0:00 / 0:00
Sport or entertainment? Why levelling the playing field is problematic for F1

Sport or entertainment? Why levelling the playing field is problematic for F1

0:00
0:00

About this episode

The hosts wrestle with whether F1’s “performance equalizing” rules turn racing into sport or scripted entertainment. They unpack FIA/F1 efforts to level power units and shift development toward the electrical/battery side, while questioning whether cost caps, tyre changes, and measurement/upgrade restrictions simply create new strategies and “gaming the system.” Hill and Herbert also argue that unpredictability—tire behavior, strategy, even “randomness”—is part of the appeal, but when rules feel engineered for outcomes, fans may feel results aren’t on merit.

Technical Too Afraid to Ask
Term

internal combustion engines, ICs

"So Damon, we've just had the first audio adjustment additional development upgrade opportunities of the internal combustion engines, ICs, that's a component of the PU, the power unit."

An internal combustion engine is an engine that makes power by burning fuel inside it. In F1, it’s the “burning” part of the car’s overall hybrid engine system.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

PU, the power unit

"opportunities of the internal combustion engines, ICs, that's a component of the PU, the power unit. Are you going to speak English in a minute?"

In F1, the “power unit” is the whole engine package. It includes the fuel-burning engine plus the hybrid/electric parts that help it make power.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

performance equalizing mechanism

"Okay, I'll stop with that. So basically it's a performance equalizing mechanism that the FIA and F1 together combined to try and bring everybody's internal combustion engines to roughly the same level."

A performance equalizing mechanism is a set of rules meant to make the cars more evenly matched. The goal is to reduce the advantage the fastest teams have so more teams can fight for results.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

leveling down

"And I think they've done the leveling up or the leveling down. Really, it's leveling down, isn't it? You've got the opportunity with cost caps and people who don't have teams that don't have the most points or they've got more space, but then maybe don't have the resources"

“Leveling down” means the rules try to reduce the advantage of the teams that are winning. Instead of only helping the backmarkers, it also limits the front-runners so the gap shrinks.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

cost caps

"But anyway, you've got a chance to, to equalize. Is that then no longer a sport is a question? Because if you've denied people the opportunity, which is part of the show in Formula One is, is sharing off the manufacturing and the design"

Cost caps are spending limits for F1 teams. They’re meant to stop the richest teams from having a huge advantage just because they can spend more money.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

make equalization mechanism

"And I think basically this make equalization mechanism is almost making that element redundant. It's, it's almost saying, if you get too far ahead, we're going to peg you back."

The “make equalization mechanism” refers to F1’s rule tools that aim to equalize competitiveness by limiting how far ahead one team can get. Here, it’s described as making the technical-innovation side less decisive by reducing the consequences of being ahead in development.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

peg you back

"It's, it's almost saying, if you get too far ahead, we're going to peg you back. And then it's more, is it more a sport then for the drivers because you've equalized the machinery"

“Peg you back” means “hold you down” a bit. The rules are trying to stop the fastest team from running away with it by limiting how big their advantage can be.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

gaming the system

"Ultimately, if you're talking about a totally level playing field, but it is quite interesting that, you know, we're now getting people gaming the system,"

“Gaming the system” means finding loopholes in the rules. Instead of just racing normally, teams try to get an edge by working the rules in their favor.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

FIA's method of measurement

"So we've had Red Bull has been measured as according to the FIA's method of measurement as having the strongest internal combustion engine."

The FIA is Formula 1’s governing body. They use official rules and tests to measure how strong each team’s engine is, so teams can be compared fairly.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

ice

"So these upgrades can only apply, be applied to the ice, the internal combustion engine part, not to the batteries and all that."

“ICE” here means the internal combustion engine—the fuel-burning part. The point is that the upgrade rules apply to that part, not the battery part.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

batteries

"So these upgrades can only apply, be applied to the ice, the internal combustion engine part, not to the batteries and all that."

