From Transactions to Trust
About this episode
Keith Mate of Synchrony breaks down how loyalty in the automotive aftermarket has shifted from punch cards and discounts to data-driven, personalized engagement. The conversation covers what information shops should collect, how to follow up on declined services, why timing and relevance matter, and how to measure ROI beyond enrollment numbers. The big takeaway: loyalty is less a program than a discipline built on consistency, convenience, and trust.
From tracking declined services to asking customers how they prefer to be contacted, Keith Mait, Senior Vice President and Auto Leader at Synchrony, outlines practical steps shops can take right now to turn one-time transactions into lasting relationships. He explains why loyalty isn’t a program—it’s a discipline—and how shops that stay connected between visits with timely, relevant communication will win in an increasingly competitive market.
Endeavor Business Media
"produced by Endeavor Business Media, a division of Endeavor B2B, bringing you strategies and inspiration for auto care success."
This is the company that produces the podcast you’re listening to. It doesn’t directly relate to car repair techniques.
Endeavor Business Media is mentioned as the producer of the podcast. While not an automotive concept, it provides context for the show’s publishing organization.
data-informed engagement
"independent shop owners are being challenged to move beyond punch cards and discounts, and toward personalized data-informed engagement that builds long-term trust."
It means the shop uses information about you and your car to decide what to say and when to say it. The goal is to make recommendations feel relevant, not random or salesy.
“Data-informed engagement” means using customer and vehicle data to tailor how a shop communicates and recommends services. Instead of generic promotions, shops use insights to time outreach and match offers to what the customer is likely to need next.
building loyalty
"Today, we are touching on a topic that is near and dear to many people's hearts in this industry, building loyalty. We're talking about turning customers into lifelong brand champions."
They’re talking about how shops can earn repeat customers over time. The idea is to build relationships so people trust the shop and recommend it.
This segment focuses on what “loyalty” means for independent shops in the automotive aftermarket. The discussion frames loyalty as turning customers into long-term advocates rather than relying on one-off promotions.
data-driven loyalty
"You know, when we think about data-driven loyalty, we sort of have to remember what loyalty used to mean and what our expectations are today."
It’s when a business uses information about you—like when you usually come in—to make the next visit feel more “for you.” In car services, that can mean reminders and offers that match your habits.
“Data-driven loyalty” means using customer data (like visit history and preferences) to tailor offers and predict future behavior. In automotive service, it’s often used to encourage repeat visits by timing reminders and personalizing communication based on how you use your vehicle.
predicting when people are going to come back
"Today's data-driven loyalty techniques extend into how to encourage repeat visits, personalization, understanding, or predicting when people are going to come back, knowing more about your vehicle that helps to understand frequency of visit."
It’s basically trying to guess when you’ll want to come back based on what you’ve done before. For car services, that could mean sending the right reminder at the right time.
This is the idea of forecasting customer return timing using data such as service intervals, past visit frequency, and behavior patterns. In the automotive context, it can translate into smarter scheduling for services like maintenance and detailing.
location-based preferences
"knowing more about your vehicle that helps to understand frequency of visit, location-based preferences."
It means the service company uses your location or where you usually go to decide what to offer you. For example, it can help them target the closest shop or the right time to reach you.
“Location-based preferences” refers to tailoring recommendations or outreach based on where a customer is (or where they typically go). For auto services, this can influence which shop gets your business, what promotions you see, and when you’re contacted.
personal touch / customization in auto service
"...that I get from the place I get my food, where I see my movies, my airline, my hotel. That's the standard. Now, they expect that same level no matter what they're interacting... Make year and model a vehicle, my VIN number... the type of oil that I use."
They’re talking about how car service should feel personal, not generic. When a shop uses your car’s details and remembers you, it builds trust and makes the experience smoother.
The segment frames auto service as a relationship where customers expect the same personalized experience they get from other industries. In practice, that “personal touch” can mean using your vehicle details (VIN, oil type) to tailor service and improve trust.
VIN number
"Make year and model a vehicle, my VIN number, my license plate number, my wife's name, my kid's names, the preferred location that I go to, the type of oil that I use."
VIN is like your car’s fingerprint. It helps shops make sure they’re working on the exact right vehicle, especially when ordering parts or checking service records.
