that's kind of the human macro side.
29:50
Then there's the other side, which is just technologically,
29:55
If these things get so fricking advanced
29:56
and they need, you need such crazy budgets to, for R&D,
30:00
which means you also need to model them out
30:03
at greater numbers, greater volumes,
30:06
you're going to have to see consolidation, right?
30:09
Because in the past, maybe to build a vehicle
30:12
was less expensive or maybe not less expensive,
30:14
but required less research and development
30:15
or maybe that research and development did not need to be,
30:18
you know, reinvested so at such a high clip
30:21
every single year, then your overall operating model,
30:25
I would assume you just did not need to sell
30:26
as many cars to be profitable,
30:28
but now as those inputs have changed,
30:31
you need to sell higher volumes as we've seen with EVs.
30:34
We haven't even gotten close to them,
30:37
which all roads lead to consolidation.
30:40
So it's like, again, this is like super napkin math.
30:43
This is dealer math, right?
30:44
This is totally dealer math.
30:46
This is not Wall Street math, so excuse me, Wall Street,
30:48
but I just say like, I just, you know,
30:51
it's going to get tougher for the manufacturers.
30:53
If you could look at just macro,
30:56
you look at the, you know, population figures
30:58
or, you know, just consumption and you think about technology
31:02
and the needs or requirements from a brand
31:05
in terms of, you know, how much they can invest.
31:07
So I hope you enjoyed my dealer math there.
31:10
It is awesome dealer math.
31:11
It is fascinating to watch because some, you know,
31:13
especially when you talk consolidations,
31:15
like think of how, think of all the stories
31:17
where you see these big consolidations
31:18
and then you see these nasty breakups, right?
31:21
Like you were really set up.
31:23
I mean, Marchione did an amazing job.
31:25
You know, when it was, what he was doing with Stellantis,
31:29
right, before he passed away.
31:30
But now they're struggling,
31:31
but maybe they're going to figure it out again, right?
31:33
You know, or the, you know, the Nissan Reno,
31:36
like think about like how that fell apart.
31:38
But, you know, even Ford, I mean,
31:40
Ford is a poster child for it, right?
31:41
Like Ford consolidated, I mean, I forgot how many brands
31:44
they had, Volvo, Land Rover, Jaguar, right?
31:47
You know, Lincoln, Mercury, I know I'm forgetting something,
31:51
but, oh, Aston Martin of all vehicles, right?
31:54
They had all these, and then it wasn't working.
31:56
And then Al Malawi chopped them all
31:58
and all of a sudden Ford started doing better again.
32:00
Like, so it's fascinating.
32:02
Cause you're right, the economics say
32:04
there should be consolidation.
32:06
It's just, it has worked.
32:08
You have pulled it off Toyota hasn't consolidated
32:12
I mean, no one's even close to them.
32:14
I don't know, they made, what, $30 billion?
32:16
Sold the most cars of anybody.
32:17
And they're, you know, their market cap
32:19
is a fraction of what Tessels is, but they kill it.
32:22
This episode was brought to you by Repair360.
32:25
If you're in the used car business,
32:27
you know waste to time is wasted money.
32:29
Check out Repair360, the first and only
32:31
reconditioning software that connects every function
32:34
in the dealership to tighten Recon
32:35
and help you sell more cars.
32:37
No more hounding vendors.
32:39
Goodbye, endless texts and hallway chases.
32:42
Repair360 connects all the dots.
32:44
See where every car is and what its Recon
32:46
is costing minute to minute in real time.
32:48
Go to Repair360.com or click the link
32:51
in the show notes below.
32:53
Doug, what do you think you are a marketer for Lincoln?
32:56
Most recently, what do you think about Lincoln,
32:58
the future of Lincoln?
33:00
So I don't know the few, like I was working on future EVs
33:03
and that they've obviously changed course
33:04
since I was there, right?
33:06
I love the products that are out today.
33:08
I mean, you look at a navigator, you look at an aviator,
33:11
the new Nautilus want a tremendous amount of awards.
33:13
So I mean, we've got, you know, gorgeous products.
33:15
I'm just hoping the factory stays behind it, right?
33:18
They just need their resources.
33:20
They've got awesome dealers.
33:22
They've got great products.
33:23
They just need more products, you know?
33:25
And I hear that from Lincoln dealers like,
33:27
hey, we've got great products,
33:28
but there's four, give us a few more, you know?
33:30
And I get that now.
33:32
Now that I'm on the Ford side, I'm like,
33:34
yeah, I'd like a little bit more product diversity too.
33:36
So I totally get where they're coming from.
