0:00 / 0:00
My Most HEATED ARGUMENT Yet With a Dealership

My Most HEATED ARGUMENT Yet With a Dealership

0:00
0:00

About this episode

A heated debate between Tommy (a flat-fee car negotiation service owner) and Vic (a dealership-side voice) centers on why car buying feels rigged and what should replace the current system. Tommy argues commission should be removed, franchise laws should end, and manufacturers should sell more directly so consumers can shop like they do for phones. Vic counters that capitalism needs profit and competition, and that dealerships add value through incentives and infrastructure. They clash on whether incentives would disappear without dealers and whether direct-to-consumer would truly be cheaper.

Technical Too Afraid to Ask
Term

taxes

"Because the out-the-door price should just involve taxes, which is the same at every damn dealership, dude."

Here, “taxes” means the government charges added to the car’s price. Those charges can change depending on the state or local area, which is why the final total can differ between dealers.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

six and a half percent

"This is in Florida, or six and a half foot percent. If I buy a car in Florida, it doesn't matter where the foot by by the car, it's six and a half percent."

They’re talking about a specific sales tax rate (six and a half percent). That percentage affects the final total you pay, so it can make one dealer’s offer higher or lower than another’s.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Place

Florida

"This is in Florida, or six and a half foot percent. You were in Florida. If I buy a car in Florida, it doesn't matter where the foot by by the car, it's six and a half percent."

Florida is the state the speaker uses as an example for how sales tax is applied to car purchases. The point is that state tax rules can affect the out-the-door price, so negotiations can’t be compared using only the advertised vehicle price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

commission

"I believe commission should be removed out of the sale car sales experience today. I think it's one of the biggest causes of consumer trust."

Commission is extra pay a salesperson earns when they sell a car. If their pay depends on making the sale, they might be more focused on closing than on getting you the best deal.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

direct to consumer

"I believe that the easiest way for the dealership problem to be fixed is direct to consumer."

Direct to consumer means the buyer deals more directly with the seller, not through a dealership. The idea is that it can make pricing clearer and reduce pressure tactics.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

marking up rates

"I believe dealerships are not entitled to a profit. I believe that marking up rates should be illegal."

Marking up rates means the dealer charges you a higher interest rate than the underlying loan rate. That can raise your monthly payment and total cost.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

flat fee

"We charge a flat fee of a thousand bucks and we literally handle everything for you."

A flat fee means you pay one set price for the service. It’s not based on how expensive the car is, which can reduce incentives to upsell.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

trade

"The price of the car, the trade, the add-ons, the accessories, you sit back,"

A trade is when you turn in your current car to help pay for the next one. The value they give your car changes how much you’ll pay overall.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

add-ons

"The price of the car, the trade, the add-ons, the accessories, you sit back,"

Add-ons are extras you can be charged for on top of the car price. They can increase the total cost, so it’s important to know exactly what’s included.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

accessories

"The price of the car, the trade, the add-ons, the accessories, you sit back,"

Accessories are extra gear added to the car, like add-on items or upgrades. They can cost extra, so it helps to check whether they’re worth it.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

buyer's orders

"I mean, these people are presented buyer's orders with full breakdown and they're signing a piece of paper."

A buyer’s order is the dealership form that spells out what you’re buying and how much it costs. It’s basically the written record of the deal before you sign.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

off the door price

"our customers ask me all the time over the phone, what's the off the door price? I literally send them a screenshot."

The out-the-door price is the total you’ll actually pay at the end. It includes the car price plus taxes and fees, so it’s the best number to compare between dealerships.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

price details

"You can click it, click on price details, and it tells you the whole price with the taxes, fees, and all that."

Price details are the line-by-line list of how the final price is calculated. It helps you see what part is the car and what part is taxes and fees.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Topic

discount over the phone

"Now, if a customer is asking me for a discount over the phone, I haven't been allowed the opportunity to add value to the vehicle. I have no commitment."

They’re talking about negotiating a lower price by phone. The point is that the dealership may not have a chance to shape the deal before you ask for a discount.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

manufacturer incentives

"We found manufacturer incentives to get them to that price point. From the manufacturer to just the price point."

Manufacturer incentives are money the car company offers to lower what you pay. A dealer can use those incentives to make the deal cheaper, but you usually have to qualify.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

$7,500 credit

"Like I can see the $7,500 credit there. I can click and say, do I get this or not?"

That “$7,500 credit” is basically a set amount of money off the deal. The important part is whether you actually qualify for it.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Brand

Tesla

"Like they do on Tesla. Like I can see the $7,500 credit there."

Tesla is mentioned as an example of a company that shows incentives clearly online. The host is using it to argue that other brands could do the same.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Brand

Ford

"Wouldn't that be like a value? Like I don't want you to buy a Ford."