In a hybrid F1 car, the battery stores energy that can be used to help the car accelerate. Here, they’re saying the upgrade rules don’t cover the battery side—only the engine side.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

aero upgrades

"So is, okay, you can say, yeah, but they brought aero upgrades and blah, blah, blah, yeah, maybe could be, but it's just, it is,"

Aero upgrades are modifications to the car’s shape and wings to make it stick to the road better and go faster. Hill is saying that even if aero upgrades happened, the timing still looks questionable.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

leveling up

"Yeah. Is the objective because it would make sense to conclude from this restriction on, [471.1s] on the leveling up the opportunity for, for other competitors to level up with the best [476.0s] power unit in, sorry, the best internal combustion engine in the sport, that their objective is to"

“Leveling up” means F1 rules try to make the cars closer in speed. That way, one team can’t dominate as easily.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

battery side

"The, the justification made [500.3s] was that they wanted to see the competition, the development competition be on the electrical side, [506.4s] on the battery side. And therefore, let's get all everybody's engines, internal combustion engines,"

The “battery side” is the part of the car that stores electrical energy. In hybrid F1 cars, that energy can be used to help acceleration, so teams may focus development there.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Topic

Hungary

"But unless you're saying that now, Ferrari have kind of, the starting gun [590.5s] has been fired, and when's the next time they're measured? After Hungary, so yeah, it does get [596.8s] measured again."

“Hungary” means the Hungarian Grand Prix on the F1 schedule. The hosts use it as a checkpoint for when teams will be compared again.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

strategy

"Yeah, strategy is the big picture and tactics, the whole thing and the nitty-gritty. Yeah, yeah."

Strategy is the big plan for the race—how you’re going to approach the whole weekend or race. Tactics are the smaller decisions you make moment to moment while racing.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

tactics

"Yeah, strategy is the big picture and tactics, the whole thing and the nitty-gritty. Yeah, yeah."

Tactics are the day-of decisions—how you act in the moment to carry out your plan. They’re the smaller moves you make while the race is happening.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

randomness

"They ask in the same question, okay, how can Haas win the next four races, for example? Yeah. You know, and not because they want particularly Haas, but it's just, we want a randomness."

Here, “randomness” means making race results less predictable—so the same team doesn’t always win. The idea is to create more variety in who can take the top step.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Brand

Haas

"They ask in the same question, okay, how can Haas win the next four races, for example? Yeah. You know, and not because they want particularly Haas, but it's just, we want a randomness."

Haas is one of the Formula One teams. They’re mentioned as an example of a team that might be able to win more often if the sport is made less predictable.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

Pirelli tires

"But I mean, do you remember when they brought in some Pirelli tires that 2012? In fact, they had five different winners in five races. I think it was eight in eight."

Pirelli makes the tires used in Formula One. Different tire designs and compounds can change how cars grip and wear during a race, which can make results less predictable.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

active car

"It's always annoying as hell when you, when somebody says, no, you can't, I mean, I was with Williams and they came up with the active car. But of course, the active car was so much better than everyone else's, it won everything."

An “active car” is an F1 car that uses computers to automatically adjust how it drives while you’re driving it. Instead of only the driver controlling everything, the car can change its behavior to help it go faster and stay stable.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

hybrid technology

"Maybe, I don't know. I mean, that's, in this case, they seem that the hybrid technology is important in that the, the manufacturers are interested in that. And I think that hybrid has"

“Hybrid technology” means the car uses two energy sources: a regular engine plus a system that captures energy and reuses it. In F1, that matters a lot because it can directly affect how fast the car is.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

power units

"In terms of Formula One, it's produced these incredibly efficient power units, which can, can scavenge and recover fuel and everything."

In Formula One, “power unit” means the whole hybrid engine package. It’s more than just the engine—there’s also energy recovery that helps the car use fuel more efficiently.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

scavenge and recover fuel

"In terms of Formula One, it's produced these incredibly efficient power units, which can, can scavenge and recover fuel and everything."