33:38
So they've got great products.
33:40
I'm just, you know, and I believe they will.
33:42
I just hope they get the vehicles to the dealers in time,
33:45
like the new products and new generations
33:46
over the next couple of years.
33:48
Is that your concern?
33:50
Yeah, it is because when you live in the product world,
33:53
everything takes so long.
33:55
It's not like, oh, well, the EVs are away.
33:57
Let's just come out with a new, you know,
34:00
flux capacitor for whatever.
34:01
It's like, it's like a five-year product plan, right?
34:03
It's the design, it's the engineering.
34:04
It's in the timeline, the lead time,
34:07
and it's for everybody, does take forever.
34:10
I mean, Tesla Braggs, but they're just updating software.
34:12
But if you're updating sheet metal and design
34:15
and platforms, you know, it's,
34:17
you need that time to do it right.
34:19
You need the design, the research
34:21
to make sure the customers are gonna love it.
34:22
You're forecasting out something
34:24
that's gonna look beautiful and sexy
34:26
and exciting in three to six years.
34:29
It is complicated, but that's how so many manufacturers
34:33
get it right and have awesome products on the road today.
34:36
But do you think there's something,
34:38
like there's, it seems like we have this tale of two worlds
34:42
where you have the Teslas,
34:44
you have very few SKUs, relatively speaking, right?
34:47
Like, couple models, a couple colors.
34:51
There's just not that many variations
34:52
of purchase in that vehicle.
34:54
And then on the other hand, you have other brands,
34:57
such as Ford, where you have, you know,
34:59
all these different variations, all these different colors.
35:01
Do you think it needs to be that way?
35:04
Like, could Ford go more Tesla with fewer models,
35:07
fewer variations, streamline the supply chain,
35:10
make it easier to get product into people's hands, right?
35:13
Likely also reduce costs along the way
35:15
because your supply chain is, you know, a bit simpler.
35:17
I know you're not like some,
35:19
you weren't like the head of supply chain or anything,
35:21
but you were a marketer
35:22
and you did have to control product and timing.
35:25
Is there a world where we see
35:26
that kind of stuff, the more simplicity?
35:28
It was like a former marketer, right?
35:30
Like, and as an owner of a dealership now,
35:32
which I think makes me just a customer advocate,
35:35
I truly believe customers want choice.
35:37
Could be paint colors, could be interior colors.
35:39
It could be options, you know, moon roofs, you know,
35:43
massaging seats, you know, with your luxury customer,
35:45
cloth seats versus leather, you know,
35:49
22 inch wheels versus 18s.
35:52
And like, all at the end of the day,
35:54
look at, there's so many aftermarket companies
35:57
that retrofit Teslas that put leather interiors in
36:01
or put packages on the outside
36:04
that make them look modified
36:05
and different than what their neighbors have.
36:07
You know, at the end of the day, customers do want choice.
36:10
And so I think customers,
36:11
what I believe I speculate and my hypothesis would be
36:14
is that customers are making a sacrifice for Tesla.
36:16
Cause what Tesla does have is they have awesome technology.
36:20
And they got an awesome brand that Elon Musk has created.
36:24
That brand is volatile, but it's still awesome, right?
36:27
You know, and that's the speculation
36:28
that's driving the stock price so high too, right?
36:30
Like, so people are buying into the brand,
36:32
they're buying into the tech
36:33
and they're willing to make a sacrifice.
36:34
So it's like, I want a black Tesla with, you know,
36:37
or the black and cloth vegan interior
36:41
because, you know, it doesn't match my Birkenbeck,
36:44
but you know, right now I want an EV and I, you know,
36:47
and I want to be, well, now it's changing
36:50
based on politics, right?
36:51
But pre-politics, right?
36:54
Everybody just want to be part of the Elon crowd, right?
36:56
That was a very, you know, forward thinking,
36:59
tech forward type of crowd.
37:01
Now it's a different crowd,
37:01
but it's still brand-based, which is fascinating.
37:04
I agree with you that consumers make a sacrifice
37:08
when, you know, let's say that you buy a Tesla
37:11
or I should say differently,
37:12
you make a sacrifice in certain elements.
37:15
I think that there is a price or value associated
37:18
with choice and I think the danger for an OEM
37:22
is to be stuck in the messy middle, right?
37:25
If you maybe remove a couple options,
37:26
but not enough to create,
37:29
or you're not creating some other value alongside, right?
37:32
Maybe the vehicle is inexpensive enough
37:34
or cheap enough to where it's affordable or whatever maybe.
37:38
I do believe that it's at least worth exploring, you know,
37:42
where, what is of most value
37:45
and where can we maybe streamline to get costs down?
