Trevor Long and Stephen Fennig dive into Tesla's autonomous driving capabilities, featuring insights from James Ward of Drive.com.au. James shares his firsthand experience testing Tesla's full self-driving feature on a long journey from Sydney to Melbourne, discussing its performance, limitations, and the implications of marketing terms like 'autopilot.' The episode also touches on the responsibilities of drivers using such technology and the future of autonomous vehicles in Australia, alongside a lively discussion with a new EV owner about their recent purchase.
James Ward from Drive.com.au took a Tesla on an epic road trip without driving - the car did it all. What he learned was fascinating.
What does it mean for the future of cars and driving
We talk to Tim who JUST picked up his new car!! Find out what and why!
Get in touch, SMS us thanks to Vodafone on 0477 657 657
All thanks to Uniden Dashcams and NRMA Insurance
"Just good at the new EV. Fingers crossed for that one."
EV means electric vehicle. These cars run on electricity instead of gas, making them better for the environment and often cheaper to run.
EV stands for electric vehicle, which is powered entirely by electricity rather than gasoline or diesel. EVs are known for being more environmentally friendly and often have lower operating costs compared to traditional vehicles.
"I followed quite closely all the reporting he did around the Tesla self-driving autopilot supervisor, whatever they call it."
Tesla Autopilot is a system that helps drivers by steering, accelerating, and braking automatically. However, drivers still need to be alert and ready to take over if needed.
Tesla Autopilot is an advanced driver-assistance system that offers features like lane-keeping, adaptive cruise control, and self-parking. It is designed to assist drivers but still requires them to pay attention and be ready to take control.
"What was the plan once you saw that Tesla was going to hit the go button on autonomous driving in Australia?"
Autonomous driving means that a car can drive itself without needing a person to control it, using technology to see and understand the road.
Autonomous driving refers to the capability of a vehicle to navigate and drive itself without human intervention, using a combination of sensors, cameras, and artificial intelligence.
"...when you first sort of assign the full self driving supervised software to the car, you have to go through and agree to a number of things..."
Full self-driving means the car can drive itself without much help from the driver. But the driver still needs to pay attention and be ready to take over if needed.
Full self-driving refers to advanced driver-assistance systems that allow a vehicle to operate autonomously under certain conditions. However, the driver must remain attentive and ready to take control at any time, as they are ultimately responsible for the vehicle's operation.
"...which is part of this supervision process that basically says, I as the driver am still in full control and in full responsibility of this vehicle..."
Driver responsibility means that even if the car can drive itself, the person behind the wheel is still in charge and must pay attention to what’s happening.
Driver responsibility emphasizes that even with advanced driving technologies, the driver is legally and ethically responsible for the vehicle's operation. This means they must remain alert and ready to intervene if necessary.
"...the most of the systems that we have at the moment that have distance, which is like an adaptive cruise control you'll see in any car..."
Adaptive cruise control helps your car keep a safe distance from the car in front of you by automatically changing your speed. If the car ahead slows down, your car will slow down too, and it will speed up again when the road is clear.
Adaptive cruise control is an advanced driver assistance system that automatically adjusts the vehicle's speed to maintain a safe distance from the car ahead. It uses sensors to monitor traffic and can slow down or speed up the vehicle as needed.
"...and a lane keeping function that you will see that, you know, will go around corners and bits and pieces that you'll see in most any modern cars."
A lane keeping function helps your car stay in its lane by watching the road markings. If you start to drift out of your lane, the car can gently steer itself back into the lane to keep you safe.
A lane keeping function is a safety feature that helps prevent unintentional lane departures by using cameras and sensors to detect lane markings. If the vehicle begins to drift out of its lane, the system can provide steering assistance to keep it centered.
"These are driver assistance systems. And the Tesla system is arguably significantly more advanced than any other level two system on the market controls for sure."
Level two means the car can help you drive by controlling some functions, but you still have to pay attention and be ready to take over at any time.
Level two refers to a classification in the SAE automation levels for driving systems, where the vehicle can control both steering and acceleration/deceleration, but the driver must remain engaged and monitor the environment.
"So it's kind of like it's a level two by law, but it's a level three by function, right?"
Level three means the car can drive itself in some situations, but you need to be ready to take over if the car asks you to.
Level three automation allows the vehicle to handle all aspects of driving in certain conditions, but the driver must be available to take control when requested by the system.
"But coming up, the car in front of me put on its right turn indicator. And so that model three moved around it."
The Tesla Model 3 is an electric car that is smaller and less expensive than other Tesla models. It's known for being fast and having a lot of high-tech features.
The Tesla Model 3 is a compact electric sedan known for its performance, range, and advanced technology features. It has gained popularity for being more affordable compared to other Tesla models while still offering impressive electric driving capabilities.
