416: Hagerty's Dave Kinney on Where Collector Car Values Are Heading
The Collector Car Podcast
416: Hagerty's Dave Kinney on Where Collector Car Values Are Heading The Collector Car Podcast · Apr 23, 2026
416: Hagerty's Dave Kinney on Where Collector Car Values Are Heading

Annotations will appear as you listen

0:00
56:25
416: Hagerty's Dave Kinney on Where Collector Car Values Are Heading
Company

Hagerty

Hagerty is a well-known collector-car brand associated with insurance and market reporting. Even though the transcript segment doesn’t detail Hagerty’s methods, the episode framing indicates the discussion is tied to Hagerty’s valuation perspective.

Topic

NAMM conference

The Packard Museum is mentioned in connection with the NAMM conference, which is a specific event context for why the books need to arrive. For listeners, this helps explain the timing and logistics around collector-car media and presentations.

Concept

valuation tools

A “valuation tool” is a way to estimate what a collector car should sell for. It looks at recent sales and similar cars to guess a fair price.

Brand

Ferrari Club of America

Ferrari Club of America is a major enthusiast organization for Ferrari owners and collectors. Its involvement here signals that the wealth-management partner is targeting the Ferrari and broader collector-car community.

Company

Paris style wealth

Paris style wealth is a financial company that works with collectors. They’re connected to the Ferrari Club of America, and the pitch is about planning for the long term.

Company

NCM insurance

NCM Insurance is a company that sells insurance for classic and collector cars. Instead of treating your car like a normal daily driver, they tailor the policy to how you store, protect, and value the vehicle.

Term

collector car

A collector car is a car people keep because it’s special to them—maybe rare, classic, or valuable to enthusiasts. Since it’s not treated like a regular daily driver, it often needs different insurance and better records.

Term

agreed value coverage

Agreed value coverage is when you and the insurance company agree on a price for your car ahead of time. If the car is totaled, you’re paid that agreed amount instead of a lower “what it’s worth today” number.

Company

Carport

Carport is a digital “garage” app/service that helps owners document, organize, and manage their vehicles. In a collector context, it’s used to track service history and store records so the collection is easier to maintain and (often) easier to insure or sell.

Term

service history

Service history is the log of work done on a car—like oil changes, repairs, and maintenance. Keeping it helps show the car was looked after, which can make the car easier to trust and easier to sell.

Concept

insane prices

They’re saying cars are selling for surprisingly high money at auctions. When that happens, it can raise prices people expect to pay for similar cars.

Topic

Kissimmee

Kissimmee is where a lot of collector cars get auctioned off. Big results there can strongly influence what people think cars are worth.

Topic

Amelia

Amelia refers to the Amelia Island collector-car auctions in Florida, known for high-end inventory and strong buyer participation. The segment uses Amelia results to support the idea that the market is unusually hot.

Topic

Barrett Jackson

Barrett-Jackson is a famous collector-car auction. If it’s seeing high prices too, it means the market strength isn’t just one event.

Topic

RM sale in the Phoenix

RM Sotheby’s is a big-name auction company for expensive collector cars. Strong results in Phoenix suggest buyers are paying up broadly.

Company

Broad Arrow

Broad Arrow is a company that auctions collector cars. The host is saying their sales were unusually strong, which supports the idea that the market is hot.

Topic

bottom sale

They mention a “bottom” sale, meaning a segment of the market that’s not always the most exciting. The point is that even those cars are doing well.

Concept

2005 up buying spree

The host suggests that buyers have been aggressively purchasing collector cars from roughly the 2005 model-year era onward. That’s a “demand cohort” idea: newer collector cars can behave differently than older classics because of different buyer motivations and availability.

Concept

oddball colors

“Oddball colors” refers to unusual paint colors that might not be everyone’s taste, but can still attract buyers depending on rarity, provenance, and how the car is presented. In collector markets, color can materially affect desirability and pricing.

Company

RM

RM is an auction company that sells collector cars. When they say RM did really well, they mean the cars sold for strong prices.

Concept

auction caveat: cars can sell for less or more than expected

They’re saying auction prices can surprise you. Sometimes a car sells cheaper than expected, and sometimes it sells for more because buyers get competitive.

Concept

tailor-made customization before there was a program at Ferrari

They’re talking about cars that were customized in a very personal way before the brand had an official option program. The point is that custom stuff can add value, but it doesn’t always make the price jump the way people assume.

Brand

Rolls Royce

Rolls Royce is being used as another example of a luxury brand that learned to listen to customers. The idea is that giving people what they want can pay off.