Ford is just the example car brand being discussed. The argument is really about how car companies should show incentives to shoppers.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

retail price

"The dealership, that's the dealership of the manufacturers who just did a retail price. That's the dealer's price on the car."

Retail price is the price shown to regular buyers as the starting number. The final price can change once incentives and dealer pricing are applied.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

dealer's price

"That's the dealership of the manufacturers who just did a retail price. That's the dealer's price on the car."

Dealer’s price is what the dealership wants to charge you for the car. It can be different from the manufacturer’s advertised price, especially after incentives.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

manufacturer money

"[474.5s] and they were giving you six grand off in manufacturer money, [476.7s] why wouldn't the manufacturer advertise that?"

“Manufacturer money” is discount help from the car company itself. It can be rebates or special financing that makes the car cheaper than the sticker price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

invoice price

"[503.5s] They might as well just charge MSRP. [504.8s] Yeah, so the manufacturer does make a profit on a deal [507.3s] even at invoice price."

Invoice price is what the dealer pays the car company for the car. When someone says “at invoice,” they mean the dealer isn’t charging much extra beyond that baseline.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

invoice vs MSRP pricing

"[515.9s] They're already making their profit. [517.2s] So this idea that invoice, now MSRP is the choice [520.2s] or is the price they pay is just not true."

They’re arguing about how to think about sticker price versus what the dealer pays. The takeaway is that incentives and pricing structure can make the “invoice vs MSRP” story more complicated than it sounds.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

reconditioning fee

"or go to the fine print in the details, I'm going to see the $2,000 reconditioning fee on there, correct? ... No, I'm talking about reconditioning fees because not every dealership charges reconditioning fees."

A reconditioning fee is money the dealership charges to “get the car ready” for sale. It’s usually added on top of the advertised price, so the final total can be higher than what you first saw.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

filing fees

"You will see all the fees, you will see all the state taxes and the filing fees and the outdoor price on the vehicle."

Filing fees are charges for the paperwork and administrative steps needed to complete the sale. They’re usually added on top of the car’s price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

outdoor price

"You will see all the fees, you will see all the state taxes and the filing fees and the outdoor price on the vehicle."

They’re talking about the “out-the-door” price—the total you’d actually pay at the end. It includes taxes and fees, not just the sticker price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

dealership fees

"Every dealership charges dealership fees, but that's irrelevant to the point, right? No, I'm talking about reconditioning fees because not every dealership charges reconditioning fees."

Dealership fees are extra charges a dealer adds to the transaction beyond the vehicle’s base price—often for processing, documentation, or other administrative costs. They can be used to inflate the final total even when the advertised price looks lower.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

limited availability

"even though I'm trying to push her to buy the car because, again, limited availability."

This is the idea that the car might sell soon or there aren’t many of them. The seller uses that to push you to decide faster instead of shopping around.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

advertise a lower price

"the reason why you don't put the reconditioning fee into the price of the vehicle is so you can advertise a lower price"

It’s basically about how dealers show prices. They may list a lower “starting” number to get you interested, then add extra fees later—so the total cost isn’t as low as it first looks.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

dealership model

"which is one of the reasons why people don't like the dealership model."

This is talking about how car sales usually work through dealerships. The host is saying some people don’t like it because the final price can be built from multiple parts, not one simple number.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

used cars

"You're saying used cars are what we're referring to right now. [971.5s] Used cars, used cars. [972.4s] Do you have reconditioning on new cars, too?"

Used cars are cars that someone owned before you. Dealers usually price them differently than new cars, often depending on condition and what work they’ve done to get them ready to sell.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Car

Volvo S60 Recharge

"OK, so I am looking at this Volvo S60 Recharge. [986.2s] You're saying, like, 2023 years, the price of the car"

The Volvo S60 Recharge is a Volvo sedan that can use electricity sometimes (like a plug-in hybrid). It’s not a full electric car, but it’s designed to be able to drive on electric power part of the time.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

title license

"I expect the price should be 26,995 plus tax title license."

“Title and license” are the costs for the paperwork to put the car in your name and get it registered. It’s usually added on top of the car’s sticker price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

payments

"For me to see the price, I have to go to see payments. I see payments. The only thing I see here is $523.54."

In dealership pricing flows, “payments” usually means the monthly payment estimate for financing. It can be shown separately from the vehicle’s sales price, which is why the speaker checks payments first and then switches back to see the actual sales price and OTD.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

out the door

"I can scroll down and now I see, I can finance or I can pay cash and the out the door is 32,299."

“Out the door” means the full total you pay to actually drive the car home. It includes the car price plus taxes and the paperwork/fees.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

sales tax

"You see everything, correct? $1,800. No, wait, wait, $1,800 in sales tax."