37:48
Because I really think affordability
37:49
is going to continue being the biggest challenge here.
37:52
We haven't seen a massive decline in prices
37:58
in the last couple of years.
38:00
And yes, prices have somewhat come down,
38:03
but average transaction prices, you know,
38:05
if you look at new vehicles have stayed very much elevated
38:09
in that we've now, you know, done away with the EV tax credits,
38:11
used cars are in no better shape.
38:13
They've come down, prices have come down
38:15
and used to like the mid-20s,
38:16
but you've also, you have a lot less supply.
38:20
So, you know, I just, I think about these things.
38:23
I try to go to like the source and say, you know,
38:25
is there a different way?
38:27
And I want to be very clear.
38:28
Like I'm coming to this with like full humility.
38:30
Like there's people that spend days, weeks, years on this stuff.
38:33
I'm just over here, you know, yapping away, giving my thoughts.
38:38
But, you know, I'm one consumer.
38:40
So I have an opinion and I welcome anyone
38:43
that's listening who's way more experienced in this
38:45
and deals with it on a daily basis,
38:47
maybe at the manufacturer to hit me up and give me their take.
38:51
No, you're absolutely right.
38:52
You'll see in these whole teams at the factory,
38:53
like I would spend hours with teams of engineers and finance
38:57
and everybody and how we can reduce costs, right?
39:00
And as a marketer, usually the counterpoint to those questions.
39:04
The interesting before I left, I remember I was like,
39:06
we had removed it, like Explorer was one of the vehicles.
39:08
We removed a ton of content and a ton of configurations.
39:12
But then they couldn't quantify, we were, we were,
39:15
we couldn't quantify the savings.
39:16
They're like, is it really saving us money at the factory?
39:19
Right. Some things clearly do, right?
39:20
Like if you can remove certain lines at a factory
39:22
and increase efficiency.
39:24
And then to your point, it's like the value.
39:26
It's like there are certain items that do have big value
39:28
and other ones that don't.
39:29
Like is really going from 12 paint colors to 10 paint colors
39:32
going to save that much money.
39:33
And I guess it depends how many paint colors
39:35
the line set up to manage, right?
39:38
It's all of an interesting dealer now.
39:41
Like I'm also, you know, speaking out on one side of my mouth
39:43
because I can't carry every combination on my lot.
39:46
And I sell most of my vehicles off my lot, right?
39:48
So our job is to help a customer who wants it as a vehicle
39:51
they've always wanted, regardless if it's the right color
39:53
or if it has a mood or if it's not.
39:56
Yeah. So you step into that dealership.
39:59
Now we fast forward to present day.
40:01
What aspects of just being a dealer have surprised you?
40:05
Is it maybe something that you're like, wow,
40:07
I can't believe this is being done this way.
40:08
We got to do better.
40:09
Or maybe something where you're just like,
40:11
I didn't even know that this exists.
40:13
Like what has surprised you?
40:14
For me, coming from the factory side of it, right?
40:18
It was, it's the human side of it, right?
40:20
You know, like on the factory side, you're in big teams
40:23
and people are moving around every 18 months
40:26
and so you kind of get to know somebody and they move on
40:28
and you're moving up or you get promoted.
40:31
And, you know, most people are successful
40:33
when you're high level in the factory, right?
40:35
So few people are talking about finance problems
40:38
or anything like that, right?
40:40
So when you're in a small business, you're there for everything, right?
40:44
You know, like these people, I've got people on the team
40:45
that have been on this same team in the same office 20 plus years,
40:49
you know, long before I got there, right?
40:51
You know, people with family issues, you know,
40:53
people with conflicts within the team, you know,
40:56
people that just need to be reassured.
40:59
And it was kind of like, wow,
41:01
I just need to have an open door every day
41:03
and I can do an open door.
41:04
But I mean, so much of it was, I wasn't, I was thinking,
41:08
hey, this is going to, you know,
41:09
coming from the factory, I'm ready for it to be all numbers.
41:11
PowerPoints, right?
41:12
I can analyze and put together a great, you know,
41:15
PowerPoint presentation of what we're going to do.
41:17
And I found out of, like, oh, my God, it's so much
41:21
about hard conversations or uncomfortable conversations.
41:24
And it's not just emotional.
41:25
The emotional intelligence.
41:28
Yeah, the EI side of it.
41:30
Other than emotional intelligence, how has the store performed
41:33
when you came in today?
41:35
I mean, how profitable are we talking?
41:38
Like, where are you at?
41:39
So the most stressful the first couple of months, right?