Brand

Bentley

Bentley is referenced as a brand that learned a lesson about customer-driven customization—essentially, that meeting buyer preferences can be important for satisfaction and desirability. It’s part of a broader point that brands have adjusted their approach over time.

Topic

Bring a Trailer

Bring a Trailer is a popular online auction site for collector cars. If a car does really well there, it can make more people want that car and affect its value.

Term

paint the sample stuff

This phrase means “the eye-catching color options.” The idea is that if a car looks especially cool, more people notice it and it can become more desirable.

Ford F150
Car

Ford F150

They’re talking about a Ford F-150 truck they saw on a dealer lot. The takeaway is that people tend to buy certain colors more than others, and dealers stock those colors heavily.

Concept

predictable and the same

They’re saying people tend to like cars that are predictable—cars that look and are configured in a familiar way. That can make it easier for buyers to want them, which can affect resale value.

Term

day two builds

“Day two builds” just means you buy the car first, then modify it later. People do it to make the car more personal, but collectors may care a lot about whether changes keep the car looking original.

Concept

day one build

“Day one build” means you get the car the way you want right from the factory. That can be better for resale because it’s more “correct” than doing big changes after you buy it.

Term

signal orange

“Signal orange” is just a bright, noticeable paint color. The idea is that unusual factory colors can make a car easier to market and more desirable to the right buyers.

Term

McLaren orange

“McLaren orange” is a famous-looking orange color. The host is using it to make the point that standout, recognizable colors can help a vehicle feel more special.

Term

Irish green

“Irish green” is a particular green paint color. The point is that if lots of cars are ordered with the same distinctive color and interior, buyers know exactly what they’re getting.

Term

tartan interiors

“Tartan interiors” are plaid-pattern seats or trim. The idea is that a distinctive interior can make a car more desirable and help it stand out when buyers shop.

Term

guard red

“Guard red” is a specific red paint color. The host is saying that if it’s just another common red, it won’t stand out as much to buyers.

Concept

Millennials

They’re saying younger buyers are becoming more important in the collector car world. When that happens, the kinds of cars people want—and the prices—can shift.

Concept

Generation X

They’re also talking about Gen X buyers joining the collector car market. Different age groups tend to buy different kinds of cars, which can affect prices.

Concept

boomers

The speaker identifies themselves as a “boomer” and contrasts their approach to buying with younger buyers. In collector car markets, generational behavior can affect timing (when people buy), risk tolerance, and what they consider “worth it.”

Topic

motor Miami

They’re referencing another car event in Miami where they talked about younger buyers. It’s included to show these ideas are coming up in multiple places.

Concept

cars and coffee effect

“Cars and coffee” is a style of car meet where people gather casually, usually for a couple hours, and then go home. It changed the hobby by making it feel less like a big commitment and more like a fun hangout.

Concept

coolness factor

“Coolness factor” means people buy cars because they think they look awesome or fit their vibe. When enough buyers feel that way, it can push prices up even if the car isn’t the most “important” historically.

Concept

collector market

A “collector market” is where people buy cars not just to drive, but because they think the car will be special or valuable later. When more companies and buyers get involved, the prices and what people want can change.

Brand

Porsche

Porsche is being used as an example of a brand that makes special cars for collectors. Instead of only selling normal versions, they create limited editions and unique options that collectors want.

Term

special color

A “special color” is a unique paint or finish that isn’t available on every car. Collectors often like these because they make the car stand out and can be rarer.

Term

limited production (cut it off at 48 worldwide)

That phrase means only 48 cars are being made worldwide. When something is rare like that, collectors often want it more, which can help keep its value higher.

Porsche GT3 Touring
Car

Porsche GT3 Touring

They’re talking about a special Porsche GT3 Touring, built around a 2014. It’s basically a high-performance Porsche that’s meant to feel a bit more “everyday friendly,” which collectors often pay extra for—especially when it’s customized.

Term

custom-spec

“Custom-spec” means the buyer configured the car with special options. For collectors, that can make the car more interesting or valuable, but it has to be the kind of customization other people will also want.

Concept

feasibility study

A feasibility study is basically a “can we actually do this?” check. Before a company agrees to make a custom color or finish, they test whether it’s possible and worth the effort.

Concept

customizable cars in the 1970s

They’re saying that in the 1970s, people could customize cars a lot—colors and interior details. The risk is that what looks cool now might not be what future collectors want.

Term

vinyl roof

A vinyl roof is a fake “top” made of vinyl that’s attached to the outside of the car. Some collectors like the look, but if it’s old or poorly maintained, it can hurt the car’s value.

