0:00 / 0:00
Is There Any Manual Swap You Shouldn’t Do? — Carmudgeon w/ Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep 211

Is There Any Manual Swap You Shouldn’t Do? — Carmudgeon w/ Jason Cammisa & Derek Tam-Scott — Ep 211

The Carmudgeon Show Nov 03, 2025 66 min
0:00
0:00

About this episode

Exploring the world of manual swaps, Jason Cammisa and Derek Tam-Scott dive into whether there are any manual swaps that should be avoided. They discuss the merits of manual transmissions in various cars, including the iconic Mercedes-Benz W140, and share personal stories about their experiences with manual swapped vehicles. The episode also touches on the rise of electric bicycles, highlighting a unique series hybrid bike that eliminates traditional drivetrain issues, making it a compelling topic for car enthusiasts.

Technical Too Afraid to Ask
Term

tire inflator

"...a new, more powerful charge and start unit that combines a charger, jump starter, and tire inflator all in one..."

A tire inflator is a tool that helps fill up car tires with air. It's useful when your tires are low on air and need to be pumped up.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

jump starter

"...a new, more powerful charge and start unit that combines a charger, jump starter, and tire inflator all in one..."

A jump starter is a small device that helps start a car when the battery is dead by giving it a quick burst of power. You connect it to the car's battery to get it running again.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

lithium batteries

"...I like smart lithium batteries more than..."

Lithium batteries are a kind of battery that can be recharged and are often used in cars. They are lighter and can store more energy compared to other types of batteries.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

battery tender

"battery tender. I had this one stored for probably 2 or 3 months and it just started and it wasn't hooked up to a tender..."

A battery tender is a tool that keeps your car battery charged when you're not using your car for a while. It helps make sure the battery doesn't run out of power.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Mercedes-Benz W140
Dinkun Chen (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Mercedes-Benz W140

"...to your tremendous surprise a W41 W140"

The W140 is a model of the Mercedes-Benz S-Class, which is a line of luxury cars. It was made in the 1990s and is recognized for its high quality and many features that make driving comfortable and safe.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

W140

"It's not functioning like all W140s. It has soft closed issues."

W140 refers to a specific generation of the Mercedes-Benz S-Class that was made in the 1990s, known for being very well-built and having many advanced features.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Lexus LS400
Calreyn88 (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Lexus LS400

"...because Lexus was to use a technical term kicking the [ __ ] out of them with the LS400. And so this car, the 140 came out in Germany and was immediately recalled..."

The Lexus LS400 is a high-end car that was first made in 1989. It's known for being very comfortable and well-made, helping Lexus become a popular luxury car brand.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

tire blowout

"...because they were blowing tires. They couldn't. There existed no tire in the world that could deal with that much mass and that much speed..."

A tire blowout is when a tire suddenly bursts and loses air, which can make it hard to control the car. This can happen if the tire is too old, damaged, or if the car is too heavy.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Fiat 124
Martin308GTB (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Fiat 124

"...I had driven lots of 124s and owned lots of 124s..."

The Fiat 124 is a small car that Fiat made from the late 1960s to the early 1970s. It was well-liked for its straightforward design and was sold in many countries, including the U.S.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Mercedes-Benz R129
Matti Blume (CC BY-SA)
Car

Mercedes-Benz R129

"...including R129s. And I vividly remember pulling out the..."

The R129 is a model of the Mercedes-Benz SL-Class, a luxury convertible sports car that was made between 1989 and 2002. It's recognized for its stylish looks and high-tech features for that era.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Mercedes-Benz S500
Ethan Llamas (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Mercedes-Benz S500

"...talked him into a 140 S500 or 500 SCL. Um would have been an S500 S500 S500."

The Mercedes-Benz S500 is a high-end luxury car that offers a smooth ride and many features. It's part of a series of cars known for being very comfortable and packed with technology.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Honda S500
Mytho88 (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Car

Honda S500

"... 10. And uh and so Mike had talked him into a 140 S500 or 500 SCL. Um would have been an S500 S500 S500."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
BMW 140
Dinkun Chen (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

BMW 140

"And so Mike found him a silver over gray 140, ordered him a silver over gray 140."

The BMW 1 Series is a small luxury car that offers a fun driving experience. The '140' is a specific version of this car that has more power and features than the base models.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

$100,000 car

"...when you've just bought a $100,000 car. For the"

A $100,000 car is a very expensive car, usually with high-end features and performance. These cars are often luxury brands or high-performance sports cars.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Volkswagen Egolf
Dinkun Chen (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Volkswagen Egolf

"I did this in my e-Golf because I knew you don't have to break the engine in an electric car."