This is about getting energy back instead of wasting it. In hybrid race cars, braking and other moments can capture energy and then use it again to help the car go faster.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

nitrous oxide

"you'd have dragster engines with nitrous oxide and flames coming up back all the time. Well, that's not going to happen, is it?"

Nitrous oxide is a gas some race cars inject into the engine to get extra power for a short time. It helps the engine burn more fuel, so the car accelerates harder.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

team orders

"I can remember watching a McLaren 1-2 in Monaco once. And when I found out that they were playing team orders."

Team orders are when the team tells one driver to help the team’s result, even if it means not racing “normally” against a teammate. It can be controversial because it changes the outcome from what drivers might do on their own.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Car

Mclaren 12

"that it's not really what they thought it was, is how solid is that? I can remember watching a McLaren 1-2 in Monaco once. And when I found out that they were playing team orders. Oh, well, on Hamilton, I think it was. And I remember being really annoyed, because I thought,"

The McLaren 12C GT Sprint is a race car version of the McLaren 12C. It’s made to be driven in racing events rather than just on the road. People talk about it when they want to understand how well a “real racing” McLaren performs compared with what they expected.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

legislating for an outcome

"because it lends itself to that idea that you may be legislating for an outcome. [1235.1s] And also, it's where the teams would have got to anyway, if you just let them compete."

It means making rules with the goal of getting a particular result. In racing, people worry that if rules are written to “engineer” who wins, it can feel less fair and more like manipulation.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Place

Paris

"Oliver Mintsleff goes to see the FIA president apparently in Paris, [1245.4s] after this has come out that the Red Bull."

Paris is just the city mentioned as the meeting location. It matters here because it’s where the FIA leadership is involved.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Brand

Red Bull

"after this has come out that the Red Bull. It's got the best power unit. [1249.6s] It's got the best power unit. So then you start, people start thinking, whoa, what did they talk"

Red Bull is an F1 team. Here they’re being talked about as the team whose car has the strongest engine/energy system compared with the others.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

conspiracy theory whirlwind

"So then you start, people start thinking, whoa, what did they talk [1255.9s] about? Yeah. And then, you know, before we know it, there's this kind of conspiracy theory whirlwind."

They’re talking about how people can start assuming the worst when they don’t fully understand what’s going on. In F1, that can lead to rumors about teams or officials being unfair.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

regulation change

"but eventually they had to put a stop to it. They were going, you can't be losing viewers. [1405.2s] So they did a regulation change. They said, right, you can't change tyres, knowing that"

A regulation change is when the sport’s rulebook gets updated. In this case, the rules about tyres during races were changed, which can change how teams plan their strategy.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

tyres

"They were going, you can't be losing viewers. [1405.2s] So they did a regulation change. They said, right, you can't change tyres, knowing that [1411.7s] the Bridgestones that the Ferraris were on didn't last as long as the Michelins,"

In F1, tyres aren’t just rubber—they’re the main thing that provides grip. If one tyre type lasts longer than another, teams can go faster for longer or make fewer stops, which changes who wins.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Brand

Michelins

"They said, right, you can't change tyres, knowing that [1411.7s] the Bridgestones that the Ferraris were on didn't last as long as the Michelins, [1416.3s] that the competition was on."

Michelin is a tyre maker that supplies tyres for F1. Here, the key detail is that Michelin tyres lasted longer than Bridgestone tyres, which influenced strategy and results.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Brand

Bridgestones

"They said, right, you can't change tyres, knowing that [1411.7s] the Bridgestones that the Ferraris were on didn't last as long as the Michelins, [1416.3s] that the competition was on."

Bridgestone is a company that makes the tyres used in F1. In this story, the Bridgestone tyres weren’t lasting as long as the Michelin tyres, which helped decide who could compete effectively.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Car

Ferraris

"They said, right, you can't change tyres, knowing that [1411.7s] the Bridgestones that the Ferraris were on didn't last as long as the Michelins, [1416.3s] that the competition was on."