VIN stands for Vehicle Identification Number. It’s a unique 17-character code used to identify a specific vehicle for things like parts lookup, service history, and recalls.
license plate number
"Make year and model a vehicle, my VIN number, my license plate number, my wife's name, my kid's names, the preferred location that I go to, the type of oil that I use."
Your license plate is the number on the back of your car. Shops sometimes use it to find your vehicle in their computer system and make sure they’re dealing with the right car.
A license plate number is the public identifier assigned to a vehicle. Service providers may ask for it to match your vehicle in their systems, verify ownership/records, or coordinate paperwork.
type of oil that I use
"...my kid's names, the preferred location that I go to, the type of oil that I use. Every extra element of information that is asked for is put into the recipe"
Oil isn’t one-size-fits-all—your car needs a specific kind. Using the right oil helps the engine stay protected and run properly.
“Type of oil” refers to the specific oil grade and specification your vehicle requires (often shown on the oil cap/manual). Using the correct oil helps protect engine components and maintain proper lubrication.
service history
"We think the most valuable data might be service history, mileage, vehicle profile, purchase behaviors, et cetera."
Service history is basically the car’s “paper trail” of repairs and maintenance. If a car has been serviced regularly, it usually means it was cared for. It can also reveal if the same problem keeps coming back.
Service history is the record of maintenance and repairs a vehicle has had over its life. It helps shops and buyers understand how well the car has been maintained and can flag recurring issues. In a buying decision, it’s often more informative than a single inspection because it shows patterns over time.
mileage
"We think the most valuable data might be service history, mileage, vehicle profile, purchase behaviors, et cetera."
Mileage is how far the car has been driven. More miles usually means more wear and tear. But two cars with the same mileage can be in very different condition depending on maintenance.
Mileage is how many miles a vehicle has been driven. It’s a key input for estimating wear, scheduling maintenance, and assessing whether the car’s condition matches its usage. Higher mileage can mean more wear, but service history often matters just as much.
vehicle profile
"We think the most valuable data might be service history, mileage, vehicle profile, purchase behaviors, et cetera."
A vehicle profile is a “snapshot” of the car—what it is and what it’s been like so far. It helps a shop give advice that fits your exact car instead of generic suggestions.
A vehicle profile is a structured summary of a car’s details—often including make/model, year, trim, mileage, and known issues. Shops use it to tailor recommendations and communicate what matters for that specific vehicle. In this context, it’s part of the data used to improve the next purchase decision.
muffler
"So if I go into your shop and I bring my car in and I'm in there for a muffler, but you discover a transmission issue,"
A muffler is the part of the exhaust system that makes the car quieter. If you’re in for a muffler, it usually means the noise changed or there might be an exhaust problem. Sometimes it’s a simple fix, but it depends on what’s actually damaged.
A muffler is part of the exhaust system that reduces noise and helps manage exhaust flow. When someone comes in “for a muffler,” it typically means they’re hearing unusual noise or suspect an exhaust leak or damage. Exhaust-related repairs can range from minor fixes to more involved work depending on the condition of surrounding components.
transmission issue
"So if I go into your shop and I bring my car in and I'm in there for a muffler, but you discover a transmission issue, you discover a tire that has poor tread on it,"
A transmission issue means something’s wrong with how the car sends power to the wheels. That can show up as rough shifting or delayed engagement. Because it’s expensive to fix when it’s serious, it’s important to address early.
A transmission issue means a problem in the car’s power-delivery system that changes engine output to the wheels. Depending on the severity, it can range from shifting/engagement problems to internal failures. It’s a major diagnostic and cost category compared with many routine items.
tire that has poor tread
"but you discover a transmission issue, you discover a tire that has poor tread on it, you recommend wiper blades and I decline them."
Poor tread means the tire is worn out and doesn’t grip the road as well. That can make braking worse and increase the risk of hydroplaning in rain. Replacing tires is often a safety decision, not just a convenience one.
Poor tread means the tire’s rubber grooves are worn down, reducing grip and increasing stopping distance—especially in wet or cold conditions. Shops often check tread depth and tire wear patterns to assess safety and alignment or suspension issues. It’s a common “decline” recommendation because it’s safety-related but not always urgent to the customer.
wiper blades
"you discover a tire that has poor tread on it, you recommend wiper blades and I decline them."