41:42
You know, like so coming in, you know, I'm a long time ago
41:45
as a former Marine, right?
41:46
And so, you know, all about planning.
41:50
Why didn't I know that?
41:51
I don't know. But I had, you know, so like coming into it,
41:54
like I planned out everything, right?
41:56
We're going to take this and we're going to, you know,
41:59
And luckily, one of the the biggest things that you are in the Marines is,
42:03
you know, every good plan, you know, doesn't survive first contact.
42:07
So you better be ready to adapt, right?
42:09
And I was pretty sure, right?
42:11
Nothing matched up on my pro forma, you know, like we're losing
42:15
money the first month in, last more money the second month in.
42:19
I mean, you're always talking about like, you know, profit as a
42:22
percent of sales, like mine was like negative four percent.
42:26
And, you know, going to the store with like, you know, a million
42:29
and a half working capital, like there's only so many more months
42:32
I can do this before, like I was like, this could be embarrassing
42:35
if I, you know, go bankrupt in six months, you know, just before you got
42:38
to call before you got to call Fred Beans to bail you out or I got
42:45
Yeah, we were losing money, but what I could tell, right?
42:48
You know, and this also is like where I can just, you know, tribute,
42:51
you know, just the lessons I learned in the Marines is just being calm, right?
42:55
Like, yeah, there's a lot going on, but be calm and look through.
42:58
Like, are we doing things the right way?
42:59
And I, I had, I luckily, I inherited an awesome team, right?
43:03
And I could tell, you know, we were changing things, but we were
43:06
doing the right things, you know, I bought it the end of October.
43:10
We're going into November and December and when you're in Northern,
43:13
Northern, Northern New York, I mean, basically Canada, those are your slow
43:17
I mean, despite what's going on in the rest of the country.
43:20
And so we were slow.
43:21
I had started up, I mean, we weren't really selling cards till mid
43:24
November, because getting DMS is online and everything else.
43:28
Once we had that online, all of a sudden, you know, started making a little
43:32
bit of money, but I was like, but my, my bank account is going, why is
43:34
my bank account still going down?
43:36
Like, I'm running out of cash in my bank account, but I was like, everything
43:39
is showing us making money.
43:40
It turned out there was some clerical era in India with Ford paying me
43:45
on all my incentives and everything else.
43:47
So now I'm all of a sudden, I'm not getting my weekly incentive, you know,
43:50
and, and everything else that Ford's do, you know, based on the vehicles
43:53
you buy and all the, you know, the below the wine margins.
43:56
And then how much are we talking about?
43:57
How much money were you at?
43:58
By those 50,000 a week or something or more.
44:01
You know, so I'm burning through cash and I, and it was all coming up
44:06
right before the NAD meeting.
44:07
I was like, guys, I was like, and I was all the regional team.
44:10
I was like, if we don't figure this out before the NAD meeting, I'm
44:13
going straight to the top at the factory meeting and let them know that
44:15
you guys are going to be the ones that put me out of business because I just
44:18
the cash was, and finally got that back on and they, you know, but it was
44:21
like a true up of like several hundred thousand dollars.
44:24
When you're in startup mode, doesn't sound like a lot of money today, but
44:27
when you're in startup mode and you hadn't made money yet, that's a lot
44:30
of money, especially when you lost money or course.
44:32
So it's, you know, just kind of going into it, you know, from that mindset,
44:35
it was like, you know, it's just staying calm and having trust in your team and
44:40
a confidence in your team that, Hey, if we're doing things the right way, it's
44:44
going to come around.
44:44
We're taking care of customers with selling cars, returning wrenches.
44:48
It's going to come in a dip and it's come around and the team is grown tremendously.
44:54
You know, one of the things I instituted and again, it's just kind of like
44:57
the discipline from the military side of it is like, everyone's going to be trained.
45:01
You know, you know, as a small rural store, so it wasn't a lot of formal training,
45:04
right? But I joined NCM 20 groups.
45:07
I'm a part of an NCM 20 group joined it pretty much day one.
45:10
They reached out to me and invited me to join.
45:12
I was like, yeah, this sounds great.
45:13
I'd reached out to an ADA and it didn't get a call back.
45:16
And then a group from NCM called me and said, Hey, we heard about you.
45:20
Somebody, somebody knows you and I joined that group.
45:23
Those phenomenal deals from around the country, hard chargers.
45:25
I mean, this isn't a kind of a group, but we're just going to have fun.
45:28
I mean, we're drilling each other, you know, every time, you know, all day long
45:32
in the meetings, I mean, they've made me so much better.
45:34
So I got lucky there.