"...not to conflate autonomy with electrification because, yes, the Tesla is the autonomous platform..."
Electrification means using electricity instead of gasoline or diesel to power cars. It's part of the move to make cars more environmentally friendly.
Electrification refers to the process of replacing traditional internal combustion engines with electric powertrains in vehicles. This shift is part of a broader trend towards sustainable transportation and reducing emissions.
"...not all electric cars are autonomous and not all autonomous cars are electric, like in your big Venn diagram."
Autonomy means a car can drive itself without needing a driver. Some cars can do this, but not all self-driving cars are electric, and not all electric cars can drive themselves.
Autonomy refers to a vehicle's ability to operate without human intervention, often associated with advanced driver-assistance systems and self-driving technology. In the context of electric vehicles, autonomy can be a key feature, but it is not exclusive to electric cars.
"...drove me off the freeway to the driveway of the big supercharger site, which apparently was a new site."
A supercharger is a special charging station for electric cars that lets you charge the battery quickly. It's useful for long road trips when you need to recharge fast.
A supercharger is a high-speed charging station for electric vehicles, particularly those made by Tesla. These stations allow for rapid recharging of the vehicle's battery, enabling longer trips without long charging times.
Reverse is the gear in a car that lets it go backward. It's used when you want to back out of a parking spot or driveway.
In automotive terms, 'reverse' refers to the gear that allows a vehicle to move backward. It is an essential function for maneuvering in tight spaces or parking.
"Look, brands like Mercedes Benz, right? If you want to look at them as a good case,"
Mercedes-Benz is a well-known car brand that makes luxury vehicles and is also working on self-driving technology.
Mercedes-Benz is a German luxury automotive brand known for its high-quality vehicles and advanced technology, including safety and self-driving features.
"And I've been in in current Mercedes models that do the car to X warning where, you know, another car hits a pothole"
Car-to-X communication is a system that helps cars talk to each other and to things like traffic lights, which can help prevent accidents and improve traffic flow.
Car-to-X communication refers to the technology that allows vehicles to communicate with each other and with infrastructure to enhance safety and traffic management.
"...ke over. But what if Joe Public sees a shiny new Model Y ticks the box and goes, this is amazing for self..."
The Tesla Model Y is a type of car that runs on electricity instead of gasoline, which means it's better for the environment. It's like a small SUV that has lots of space inside and can drive itself to some extent, making it very modern and convenient.
The Tesla Model Y is a compact all-electric SUV that combines the performance and technology of Tesla's electric vehicles with the practicality of an SUV. It has gained attention for its impressive range, advanced autopilot features, and spacious interior, making it a popular choice among electric vehicle enthusiasts and families alike.
"...compare that with what you've done in an autonomous style vehicle. And you start to really see."
An autonomous vehicle is a car that can drive on its own without needing a person to control it. It uses special technology to see the road and make decisions, like stopping for traffic lights or avoiding obstacles.
An autonomous vehicle is a car that can drive itself without human intervention, using a combination of sensors, cameras, and artificial intelligence to navigate roads and traffic. This technology is often associated with companies like Tesla, which has been at the forefront of developing self-driving capabilities.
"I had I've had it had a Tesla years ago and that summon feature was was a beta when I had my Tesla back in 2018."
The summon feature lets your Tesla drive itself to you or park itself without you needing to be inside the car.
The summon feature allows a Tesla vehicle to autonomously navigate to the driver or park itself without anyone inside, showcasing the car's advanced autonomy capabilities.
"And then the second line was, oh, I'm not getting one of those Chinese cars either."
Chinese cars are vehicles made by companies in China. Some people are cautious about them because they think they might not be as good as cars from other countries.
Chinese cars refer to vehicles manufactured by automotive companies based in China. In recent years, several Chinese automakers have gained international attention for producing affordable vehicles, including electric models, but they may still carry a perception of lower quality compared to established brands.
"Well, well, we are rusted on Subaru people until an hour ago. Well, love our airbag. And so immediately you say, well, what's Subaru doing?"
Subaru is a car company from Japan that makes vehicles known for their ability to drive well in bad weather, like snow and rain. They are popular for their safety features.
Subaru is a Japanese automaker known for its all-wheel-drive vehicles and boxer engines. They have a strong reputation for safety and reliability, particularly in regions with harsh weather conditions.
The BMW E30 is a model of the BMW 3 Series, which is a popular line of compact cars. The E30 version is especially loved by car fans for its style and how fun it is to drive.
The BMW E30 is the second generation of the BMW 3 Series, produced from 1982 to 1994. It's known for its classic design and engaging driving dynamics, making it a favorite among enthusiasts.