Wiper blades help keep your windshield clear. If they’re worn, they can smear or miss spots, making it harder to see in rain. Replacing them is usually quick and inexpensive compared with many other repairs.
Wiper blades are the rubber components that clear rain and debris from the windshield. Worn blades can streak, skip, or reduce visibility, which directly affects safety. Shops often recommend replacement based on inspection of blade condition and performance.
tracking what a customer declines
"but you discover a tire that has poor tread on it, you recommend wiper blades and I decline them. Are you keeping track of what I said no to? Right?"
The hosts are talking about remembering what you said “no” to when a shop recommends repairs. If they track that, they can follow up in a way that feels respectful and relevant. It helps avoid repeating the same pitch or being pushy.
The transcript highlights the idea of tracking customer “declines” (recommended services the customer says no to). That information can guide follow-up timing and improve trust by showing the shop remembers preferences and decisions. It’s a customer-relationship concept applied to automotive service workflows.
follow-up (seven days later, 14 days later, 30 days later)
"Are you following up? Seven days later, 14 days later, 30 days later. Hey, we were thrilled to have you in for your muffler issue."
They’re describing a plan to check back with customers after the car is serviced. Instead of disappearing after the repair, the shop follows up a few times to make sure everything is still okay. This can prevent small problems from turning into bigger ones.
The segment emphasizes structured follow-up after a repair visit—checking in at set intervals (7, 14, and 30 days). In auto service, follow-up can catch lingering issues, confirm the fix held, and reinforce safety-focused recommendations, which helps build customer trust.
turn those transactions into more relationships
"So when you're trying to turn those transactions into more relationships and people feel stuck in that mindset, what are some of the first steps that they can take to turn that one-time visit into more of a long-term relationship?"
They’re talking about changing how a shop deals with customers. Instead of just fixing the problem and moving on, the shop builds trust so the customer comes back for future maintenance. That usually involves good communication and checking in after the visit.
This is a service-industry concept applied to auto repair: shifting from one-off sales (a “transaction”) to ongoing customer trust (a “relationship”). In practice, it means consistent follow-up, proactive recommendations, and communication that makes customers feel understood rather than upsold.
relational versus transactional mindset
"Well, I think first off, it starts with how you communicate and ensuring that not only are your employees grounded in that mindset, that relational versus transactional mindset, but it's also in encouraging and building systems that reflect that mindset as well."
This means the difference between treating customers like a one-time sale versus building a long-term relationship. In an auto shop, a relationship-focused approach is more about explaining things clearly and helping prevent future problems, not just pushing a deal.
A “relational versus transactional mindset” contrasts customer service built on trust and long-term value with service focused on closing a deal. For auto shops, a relational approach often includes clear explanations, appropriate follow-up, and systems that encourage safe driving and preventive maintenance.
personalizing that deal or that rebate
"It's simply not peddling a deal for the sake of the deal. It's about personalizing that deal or that rebate or that offering because you know something specific about these people that force them to recognize and be aware that that's for them."
They’re saying the shop should tailor discounts or offers to the person, not just hand out generic deals. If the recommendation matches what the customer’s car needs, it feels more helpful and less like a sales pitch.
“Personalizing” offers in an automotive context means tailoring rebates, discounts, or recommendations to the specific customer and vehicle needs. The goal is relevance—customers are more likely to trust and act when the offer connects to what they actually drive and what they likely need next.
lifetime value
"Those drawn emotional connections, they draw on relational elements and it turns into lifetime value. What role does timing play knowing when to reach out to a customer with the right message or offer?"
Lifetime value means how much money a customer is expected to bring you over the years. In car service, it’s the goal of getting people to come back for future maintenance instead of shopping around.
“Lifetime value” (often abbreviated as LTV) is the total profit a business expects to earn from a customer over the entire time they keep buying from you. In automotive service, it’s about turning a one-time visit into repeat maintenance and repairs.
timing (when to reach out)
"What role does timing play knowing when to reach out to a customer with the right message or offer? Timing is tough. It really is, especially when we think about our vehicles."