The e-Golf is a type of car that runs on electricity instead of gasoline, making it better for the environment.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

limiter

"...and it hit the limiter so hard that it woke him up. [laughter] I was like this thing could do 170. It was pulling so hard."

A limiter is a safety feature in cars that stops the engine from going too fast. It helps prevent damage by making sure the engine doesn't rev too high.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Brand

Lexus

"...caught off guard by Lexus by, you know, Lexus brought in a car at $50,000..."

Lexus is a luxury car brand from Toyota, famous for making high-quality and comfortable vehicles.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Mercedes-Benz 126
Damian B Oh (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Mercedes-Benz 126

"...the 126 was nearing the end of its life. Correct. So 1989 and the Lexus, the LS400 absolutely did..."

The Mercedes-Benz 126 is a model of a luxury car that was made from 1979 to 1991. It was known for being very high-end and had many advanced features for its time.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Brand

Alpine

"No, it's Alpine. Oh, really? It was Alpine."

Alpine is a car brand from France that makes sporty cars. They are known for being light and fast, especially the A110 model.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Part

trunk closing plinth

"little thing. It has a trunk closing plinth that automatically extends so you don't..."

A trunk closing plinth is a part of the car that helps close the trunk lid automatically, so you don't have to touch it. This keeps the trunk clean and free of fingerprints.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

vacuum actuated

"It's vacuum actuated so that it's always clean."

Vacuum actuated means that a part of the car works using vacuum pressure, which helps it move automatically. This makes it easier to use without having to push or pull it manually.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

ESP

"Um trying to I mean it was it had ESP I think standard. Um or might have been in the six-cylinder cars."

ESP is a safety feature in cars that helps keep them stable and prevent sliding or skidding, especially when the road is slippery or when making sharp turns.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
7 Series
MB-one (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

7 Series

"Um but who drives a six-cylinder S-Class? I mean I mean really. And the funny thing is the six-cylinder S-Class cost more than the 8-cylinder 7 series."

The 7 Series is a luxury car from BMW, similar to the S-Class from Mercedes-Benz. It's designed for comfort and has many advanced features.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

salvage title

"That car also had a salvage title. Yeah, it had been wrecked a couple hundred thousand times."

A salvage title means the car was in a bad accident or had a lot of damage, and the insurance company decided it wasn't worth fixing. It can be risky to buy these cars because they might have hidden problems.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Part

18-inch wheels

"It came with these 18-inch monlock wheels and the dark wood interior. And it has the seats that the 600s later on got different seats from the rest of the cars..."

18-inch wheels are the size of the wheels on the car. Bigger wheels can make a car look sportier and can improve how it drives, but they might also make the ride feel bumpier.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Fiat 600S
Silvio Durante (Public domain)
Car

Fiat 600S

"...dark wood interior. And it has the seats that the 600s later on got different seats from the rest of the"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Fiat 500S
Jean-Pol GRANDMONT (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Car

Fiat 500S

"...except for in Canada where they also put those in 500s. God, I'm so sorry. I know all this. Uh, anyway, ..."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Fiat 500e
Alexander Migl (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Fiat 500e

"all associate those wheels with like a 500E or, you know, all the C43 AM >> C43, E55. Yeah. U..."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Mercedes-Benz 500E
Mr.choppers (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Car

Mercedes-Benz 500E

"I think we just all associate those wheels with like a 500E or, you know, all the C43 AM..."

The Mercedes-Benz 500E is a luxury car from the early 90s that has a powerful engine and sporty features. It was made with help from Porsche, which makes it special.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Mercedes-Benz C43
Calreyn88 (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Mercedes-Benz C43

"...associate those wheels with like a 500E or, you know, all the C43 AM..."

The Mercedes-Benz C43 is a sportier version of the C-Class car, designed for better performance and handling. It has a more powerful engine than regular C-Class models.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Mercedes-Benz W124
Mr.choppers (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Car

Mercedes-Benz W124

"I have a 264,000 mile W124, and it has much less steering play than your..."

The W124 is a model of car made by Mercedes-Benz that is known for being very reliable and lasting a long time. Many people appreciate it for its comfort and quality.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Rivian
Photo by Rivian (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Rivian

"I thought saying we have a Rivian and also we have a bike and that's actually not the case. The reason why is it's it embodies the Silicon Valley um idea."