45:35
But I learned a lot about it in NCM.
45:37
They've got this awesome training program.
45:39
They have their own, you know, General Managers Academy.
45:41
They've got senior training for like sales managers, service managers.
45:45
So I bought into the full training program and said, Hey,
45:47
all the leadership team is going through this and everybody's been through it.
45:51
And it's just amazing how much it's opened up their eyes.
45:54
It's one thing for me to know something, right?
45:55
But it's getting by and like, I'm the factory guy coming to something
45:58
this guy's been doing for 20 years.
46:00
Like I might know how to conceptually do something and I can say it.
46:03
But if they don't believe me, like, well, you know, what kind of
46:06
real credibility do I have coming in, right?
46:08
So I can be the guy that just starts barking orders and you will do this.
46:12
But I knew if I didn't get buy-in, nothing was going to happen.
46:14
It was all about the buy-in, right?
46:16
And that's, I mean, again, like that's a lesson for the military.
46:18
It's not about barking orders.
46:19
It's about trust, earning respect, getting people to buy into whatever the mission is.
46:24
And so I knew I was like, well, you know what, I'm going to be telling them this,
46:27
you know, but I'm also going to get other industry experts because they're
46:29
with other sales managers from across the country, other service managers across
46:32
so they're hearing how important it is to use cars and focus on ELR and new video
46:36
MPIs, you know, getting the team to go through that.
46:39
So with that, you know, so tying it all together, you know, whether it's
46:42
training and focusing on the key metrics that are going to drive the distance growth.
46:47
I mean, yeah, we're doing great.
46:48
The store has had its, you know, in August, we had our best month ever,
46:53
including the store's 60-year history.
46:55
In September, we had our best month ever, including the store.
46:59
What's the net to sales percentage there?
47:01
We're now at 3%, which is, I think is great considering where I came from.
47:06
And I, there's a lot of starting from a 7% swing.
47:11
And there's a lot of startup.
47:12
I'm still paying down all my debt is also, but not all of it.
47:15
A lot of my debt is still tied up in my expenses.
47:18
So, which is, but I can tell you also, like my NCM group, I think that
47:22
averages 4.8, you know, so like my guys are like, I'm still on the right
47:27
I'm like, but I'm up to three minutes, you know, like in there.
47:30
Like, and I've got guys in there that are four dealers that are over 7%.
47:34
If I remember correctly, I mean, they're killing it, right?
47:37
You know, so like, I'm with people that know how to, you know, you know, operate
47:41
a business profitable.
47:43
The four dealers over 7%, what do you think they're doing?
47:46
They're doing every, that's the thing you'll see.
47:48
They're doing everything.
47:49
You can't, they're not just a new car dealer, right?
47:51
They're a used car dealer.
47:53
They're a great service shop.
47:55
They're great parts.
47:56
They're not one dimensional.
47:58
No, it's multi, multi-dimensional.
48:00
And they're, and they're consistent too, right?
48:02
You know, they're, there's discipline and consistency.
48:05
Um, and there's a lot you can learn.
48:07
Like I've, I, you know, like a lot of my vendors, vendor ideas came for them.
48:11
I was like, I knew things I needed to work on, but then I'd get these vendor
48:14
ideas from them, go back and implement and just, you know, wow, you know, huge
48:18
step forwards and different things.
48:20
This episode is brought to you by CDG circles.
48:23
Running a dealership today takes more than it ever has between new technology,
48:26
regulations and constant change, but the hardest part is doing it alone.
48:32
No one to call when things got tough, no place to ask what's actually working
48:35
for you right now is this vendor legit.
48:38
How would you fix this problem in your service department and much, much more?
48:42
And that's why I built CDG circles, a new kind of peer group for top
48:46
performing dealers with circles.
48:48
You get a dealer group chat, structured sessions, real time conversations, all
48:52
with the full confidentiality, antitrust compliance and a group of dealers
48:56
who actually get it.
48:58
Our goal is to end the isolation that costs dealers time, money and clarity.
49:03
We're not a 20 group.
49:05
We're not retrospective and we don't group you by brand circles is for dealers
49:09
who are looking for in the moment insights, almost like having a personal
49:13
sounding board of top notch dealers who are playing on your level.
49:16
Over a thousand dealers joined our original waitlist.
49:18
In this month, we've officially opened up signups to additional founding members.
49:23
So join us and be part of the first wave.
49:25
Taking the car business back into our own hands.
49:27
Join us at CDGCircles.com or click the link in the show notes below.
49:34
Are we going to buy another store?
49:36
Are we going to continue growing this?
49:37
Do you have any entry?