The hosts discuss “timing” as a key part of customer outreach—contacting drivers when they’re most likely to need maintenance or repairs. They connect it to vehicle usage patterns, mileage, and prior service history, since there’s no universal schedule for everyone.
diagnosed vs declined service
"…If you know when they were there last, what you worked on, what you might have diagnosed at the same time, what they declined…"
The hosts mention using prior diagnoses and what the customer “declined” to guide future outreach. That’s important in automotive service because recommended work may be postponed, and later timing can make the same recommendation more relevant.
service vs sales messaging
"And those messages, they feel like service. They don't feel like sales. They feel like the ability to help you accomplish your next thing at your convenience…"
They contrast messages that feel like “service” versus “sales.” In an automotive context, service-feeling outreach typically emphasizes help, recommendations, and convenience—rather than pressure—so customers are more receptive to booking appointments.
snow tires
"...it's sunny and 60 degrees, and we have very different needs. But you know how to get on a road trip, if you're headed skiing and you may need some serious winter gear or to get your snow tires on or chains or have you."
Snow tires are tires made for winter weather. They grip better on snow and ice and usually work much better when it’s cold out than regular tires.
Snow tires are specialized tires designed to grip in cold temperatures and on snow/ice. They use softer rubber compounds and tread patterns that perform better than all-seasons in winter conditions.
chains
"...you may need some serious winter gear or to get your snow tires on or chains or have you. Well, why am I sending you an advertisement that has a beach and sun?"
Chains are extra grip devices you put on your tires for snow and ice. They can help you drive more safely when roads are slippery.
Tire chains are traction devices installed on the tires to improve grip on snow and ice. They’re often required or recommended for certain roads during winter storms.
air conditioning recharged
"...Or inviting you to get your air conditioning recharged in December. There you go. Logic sometimes needs to play a role in how we think about messaging, timing, weather, seasons."
“Recharging” the A/C means adding refrigerant so the air conditioner can cool again. If it needs it often, there may be a leak somewhere in the system.
Recharging a car’s air conditioning typically means adding refrigerant to restore proper cooling. If the system needs frequent recharges, it can indicate a leak that should be diagnosed.
baseline comparison
"You just have to create a baseline, compare population A to population B, and understand, did it drive retention?"
A baseline comparison means you look at what was happening before you ran the offer. Then you compare it to what happens after, so you can tell whether the offer actually made a difference.
A baseline comparison means measuring results against a prior period before the campaign or offer. This helps isolate cause-and-effect by showing what changed after the intervention.
retention
"...compare population A to population B, and understand, did it drive retention? Did it drive frequency of visit?"
Retention is how well you keep customers coming back. For a car shop, it means whether people return for service again after joining a program.
Retention refers to how many customers keep coming back over time. In an automotive shop setting, retention can be tracked through repeat visits after a loyalty program or campaign.
frequency of visit
"...did it drive retention? Did it drive frequency of visit? Did it drive a change in sales type?"
Frequency of visit measures how often customers return for service within a set time window. It’s a useful KPI for evaluating whether offers or loyalty programs increase ongoing maintenance behavior.
no shows
"...Did it drive a change in vehicle that came through the door, new, used, older, newer? You have to be able to understand what you're seeing... Did it reduce the number of no shows?"
No shows are when someone books an appointment but doesn’t show up. Cutting down on no shows helps the shop run more efficiently and reduces wasted time.
No shows are appointments where the customer doesn’t arrive. Reducing no shows improves shop utilization and can be a measurable outcome of reminder campaigns or scheduling changes.
Synchrony
"Then the other thing that we focus on a lot at Synchrony when we run campaigns or marketing initiatives is did it lower my marketing cost..."
Synchrony is mentioned as a business partner that helps shops with marketing and campaigns. The point is to use the data you already have to spend smarter.
Synchrony is referenced as a partner that supports small businesses with campaigns and marketing initiatives. The discussion focuses on using marketing metrics and available data to improve efficiency and ROI.
marketing cost per existing customer
"did it lower my marketing cost per existing customer or new customers, my cost of acquisition?"