Rivian is a company that makes electric trucks and SUVs. Their vehicles are designed for outdoor adventures and are environmentally friendly.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Bmw I3
Frank Schulenburg (CC0)
Car

Bmw I3

"... really this is more like a Chevy Volt where or a BMW i3 Rex where the gasoline engine powers a generator"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Part

derailleur

"Oh, the drivetrain. It's the derailleur and the chain. Um derailleur and chains are apparently the biggest problem area."

A derailleur is a part of a bike that helps change gears by moving the chain from one gear to another. If it doesn't work well, you can't shift gears properly.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Part

chain

"It's the derailleur and the chain. Um derailleur and chains are apparently the biggest problem area."

The chain on a bike is what connects the pedals to the back wheel. When you pedal, the chain moves and helps the bike go forward.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Mercedes-Benz SL
Matti Blume (CC BY-SA)
Car

Mercedes-Benz SL

"144. He also wants to manual swap his SL. It was the red SL in the >> Revelations"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Subaru 360S
Ghostofakina (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Subaru 360S

"will happily take every opportunity to [ __ ] on 360s and 355s and 430s. >> Therefore, all for RV8s. Ye..."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Pontiac Gtos
W. Bulach (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Pontiac Gtos

">> spales scutteras challengees uh GTO's uh TDFs. They're all going absolutely wacko"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Ferrari F40
Alexander Migl (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Ferrari F40

"...lose to being I don't know I want to call it like F40 like uh in terms of my driving enjoyment and and"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Aston Martin Vanquish
Alexander-93 (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Aston Martin Vanquish

"was a sensation. Uh I did recently drive a Vanquish Aston uh the first generation. So this is like 02..."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Mercedes-Benz CLK
Dinkun Chen (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Mercedes-Benz CLK

"say it was not as seamlessly brilliant as the CLK for a couple of reasons. One was the the the foot..."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Audi R8
Vauxford (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Audi R8

"...ike to interact with. And so if you drive like an Audi R8 uh with a single clutch automated manual or the"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Audi RS4
Matti Blume (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Audi RS4

"...hat engine is to interact in that car with say an RS4 which is an automatic. Uh and that's manual"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Ferrari F430
Lothar Spurzem (CC BY-SA 2.0 de)
Car

Ferrari F430

"that interaction. >> Uh have you ever driven an F430 swapped to a manual?"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Lancia Stratos
Calreyn88 (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Lancia Stratos

"...ght? And so the reason I brought the that MAT new Stratos up is because that swap was not done by MAT. So n..."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Honda Civic
MercurySable99 (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Honda Civic

"made a three-point turn like I was in a Civic was nothing and he was just how the [ __ ] did yo..."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Porsche Carrera GT
Alexander Migl (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Porsche Carrera GT

"...ething you definitely had to work around. But the Carrera GT, though I'm not personally a huge fan of"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Porsche 911
David Villarreal Fernández (CC BY-SA 2.0)
Car

Porsche 911

"five best bested possibly only by the 911 ST the current one which you've not driven yet, r..."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
BMW M3
MB-one (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

BMW M3

"...ast year, >> you said this also about the G uh 80 M3 >> M3 works. I wouldn't buy it with an"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Car

Suzuki Cappuccino

"...d it. It was I remember that and trying to keep a Suzuki cappuccino on a back road when I was basically"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Lamborghini Gallardo
Ermell (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

Lamborghini Gallardo

"I've also driven I showed up once to buy a Gallardo. I I don't know if you remember this. Um I don't ..."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
BMW E39
Dinkun Chen (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

BMW E39

"... to back off. But, uh, he had said has he had a a E39 530i. Um, and that was a great car to bring"
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
BMW M5
Vauxford (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

BMW M5

"...that car I never liked. Same way I feel about E39 M5. I don't like that manual either. Love it."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
BMW E36
Dinkun Chen (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Car

BMW E36

"...reason. It's such a strange fall because like the E36 shifter is fine."
Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
32 cars featured

Request an Explanation

Heard something you'd like explained? We'll add it to this episode.

Sign in to request explanations for terms you heard.

Want to learn more?

Browse our glossary for plain-English explanations of automotive terms, jargon, and concepts.

Explore Terms

Help improve this episode

See something that's not quite right? Our annotations are AI-generated and can sometimes miss the mark. Click the flag icon on any annotation to suggest a correction.

Report incorrect info
Suggest better explanations
Flag missing cars