Term

Shag carpet

Shag carpet refers to a long-pile, high-texture interior carpet style that was popular in certain eras. As a collector consideration, it’s a strong visual statement—some buyers love the period-correct vibe, while others see it as dated or hard to restore.

Concept

buy a car because you love it (not just for collector value)

They’re saying don’t buy a car only hoping it will be worth more later. Buy something you actually like, take care of it, and keep good records—because collector value isn’t guaranteed.

Term

keeping all the records

“Keeping all the records” means maintaining documentation like service history, receipts, and provenance. For collector cars, records can materially affect buyer confidence and resale value because they help verify condition, maintenance, and authenticity.

Concept

unpredictable damage risk (the "sewer top" example)

They’re using a funny example to make a serious point: accidents and random stuff can happen and damage your car. Even if you do everything right, you can’t control everything.

Concept

Transportation value

It’s basically the idea that a car isn’t only an investment. If you can actually use and enjoy it, that “value” matters too, especially with collector cars.

Ferrari Enzo
Car

Ferrari Enzo

The Ferrari Enzo is one of the most famous modern Ferraris, and it’s highly collectible. Here they’re talking about how auction prices can vary a lot depending on the exact car and details like color.

Concept

Outlier auction price

They’re saying one auction price was unusually high compared to what you’d normally expect. That kind of result may not reflect the usual market value.

Concept

Color desirability (least desirable color)

With collectible cars, the exact color can matter a lot. Some colors are more popular with buyers, and the less popular ones can sell for less.

Concept

Unicorn sales

A “unicorn sale” is when a car sells for a super-surprising, record-level price. The point here is those rare spikes usually don’t happen again and again.

Concept

rising tide

It means when lots of collector cars are going up in price, the whole market often feels stronger. So even cars you’re not watching closely can still get a boost.

Ferrari FXX
Company

RM Sotheby's

RM Sotheby’s is an auction company that sells expensive collector cars. When they have a sale coming up, the results can affect what people think similar cars are worth.

Concept

estimated now this is in euros 4.9 to 5.3 million

An auction estimate is basically the predicted price range for what the car might sell for. Here, the host thinks the range is too low given how rare and well-specified the car is.

Concept

number four condition

Collector cars are often rated by condition on a numbered scale. “Number four” usually means the car is usable and presentable, but not restored to a top, show-quality level. The point here is that fewer restorations are happening, so more cars end up in that mid-to-lower condition range.

Concept

restoration shops are all full

This highlights a supply-and-demand issue in the restoration ecosystem: if restoration shops are booked solid, turnaround times increase and fewer owners can complete projects. That can delay restorations and contribute to more cars remaining in lower condition grades.

Concept

quoting times

This is about how long it takes to get a price and get on the schedule. If it takes forever to get an estimate, fewer people start restoration projects.

Concept

tariffs

Tariffs are extra taxes on imported products. If car parts or supplies are imported, tariffs can make them cost a lot more, which raises restoration costs.

Concept

labor costs going up

Even if parts didn’t change, paying mechanics and restoration shops more can make the whole project more expensive. That can reduce how many cars get fully restored.

Term

hammer

The “hammer” price is the final price the car sells for at auction. It’s the number you’d use to compare against the estimate.

Concept

rare color

Color matters a lot for collector cars. A rare color can make the car more desirable and push the price higher, but it doesn’t always mean the value will keep rising forever.

Duesenberg Model J
Car

Duesenberg Model J

The Duesenberg Model J is a legendary old American car. People collect it because it’s historically important and very desirable, so it often keeps value better than less-famous cars.

Concept

market shifts

“Market shifts” just means the collector-car market changes over time—who wants what, and how much people are willing to pay. Even famous cars can go up and down before settling.

Concept

blue chip

“Blue chip” cars are the collector favorites that people always want. They usually sell more easily and don’t drop as hard as weird or less-famous cars.

Mercedes-Benz 300 SLS
Car

Mercedes-Benz 300 SLS

Mercedes-Benz 300 SLS is a famous old Mercedes that collectors really want. The hosts are talking about how much people are paying for similar cars recently, and they say the market is doing better than last year.

Term

roasters

In collector-car talk, “roasters” typically means open-top cars (roadsters/convertibles). The hosts are comparing how the open-top versions of certain models are selling versus other body styles.

Term

comps

“Comps” means comparing recent sales of similar cars. It helps estimate what a car is actually worth based on what buyers recently paid.