Ferrari is an F1 team. In this part, the speaker is talking about Ferrari cars and how the tyres they used affected how well they could compete.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Topic

level playing field

"I was just thinking about, I mean, because the FIA's job is to make it a level playing field [1488.2s] and also to prescribe the technical boundaries. But they're in the position now of saying, [1493.7s] we're going to penalise you if you do too well."

A “level playing field” means the rules are supposed to make sure no team has an unfair advantage. The speaker is saying that if the FIA starts punishing teams just for being better, it may stop being fair in a different way.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Topic

penalise you if you do too well

"and also to prescribe the technical boundaries. But they're in the position now of saying, [1493.7s] we're going to penalise you if you do too well. Which I think that used to be more the [1500.8s] remit of F1 itself."

This phrase refers to a sporting approach where teams that dominate are hit with penalties or restrictions. The hosts contrast it with an older idea where F1’s own remit was more about rules and competition rather than punishing success directly.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

competitive playing field

"[1687.2s] but without all the conspiracies and all the upsets questioning, [1694.7s] if, if we hadn't done that. And I just wonder what the competitive playing field would look like [1699.6s] without that."

“Competitive playing field” means how fair the competition is between teams. In F1, even when rules are meant to make things more even, teams can still find different ways to gain an edge.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

energy allowance

"[1707.3s] I think Max came up with it, which was you have a energy allowance. And whether it was fuel or [1714.6s] whatever, and you can't, you have to produce something."

An energy allowance is a rule that limits how much energy a team can use during a race. Teams then have to figure out the best way to use that limited energy to go fast.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

double diffuser

"[1743.3s] then there is a chance, I suppose, that if someone's going to come up with a much [1746.3s] clever idea than everyone else, or a double, a double diffuser situation,"

A double diffuser is an aerodynamic part under the back of an F1 car. It helps push air in a way that increases grip, and it’s the kind of design that can get into debates about whether it follows the rules.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Concept

levelling the playing field

"And I do think that this, this little competitive element that has been a new dimension of the [2005.3s] competitive element has arisen through, through this little bit of legislation."

“Levelling the playing field” means making the rules fairer so one team can’t run away with everything. The goal is to keep more teams competitive, so races are less predictable.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

Formula One

"which is, which is brilliant. I think it's, it's part of F1, isn't [2068.0s] it? Yeah. So, where are we on this? Where, where are you on this? You're, you're, I think,"

Formula One is the highest level of open-wheel racing. It’s where teams race cars designed for speed under strict rules, and the drama between teams/drivers is a big part of why people watch.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

lap time

"do you think Formula One's got it right in terms of the balance between if you take a lap time, how much is car and how much is driver?"

Lap time is how long it takes to drive one full lap around the track. In racing, even tiny differences in lap time can mean a big performance gap.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

refuelling

"it's a bit like when they had the problem with refuelling was that people drove at exact, at the maximum pace from qualifying through the race"

Refuelling means adding fuel during the race. The point being made is that when refuelling rules allow teams to stay at peak speed for too long, strategy and pacing don’t evolve much.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

qualifying

"people drove at exact, at the maximum pace from qualifying through the race through to the end."

Qualifying is when drivers try to set the fastest lap to decide where they start the race. The discussion is saying that if everyone can keep the same maximum pace, the race doesn’t change much.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
Term

sprinklers

"Bernie famously said, you know, we should have sprinklers and in a sudden rain, rain shower"

Here, “sprinklers” means an artificial way to make the track suddenly wet. The idea is that it could change how cars and drivers behave, like when real rain hits.

Sign in to suggest edits or report issues
2 cars featured

Request an Explanation

Heard something you'd like explained? We'll add it to this episode.

Sign in to request explanations for terms you heard.

Want to learn more?

Browse our glossary for plain-English explanations of automotive terms, jargon, and concepts.

Explore Terms

Help improve this episode

See something that's not quite right? Our annotations are AI-generated and can sometimes miss the mark. Click the flag icon on any annotation to suggest a correction.

Report incorrect info
Suggest better explanations
Flag missing cars

1 community members have helped improve this episode.