Sales tax is the government tax added to the price of the car. It’s usually calculated as a percentage, so the final total goes up after it’s included.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

estimated registration and fees

"[1235.0s] $2,800 in estimated registration and fees. [1239.5s] So now what is the estimated registration fees?"

It’s the dealer’s guess of what you’ll owe to get the car registered and pay the associated costs. The real number can be a little different after the state paperwork is done.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

documentation fee

"[1244.5s] includes estimated first year sales registration [1247.1s] for your new car collected by the dealer [1249.1s] and the documentation fee charged by the dealer [1251.5s] to prepare this."

A documentation fee is the dealer’s charge for doing the paperwork for your car purchase. It’s worth checking because it can add hundreds of dollars and isn’t the same everywhere.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

registration fees

"and they have no registration fees, right? Would you say that that's irrelevant?"

Registration fees are the costs to get the car legally registered with your state. They’re part of what you pay to make the car road-legal, so they should be included when comparing dealer offers.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

higher trim level

"Okay, can I ask you a question? We have a higher trim level. That dealership has lower trim level."

A trim level is the version of the car you’re buying, like the “more equipped” one. Higher trims usually cost more because they include extra features.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

BSVs

"We're not talking about sales tax. We're talking about $2,800 of BSVs."

“BSVs” sounds like an acronym for certain extra charges the dealer is adding. The key point is that these items can change the final cost, even if the car’s base price looks similar.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

supply demand issue

"That's exactly my point, [1429.3s] because of the supply demand issue that occurs."

It means the car is hard to get, but many people want it. When that happens, the price usually goes up.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

dealer markups

"And we're just going to charge regular price, [1445.1s] where in their market area, [1446.4s] they might pay 10 grand over"

A dealer markup is extra money the dealer adds on top of the normal price. They do it when the car is hard to find and people really want it.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

10 grand over

"where in their market area, [1446.4s] they might pay 10 grand over [1449.0s] and we're just asking for maybe five grand more"

They mean the dealer is charging about $10,000 more than the usual price. That extra cost is basically a markup.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

leverage

"but if you come in person and I'm going to say that, your presence is your leverage."

In a car deal, “leverage” just means who has the upper hand in negotiations. The speaker is saying the dealership thinks coming in person gives them more control over the price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Car

Transit

"Why do you do the same thing on your four transits? That's not a rare car at all."

The Transit is a Ford van that lots of businesses use. The argument here is that the dealership is treating it like it’s rare, but the speaker says it’s not.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

same trim, same mileage

"It's that simple. Regardless of the fees, I challenge you to find a better deal because you won't, Tommy."

This is basically “compare like with like.” The speaker wants you to look at cars with the same options (trim) and similar wear/usage (mileage) so the price comparison is fair.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Car

Toyota RAV4

"Okay, so your RAV4 is priced 14th on market without your fee of your $2,000."

The Toyota RAV4 is a very common SUV. Here, they’re talking about how its price compares to other listings, depending on whether extra dealer fees are added.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

priced 14th on market

"Okay, so your RAV4 is priced 14th on market without your fee of your $2,000."

They’re ranking the car against other similar cars for sale. The point is whether the price looks good or bad once you include the extra charges.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

monthly payment

"What type of monthly payment they're trying to be at? [1812.7s] And I point them in the right direction"

A “monthly payment” is what you pay every month to finance or lease the car. Dealers may focus on it because you can sometimes make it look affordable even if the total deal costs more.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

extra fees

"advertising $26,999 [1833.7s] as a sales price, knowing you have recon and extra fees [1836.9s] that are just profit margins"

“Extra fees” are additional charges the dealer adds on top of the car’s advertised price. The host is saying you should look at the full total, not just the sticker price they advertise.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

profit margins

"knowing you have recon and extra fees [1836.9s] that are just profit margins so you can advertise a lower price."

“Profit margins” basically mean how much money the dealer makes on the deal. The host is suggesting the dealer is making that money through add-on fees rather than the advertised price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

all in

"And your price, you told me earlier, [1841.3s] was more competitive with everything all in, [1843.3s] but it's not."

“All in” means the full total you’ll pay, not just the advertised price. The host is saying the real total isn’t as good as the sales pitch makes it sound.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

negotiate

"I'm saying the only way to get a competitive price [1848.2s] is to negotiate, which you're just proving"

“Negotiate” means you push back and try to get a better deal. The host is saying you may need to negotiate to reduce the total cost, not just the advertised price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

tax title

"If a car is priced $3,000 over and you're still paying tax title, right? All that because that price on the internet doesn't include any of that."