49:38
Your family, you put them through quite the roller coaster with this.
49:42
I didn't even ask you about that.
49:43
Like what was the family impact and how did that go?
49:46
I was shocked at how supportive my wife is, right?
49:49
Like, I'm like, honey, well, we'll we'll leverage everything.
49:52
We're just going to put it out there.
49:53
You know, she's, you know, she's because I've moved so many times.
49:57
She's a keeper, right?
49:59
Like, so she's been, you know, this last move to Michigan, you know, Jamie,
50:03
it's hard for her to keep any sort of job because I was moving every two years, right?
50:07
And so where did you move from?
50:09
Doug, where did you move from?
50:10
So for me, it's been bouncing between like New York and Texas, Michigan,
50:17
And so those types of moves, you know, mostly with four and then, you know,
50:21
most recently, we had nothing to fall back on, right?
50:25
Like, I'm because I'm betting the cushion to run that.
50:27
And, you know, like, we got nothing to fall back on.
50:28
And she's like, and she's like, I know you can do it.
50:32
You know, she had confidence in me and I couldn't have done it
50:34
had she not been there, you know, supporting me like that.
50:37
So yeah, the family family is getting me a little misty.
50:42
Thinking about because it's what it's all about, right?
50:45
It's so you're bad.
50:47
Yeah, it's so, so important.
50:49
Having that support system, it's just it sounds it sounds cliche,
50:54
but it's not like I, you know, when I'm when I'm 12 hours in the office,
50:59
someone's holding the four down.
51:00
You cannot do it alone, you know.
51:03
So I totally respected it.
51:05
I understand where you're coming from because to do anything great,
51:09
you know, as they say, you need a team.
51:14
So some of the sacrifice, the sacrifice I made, like we thought,
51:18
please, so we're in Girls Point, Michigan, that'd been where we were at
51:21
were out for three years.
51:22
And so I bought the store in Northern New York, beautiful town.
51:25
It's on the edge of the Adirondacks.
51:27
It's near Lake Placid.
51:28
I mean, there's lakes and mountains where skiers were hikers.
51:32
I mean, it's just it's just gorgeous, right?
51:34
We were going to move and then it was kind of like we moved the kids
51:38
so many times, right?
51:40
And then we started talking about like they're doing good in school,
51:43
they don't get in high school, they don't get in middle school.
51:45
You know, can we make this work?
51:48
You know, can we make it work where it's all of a sudden what I forgot,
51:51
what I didn't know, I guess I didn't forget is that going into small
51:54
business and entrepreneurship, I get a little more control of my schedule back.
51:58
Like I was a slave to the bureaucracy.
51:59
And it's just because I let myself be a slave to it.
52:01
When I was at Ford, like I had no problem working around the clock all day long.
52:06
You know, because you want it.
52:07
You wouldn't you want it to win.
52:09
You know, I would take perspective like in you were playing the game on the field
52:13
and you wanted to be the best at it, you know, which I would do the same.
52:16
Like if I was in your position, I would be putting my heart into it
52:18
because that's just if I do something, I literally I actually have this tattoo
52:22
to myself, but it's like, do what you do and do it well.
52:24
Like if you do something like you go all in.
52:26
Yeah. And that's how I was at Ford.
52:28
I loved it, right? But it was burning out like.
52:31
So the funny thing is, is right now I split my time between Northern
52:33
New York and Michigan, and I now spend more time with my kids
52:37
than I was when I was with Donald's at Ford, right?
52:40
Like a more present, you know, back for the the moments when it when it matters.
52:43
And so like I fly back on the weekend.
52:45
So I'm out the dealership during the week.
52:46
And again, it was skills that I learned, you know, from this so long ago.
52:50
Like some I went to business school, like, you know, got in my MBA.
52:54
I have all these trainings and things.
52:56
And like some of my best military lessons is like when I was a kid in the Marines, right?
53:00
But it's so much of it was is how do you create a team
53:02
that if you take a bullet in the head that they're going to keep running
53:04
and keep, you know, keep on the mission, right?
53:07
And so I've always led a team like that every time.
53:09
And it's the same way I set up this dealership.
53:10
Like I built a team from a general manager down that I can trust, right?
53:14
And these this team is killing it for me, right?
53:17
And it wasn't like that when we started, but we built it up.
53:19
And I want them to have that ownership.
53:20
I want them to have that, you know, that success from from winning.
53:25
You know, they didn't have the transparency.
53:26
They've got the transparency of seeing, you know, all their metrics.
53:29
Many of them are paid off their own department, bottom lines.
53:31
They've got big commissions.