Honda Gold Wing
Car

Honda Gold Wing

Honda Gold Wing is being used as a comparison point for collector demand and pricing, but it’s a motorcycle (not an automobile). The hosts are contrasting the value movement between the Gold Wing and the Mercedes-Benz 300 SLS “roaster” market.

Duesenberg
Car

Duesenberg

Duesenberg is a famous American car brand known for high-end, collectible classics. The hosts say people are still actively buying them, and that Americans tend to value them more than Europeans.

Concept

worldwide market

A “worldwide market” means lots of buyers around the world want the same car. When that happens, it can help prices stay stronger because there are more people competing to buy the best examples.

Term

number one condition

“Number one condition” means the car is in the very best shape—like the top-quality, show-level example. In collector markets, the best cars can sell for way more than typical ones.

McLaren F1
Car

McLaren F1

The McLaren F1 is a famous, very rare supercar. The big reason collectors pay so much is condition—especially cars that are original and have very low miles, not ones that have been heavily changed.

Pontiac GTO
Car

Pontiac GTO

The Pontiac GTO is being used as a reference point for what makes a car become a top collector target. The idea is that the McLaren F1 could become that kind of “must-have” car, and the same value drivers apply—history and originality.

Concept

low miles original cars

Collectors usually want the best-preserved versions of a car. Even if many cars get restored, the highest prices tend to go to the ones with very few miles and that stayed close to how they left the factory.

Concept

restored vs low-mile original

Restoration can preserve a car’s appearance and function, but it doesn’t always replicate the market value of an untouched, low-mile original. Here, the speaker notes that more McLarens will be restored over time, yet the highest demand remains for the few that stayed “true” and unmodified.

Concept

replacement motor

A replacement motor means the car’s engine isn’t the original one. Collectors usually prefer original parts, so an engine swap can make the car worth less than a similar car with its original engine.

Concept

provenance and racing history

Collectors care a lot about a car’s story. If it has a documented racing background—where it raced and what it won—that history can make it worth much more than a similar-looking car without that pedigree.

Buick Grand
Car

Buick Grand

The Buick Grand National is a famous muscle car from America’s performance era. The host is saying it was one of the cars that kept the muscle-car spotlight alive for a while, which helps explain why collectors still care.

Concept

generational shift in collector interest

The idea is that younger people are starting to like cars that older collectors have loved for years. When that happens, the market can start valuing those cars more.

Car

Chevrolet Grand National

The Chevrolet Grand National is a famous turbo performance car from the 1980s. The host is using it as an example of a car that stayed popular for a long time and then started attracting new fans.

Buick Regal
Car

Buick Regal

The Buick Regal is a mid-size car made by Buick. People may talk about it because certain cars have special paint or personal history from an owner. In this episode, it’s being mentioned as a Regal that was painted a particular way.

GMC Typhoon
Car

GMC Typhoon

The GMC Typhoon was a small SUV that surprised people with how fast it was. The discussion is about whether collectors are valuing it enough today.

Car

GMC Cyclone

The GMC Cyclone is another 1980s fast SUV from GMC, built to be more performance-focused than a typical family vehicle. The point here is that collectors may be overlooking it.

Ferrari 308
Car

Ferrari 308

The Ferrari 308 is a famous classic sports car. The host is saying the GMC Typhoon/Cyclone were surprisingly quick compared to it when they came out.

Concept

JDM

JDM means Japanese cars made for the Japanese market. Collectors like them because they can be rare and sometimes have different features than what you’d find in the U.S.

Brand

Top Rank Imports

Top Rank Imports is referenced as a company that imports large numbers of JDM cars into the U.S. In collector-car value discussions, importers like this can influence availability, pricing, and which models become popular with enthusiasts.

Concept

collector "imprinting" on a single model

The idea here is that many car people get “hooked” by one car when they’re young. That first big obsession tends to stick, and it influences what they buy and value later.

Volkswagen GTI
Car

Volkswagen GTI

The Volkswagen GTI is a sportier version of the Golf. It’s famous for being a “hot hatch,” meaning a small car that’s still practical but drives like a performance car.

Dodge Omni
Car

Dodge Omni

The Dodge Omni GLH is a sporty version of the Dodge Omni. It’s remembered as a fun, limited-edition kind of 1980s performance car.

Mitsubishi Starion
Car

Mitsubishi Starion

The Mitsubishi Starion is a 1980s Japanese sports coupe, and it’s known for being turbocharged. People like it because it’s a fun, enthusiast-oriented car from that era.

Concept

Badge engineering (rebadging)

Badge engineering means one car is sold by different brands with different badges. So collectors may find the “same” car wearing a different name.

0:00
56:25