"...maybe we'll try one of these Chinese cars and had a drive in the Geely and then loved the BYD7..."
Geely is a car company from China that makes different types of vehicles, including electric cars. They are becoming more popular around the world.
Geely is a Chinese automotive manufacturer known for producing a range of vehicles, including sedans, SUVs, and electric cars. The company has been expanding its presence in international markets and has invested in various automotive technologies.
"...Had a go on a Polestar, went in the BMW IX..."
Polestar is a brand that makes electric cars, and it started from Volvo. They are known for their stylish and high-performance vehicles.
Polestar is a performance electric vehicle brand that originated from Volvo and Geely. They focus on high-performance electric cars with a strong emphasis on sustainability and cutting-edge technology.
"...went in the BMW IX. But the wife wasn't sold on any of them..."
The BMW iX is a fully electric SUV made by BMW. It has a lot of modern technology and is designed to be eco-friendly.
The BMW iX is an all-electric SUV that represents BMW's commitment to electric mobility. It features advanced technology, a spacious interior, and a focus on sustainability.
"...there's this thing I'm reading about X-Pane that sounds good."
X-Peng is a car company from China that makes electric cars with smart technology. They are working on features that allow cars to drive themselves.
X-Peng Motors is a Chinese electric vehicle manufacturer known for its smart, connected electric cars. The company focuses on integrating advanced technology and autonomous driving features into its vehicles.
"...oh, you want to try this Zika X? And she jumped out of that and said, I love this car."
The Zika X is a small car made by the Zika company. It's designed to be efficient and easy to drive, making it a good choice for city driving.
The Zika X is a model from the Zika brand, which is known for its compact and efficient vehicles. It often appeals to those looking for a smaller car with modern features.
Select text to request an explanation
This is Two Blokes talking electric cars with Trevor Long and Stephen Fennig.
Thanks to NRMA Insurance and UNIDEN.
Great to have our company.
I've just realised Stephen for the first time that there's two intros.
Oh.
One of them says my name first, the other one says your name first.
And that's obviously for fairness.
But it's funny because every now and then in the video I point and then I get it wrong
and I'm like well how did I get that wrong?
The last week it was fine.
The last show is right.
It's very weird anyway.
You're just realising that, aren't you?
I am just realising that.
Thank you to our intro people.
Swirl the uptake.
Really good stuff.
Two Blokes talking electric cars proudly brought to you by NRMA Insurance, a help company
helping Australians protect what matters most for over a hundred years and UNIDEN Smart
Dash Cam.
Get yourself a dash cam.
Get it front and rear.
When you look at the packaging all their models, if it comes with an R on the end, that means
there's a rear camera as well.
Be smart.
Get a smart dash cam.
UNIDEN has got you covered.
We've got a fun show today.
We have a caller later.
Hopefully they answer their phone because I think almost right now they are picking up
their car.
If we time it right, we're going to speak to someone who literally just picked up their
car.
Just good at the new EV.
Fingers crossed for that one.
I also want to catch up with James Ward from drive.com.au because I followed quite closely
all the reporting he did around the Tesla self-driving autopilot supervisor, whatever
they call it.
So that was something I wanted to do.
So let's not muck around here.
Let's just get cracking here on Two Blokes talking electric cars.
Thank you, or Babu Bhatt there, just from Seinfeld with the one thing you know.
Two Blokes talking electric cars.
We'd love to hear from you.
Any time you want to get in touch, if you want to talk anything electric cars, you're
in the market.
You've just bought one.
You've only bought one for a long time.
It doesn't matter.
We love hearing from you.
Even if you're negative about it.
I don't mind.
Let's talk less.
We want to hear what you think.
We want to know why.
That's your thoughts.
Let's hear it.
Send us a text or a WhatsApp.
Thanks to Vodafone.
04777657.
Now, Steven, a month or so ago, I came across a great piece of content from James Ward
at drive.com.au.
When Tesla announced that the autonomous driving feature was finally coming to Australia, the
autopilot, it was a big deal because this was something they've been talking about
for ever.
Long time coming.
They were talking about it since I had a Tesla.
Frankly, false advertising for over a decade, something that you could buy but not use.
But anyway, let's move on from that.
And James decided to put it to the test by taking it on a decent drive.
So the director of content for drive.com.au is James Ward.
And he's on the line.
Good day, James.
How are you doing?
Good day, guys.
I'm well.
I'm well.
Talk us through the plan.
What was the plan once you saw that Tesla was going to hit the go button on autonomous
driving in Australia?
What did you want to do with it?
Yes.
So look, when they had that initial media launch and the couple of guys, they drove it around
in town and they sort of went through and said, yeah, wow, gee whiz, it's pretty impressive.