53:33
So as they've been killing it, I mean, they're they're reaping the rewards of it, right?
53:37
Like, and I love it, you know, it is awesome.
53:39
So like, I've got a team there.
53:41
So like, it's, you know, here it is, you know, Friday afternoon,
53:44
you know, I was able to fly back and be with the kids for the weekend.
53:47
And, you know, like, I've got that flexibility.
53:50
And it's, you know, you know, the funny thing is I fly into Montreal.
53:54
So like people still show you like, so you're in New York.
53:55
Yeah, I was like, yeah, but I fly out of Montreal into Detroit.
53:58
Like I'm an hour from Montreal where the dealership's at.
54:00
Well, you have a very calm demeanor about you.
54:04
You're very easy to talk to.
54:05
So I'll give you that as a compliment because I think in the dealership
54:09
setting, that's a very important thing, right?
54:11
To be, you know, easily approachable.
54:17
So before we wrap up, you mentioned a couple of things throughout.
54:20
I was writing this down.
54:22
You mentioned earlier like video MPIs, little technology stuff.
54:25
I'm curious to know as you've had this, again, seven point swing
54:29
from unprofitability to profitability, right?
54:32
And working with your team to get there.
54:34
Has there been anything meaningful changed within, you know,
54:38
your systems, your tech, how you do business?
54:41
I know process tech is obviously related, but anything specific
54:45
that comes to mind that you've implemented that's been very successful for you?
54:51
Some of the things were implemented.
54:52
Some of the things we added, right?
54:54
So like when I got there, the store had been using the auto, right?
54:57
But we didn't sell hardly any used cars, but they had the auto, right?
55:00
And I was at my NCM 20 group.
55:03
I'm like, and I was the worst in the ratio of new to new to use.
55:06
Like we'd be selling, you know, 40 to 50 new a month and 10 used a month, right?
55:10
So I was like, not even non-existent.
55:12
I'm like, Hey guys, what do I need to do?
55:14
I was like, it's and one of the one of the guys, William, he's like, he's like,
55:18
I was like, yeah, he goes, how often do you meet him with your coach?
55:21
I said, well, I think the team meets with him once a month.
55:24
And he's like, he's like, our team meets with our coach weekly.
55:28
And he's like, and I'm in most of those meetings and we do everything
55:32
And I'm like, Roger that.
55:34
And so I started realizing, like, and all of a sudden, just me being in the
55:38
meeting for one, the auto realized, you know, our coaches, the auto guys are very
55:41
good, they're very good.
55:44
They're training, you know, their background, their experiences.
55:47
And once they realized, OK, these guys are, looks like they're getting engaged.
55:50
They saw me getting in the meetings.
55:51
They saw us asking for weekly meetings.
55:54
My team, I think they saw how important I, you know, I considered it now.
55:58
And all of a sudden there's like, when we're having a merchandising
56:00
because yep, we're going to make sure there's, you know, pictures of everything
56:02
or we're going to improve the stories of all these vehicles or yeah, we're
56:06
still, you know, wholesaling too many cars.
56:08
So I mean, our used is, you know, already jumped just they jumped the first
56:12
year and just year over year is where we're up another 30 percent.
56:16
We're now averaging, you know, like 35 to 40 used a month.
56:19
And with the sky is a limit on the use sign.
56:22
And we're still figuring it out and learning it.
56:24
But that's been, you know, one of our pessimistic success is like, we do
56:28
great on the new side, we 200 percent sales expectancy.
56:30
So it's only so much how you can go on the new side.
56:33
But use the sky is a limit.
56:34
And so many of the dealers that I respect, I'm like, wow, you guys are awesome.
56:38
Like, you know, you realize they're also great use car dealers.
56:40
And it's understanding that that side of it.
56:43
So that's that's one of the ones we're getting better at.
56:45
One of the ones we implemented is like, I was like trying to figure out
56:48
like the service side and another guy's like, Hey, you ever heard of Dynatron?
56:53
So I know there's some other competitors out there to Dynatron, but Dynatron's
56:56
So we signed up with Dynatron.
56:57
It's kind of like the Vado, you know, service, right?
57:00
And so then we started really diving into ELRs and we're still
57:03
had and then doing weekly meetings with a service manager there.
57:06
And we're like, wow, our pricing is all off.
57:08
And all of a sudden realize, and then there's real data behind it.
57:11
So it's, you know, we're guessing, you know, team was had to guess.
57:13
What did you, yeah, what did you figure out about ELRs?
57:17
Like, what did you discover there?
57:18
That ours is incredibly low, right?
57:20
We were one, we were discounting a ton.