“Tax title” is the money you pay for taxes and for the paperwork to register the car and get the title. It’s usually required and can’t be skipped.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

price-to-get-you-on-the-door

"We don't try to price cars and then did kind of make their price to get you on the door"

This is when a dealership uses a low starting price to get you to come in, then the final cost ends up being higher. It’s basically marketing that relies on later changes.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

fees disclosed up front

"because we're able to disclose those fees up front and personal."

Disclosing fees up front means the dealership provides a clear breakdown of all charges early in the process, rather than revealing them later. In negotiation terms, it reduces the “surprise” factor and makes the offer easier to compare.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

tag

"[2306.4s] So do you not pay tax? [2307.6s] Do you not pay a tag on it? [2309.2s] Again, we're not talking about tax."

A “tag” is the license plate/registration you need to legally drive the car. It’s usually a required cost that gets included in the final price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

sales contract

"[2490.7s] of your new car, collected by the dealer, [2493.8s] documentation fee charged by the dealer [2495.7s] and the sales contract."

The sales contract is the paperwork that legally locks in the deal terms. It includes the final price and the fees you’re agreeing to pay.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

fine print

"Now, if I go to the fine print below that, [2499.0s] it says, sales tax includes $19.87, $50, estimated registration fee includes $425 [2521.9s] All right, so it's on there, right?"

“Fine print” is the detailed part of the paperwork where fees and add-ons are listed. That’s where you should look to make sure the final price is accurate and not padded.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

electronic fee

"it says, sales tax includes $19.87, $50, estimated registration fee includes $425 [2506.4s] registration fee, $999, $399 electronic fee, $15, $895, reconditioning fee,"

This is a dealership charge for paperwork/processing that they add to your total. You can ask what it’s for and whether you have to pay it.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

battery fee

"registration fee, $999, $399 electronic fee, $15, $895, reconditioning fee, [2515.2s] $8.50 limit on your battery fee."

This is a charge related to the car’s battery. Ask if they’re testing the battery, replacing it, or adding coverage—so you know what you’re paying for.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

out-of-the-door price

"Okay, but you know what's the first thing that people say when they call? What's the out-of-the-door price?"

The out-of-the-door price is the final total you’ll pay at the end of the deal. It includes taxes and fees, not just the sticker price of the car.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

FTC

"The FTC says the f***ing price has to be whatever it is with all of your fees minus taxes, including your dock fee, including your recon fee."

The FTC is a U.S. government agency that helps protect consumers from misleading advertising. In car buying, it’s brought up when dealers don’t clearly show the real total price and fees.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

dock fee

"The FTC says the f***ing price has to be whatever it is with all of your fees minus taxes, including your dock fee, including your recon fee."

A dock fee is money the dealer charges to cover the car’s shipping/arrival to the dealership. It’s usually added on top of the sticker price, so you want it included when comparing total costs.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

recon fee

"The FTC says the f***ing price has to be whatever it is with all of your fees minus taxes, including your dock fee, including your recon fee."

A recon fee is what the dealer charges to “get the car ready” for sale. It can include reconditioning work, so you should ask for it to be itemized and included in the total price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

one price model

"Plenty of dealerships do a one price model, dude. Plenty of dealerships do."

A “one price model” is a dealership pricing approach where the dealer advertises a single purchase price and doesn’t negotiate down from it. Supporters argue it reduces haggling and surprise fees, while critics say it can still hide costs in paperwork.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

FEC

"all of your fees into the price of the car, like the FEC is regulated, you would be transparent."

They’re saying some of the fees have rules and oversight. But the acronym isn’t explained in this clip, so it’s not fully clear what “FEC” means here.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

additional fees

"The FTC has said that price needs to include your dock fee and any other additional fees that are not taxes."

Additional fees are extra charges the dealer adds on top of the car’s base price. Here, they’re talking about whether those extras (as long as they’re not taxes) have to be included in the advertised price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

payment options

"The thing that you're asking, see payment options do, people don't do that."

Payment options are financing or payment structures (like monthly payment plans) used to present the deal. The speaker implies that focusing on payment options can obscure the true total cost compared with a clear out-the-door price.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

full breakdown of the price of the car

"[3407.9s] Disclose the full breakdown of the price of the car."

A full breakdown is a detailed list of the total price, including every extra charge. It helps you make sure you’re not surprised by fees that weren’t clearly shown at first.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
3 cars featured

Request an Explanation

Heard something you'd like explained? We'll add it to this episode.

Sign in to request explanations for terms you heard.

Want to learn more?

Browse our glossary for plain-English explanations of automotive terms, jargon, and concepts.

Explore Terms

Help improve this episode

See something that's not quite right? Our annotations are AI-generated and can sometimes miss the mark. Click the flag icon on any annotation to suggest a correction.

Report incorrect info
Suggest better explanations
Flag missing cars