“Marketing cost per existing customer” measures how much it costs to generate value from customers you already have. It’s useful for comparing retention-focused efforts versus acquisition campaigns.
cost of acquisition
"initiatives is did it lower my marketing cost per existing customer or new customers, my cost of acquisition? Was this one expensive?"
Cost of acquisition (often “CPA”) is the amount of money it takes to win a new customer. It’s commonly tracked alongside marketing spend to see whether campaigns are efficient or too expensive.
ROI
"Was this one expensive? Is this ROI too low? Is my cost per acquiring the new customer just through the roof?"
ROI is basically “did this spending pay back?” If the results aren’t worth the cost, ROI will look low and you may need to change what you’re doing.
ROI (return on investment) is a way to judge whether spending money on marketing or campaigns is paying off. If ROI is too low, the business may need to adjust targeting, messaging, or budget.
cost per acquiring the new customer
"Is my cost per acquiring the new customer just through the roof? Some of those cases, if it goes through the roof, you want to fail fast."
This is the “price tag” for getting a brand-new customer. If that number gets too high, it’s a sign you should rethink the campaign.
This is another way of describing cost per new customer, closely related to cost of acquisition/CPA. Tracking it helps businesses compare different campaigns and decide where to cut or invest.
fail fast
"Some of those cases, if it goes through the roof, you want to fail fast. Don't let that thing linger. Cut it off. You're out where it went wrong and try again."
Fail fast means you try something in a small way first. If it’s not working, you stop quickly and try a better idea instead of wasting a lot of time and money.
“Fail fast” means running small tests so you can quickly learn what isn’t working, then stopping the effort instead of letting it drag on. In a business context, it helps limit wasted spend when ROI is poor.
point of sale system
"A lot of our partners have subscribed to or purchased software that either through their point of sale system or their technology stack does have certain features. First off, know what you have."
A point of sale system is the software/register where you ring up sales and services. It can also keep useful records that help you understand your customers without buying new tools right away.
A point of sale (POS) system is where transactions are recorded, and it often stores customer and service history. The segment suggests using POS data to understand what resources and reporting features are already available.
OEMs
"So tap into your existing partners if you're a tire retailer. Talk to your OEMs. If there was a rebate that was being offered..."
OEMs are the car makers themselves. When a shop “talks to OEMs,” it means working with the vehicle brand’s programs, like promotions or rebates that can help customers save.
OEMs are Original Equipment Manufacturers—the companies that build the vehicles. In the context of tire retail and service, OEM partnerships can relate to promotions, rebates, and marketing programs tied to specific vehicle brands.
data privacy / sharing customer information
"Are they sharing that information back to you? Start with those that are closest to your business and where you already are engaging."
They’re talking about customer info—like name and contact details—and whether the shop gets that information back. If you don’t get it, it’s harder to follow up with customers and build repeat business.
The segment raises the question of whether customer data collected for promotions is shared back with the shop. That matters because it affects how effectively a retailer can follow up, measure results, and run loyalty programs.
customer engagement
"How are these data-driven loyalty programs shaping the future of customer engagement for the average shop owner? I appreciate the complexity of our world today..."
Customer engagement is basically how you keep in touch with customers and get them to respond. For a shop, it means things like timely texts, emails, and helpful updates that make people feel confident about booking service.
Customer engagement refers to how a business interacts with customers across channels—offers, messages, reminders, and follow-ups. In automotive retail, better engagement can improve trust and increase the likelihood customers choose your shop for service.
technology and loyalty platforms
"It's important to understand how technology and loyalty platforms and programs by virtue of the information that they offer and collect can help you be more efficient with every dollar that you have available to you."
A loyalty platform is an app or system that helps a business run rewards and keep track of customers. It can also help decide what messages to send so the shop doesn’t waste money on ineffective marketing.
Loyalty platforms are software systems that collect customer data and manage rewards, offers, and communications. When used well, they help shops run marketing more efficiently and track what’s working.
Request an Explanation
Heard something you'd like explained? We'll add it to this episode.
Sign in to request explanations for terms you heard.
Want to learn more?
Browse our glossary for plain-English explanations of automotive terms, jargon, and concepts.
Help improve this episode
See something that's not quite right? Our annotations are AI-generated and can sometimes miss the mark. Click the flag icon on any annotation to suggest a correction.