57:22
We weren't using a price pricing matrix, right?
57:25
Like that's another one.
57:26
Like if you have to job short, then it should probably have a lower, you know,
57:29
you know, you know, price, right?
57:32
But if you've got like an eight hour heavy duty diesel job, you know,
57:36
why wouldn't you be charging more per hour for that?
57:39
Because, you know, a doctor would write, you know, like, and that's kind
57:42
of their word tracks, right?
57:43
And it's like, it kind of makes sense.
57:45
And those, and then that is also something that you can kind of explain.
57:48
And you start understanding that.
57:49
And so we started tweaking our pricing.
57:51
And again, we've got, they have the benchmarks also know, like, wasn't
57:54
just like throwing big prices is knowing what the prices in our region of the
57:58
country where we should be at, and we were low.
58:00
And once we started tweaking that, I mean, once I submitted for a warranty rate
58:04
increase with Ford, I got a $50 warranty rate increase with Ford.
58:08
I mean, which was that's massive.
58:10
That's just all straight to the bottom line.
58:11
Then we did the same thing with Parsons.
58:12
We got like a nearly a 40% you know, parts markup increase.
58:16
I mean, just money going to the bottom line because we were leaving it on the
58:19
table and not because we're overcharging customers.
58:21
It's just because we weren't being smart about our pricing.
58:23
We weren't watching it.
58:24
We were discounting only too much, too much control for service advice.
58:27
And they were doing the right thing, can't blame it.
58:29
You know, anybody trying to make a customer happy wants to give something
58:31
away, it's just, you don't have to, right?
58:33
You know, in certain times you do, but not all the time.
58:36
And so it was balancing that.
58:38
But I mean, huge successes, you know, from, you know, vendors like that.
58:41
And it's just using, these aren't even, you know, earth shattering types of
58:44
vendors are not talking AI yet or anything kind of crazy.
58:47
These are some common vendors, but it's leveraging them the right way.
58:51
You know, using the tools you got.
58:54
Well, Doug, I mean, you've done an incredible job in a very short period of time.
58:58
You have an awesome story.
58:59
Love to hear the, you know, that you were a Marine, of course, a 13 year
59:03
And now this, do you think you're going to go for another store?
59:07
Or are we kind of happy with one?
59:09
What do you think you're going to do?
59:10
I'd definitely go for another store, but it, I'd wanted, it just need to be organic,
59:15
You know, need to be in the same area, you know, and, and then I think absolutely.
59:20
And it's just got to come up, but I'm in a rural area, right?
59:22
So it's not like there's a bunch of dealers for sale.
59:24
But if something comes up, somebody's selling, then I'd love to talk to them.
59:29
And for me, it's being a big part of the community.
59:31
And that's kind of how I work this deal.
59:32
The former family had the store for 60 years.
59:34
They wanted someone's going to be a part of the community.
59:36
And we give, you know, I mean, just, I don't know, 50,000 already has just gone
59:40
back into the community this year between like charities and sponsorships and things
59:44
And so that's a big part of it.
59:46
And that's part I like.
59:48
Um, so yeah, absolutely.
59:49
I'm always, it's, it's fun.
59:51
You'll see, I just, I love it.
59:52
It's fun, you know, just getting started.
59:54
Just getting, do you, do you subscribe to our newsletter?
59:57
Do you get our newsletter range chance?
00:00
Cause there's, um, we're launching a fixed ops pulse right now as well.
00:04
Uh, but other than that, you know, there's a lot of very tactical data that we
00:08
share and just best practices and stuff that I think you could really benefit
00:11
from, um, so I'm glad to hear that.
00:19
And I'm really, you know, just happy to see how well you're doing.
00:23
And, um, I hope, I hope, uh, Fred gets to listen to this.
00:29
No, I, you'll see, I'm still shocked that I'm here.
00:31
Like I listened to you.
00:32
So like you've got these amazing dealers.
00:35
You've got the greats on here.
00:36
You've got people, massive stores, massive groups.
00:39
Like I never dreamed I was getting a call to, you know, come chat with you.
00:42
I mean, I just, um, I'm glad to have you on, man.
00:44
Shocked and you have a great story.
00:46
I appreciate it, man.
00:47
Great story, brother.
00:48
Doug, Doug Gilmore.
00:50
Thank you so much for coming on.
00:51
It's been truly fun.
00:57
Hope you enjoyed that episode.
00:59
Please give the podcast a rating.
01:00
Consider subscribing to the show and check the show notes for links to what we talked about.
01:04
Thanks for tuning in.
01:05
I'll see you guys next time.