And I was talking to the guys from Tesla and said, oh, how does it handle a long trip?
What is it?
Yeah, we're very curious to know what are the limitations of this system.
And they basically went, ah, look, we don't really know because we haven't really done
it.
We've done testing and there's obviously been a lot of testing in the US.
But no one had ever sort of gone, let's try and see what it can do in all these cases.
And I thought, you know what, let's just find out.
So with they had a vehicle available, I had a day available and I flew up to Sydney, picked
up a car from the Tesla office there in Alexandria.
And literally with the, now let's be really clear, I'm not a Tesla aficionado by any stretch.
This is actually, I spent longer in that car on this one drive than I have had time in
any Tesla at any point at any time combined up until that point.
I just, I kind of haven't really got on the big T train.
And so a lot of the use of the vehicle was pretty new to me.
There was a lot of, yeah, a lot of the features and things.
The guys gave me a quick run through and literally said, okay, you're ready to go.
And you've got to, when you first sort of assign the full self driving supervised software
to the car, you have to go through and agree to a number of things, which is part of this
supervision process that basically says, I as the driver am still in full control and
in full responsibility of this vehicle, regardless of what it says on the box, I'm still the
bag of meat who's driving this car.
And from that point, literally put in the Sydney office destination and had it drive
me supervised from Alexandria to North Sydney as a bit of a throw in the deep end.
And then the next morning, we strapped a bunch of cameras to it.
And I said, okay, in the driveway there in North Sydney said, take me to our office in
Melbourne, in South Melbourne.
It came up and said, all right, that's going to be, you know, 866 kilometres.
I reckon you're going to need to stop in Goldman and Holbrooke and let's go.
And yeah, there she goes.
So let me get it.
So this is the full self driving.
But the rule is you still have to have hand on the wheel or what's the, what are the rules?
No, well, this is, this is it, right?
Like, and so this is level two.
So in Australia, level three, which is that the driver needs to be there, but doesn't need
to be involved, the car is making decisions.
That is not legal in Australia.
You can't have a level three car or beyond.
And so the most of the systems that we have at the moment that have distance, which is
like an adaptive cruise control you'll see in any car and a lane keeping function that
you will see that, you know, will go around corners and bits and pieces that you'll see
in most any modern cars.
That is level two, because you as the driver are still driving the car.
These are driver assistance systems.
And the Tesla system is arguably significantly more advanced than any other level two system
on the market controls for sure.
Yeah, but because of the supervision layer in there, you need to be, you need to be
concentrating because there's a camera looking at you looking at the road.
It falls under our level two rules.
So it's kind of like it's a level two by law, but it's a level three by function, right?
And it's sort of a bit of a gray area there.
You can't say it's a level three car because it's legally it's not.
And because of the supervision layer, like in the US, they don't have that.
So you can read a book while you're using FSD.
And that's why in Australia, it is FSD dash S.
It is full self-driving supermarkets.
But, you know, Elon has been marketing it as autonomous autopilot for a decade.
So, hey, what is the rules matter?
James, what is the rules matter?
And this is it.
Like this has been one of the things that I've had.
And look, I am an outward not Tesla fan, particularly around some of that marketing
because look, we're in the bubble, right?
We we read the things.
We're we're professionals.
We know what we're doing.
So when previous to to FSD, if you had a car that said it was on autopilot,
we know that's just fancy marketing term for cruise control because that's what it that's what it did.
But, you know, Joe Public out there sees the word autopilot
and thinks this thing's going to just drive itself.
That's been my theory from the very, very get go.
I feel like it's just some deep marketing.
True. In Germany, they actually sought to have the the name revoked
because it was deemed to be misleading in that way.
And if you recall, in Melbourne, a couple of years ago, there was a nasty accident
where a woman was running to get onto the tram
and she came out from behind a tree to jump onto the tram.
And another lady driving a Tesla struck her and her defence at the time
was that the car was on autopilot and it made front page news.
Now, if she had said, oh, my car was on cruise control,
she would have been laughed into the back of the Divivan straight away.
It's like, you're a moron.
You don't do that.
Whereas as soon as she said, oh, but it was on autopilot,
people go, ah, is this setting up a false expectation?
As it happened in that case, it wasn't.
She's just a double moron in that she wasn't paying attention and lied.
So but it's this whole thing.
So when you're buying a car that has full self driving,
what about you?
But that sounds like it's going to fully drive itself.
And in many ways, it really does.
Like I will be very clear here that that trip down, it was remarkable.
And was it remarkable from the get go?
Like you say, North Sydney.
So for people that don't live in Sydney, leaving North Sydney
to go to Goldman as a first stop, yeah, there's some serious motorways.
But you've got to get to the motorway first.
And that's going to involve probably the Harbour Bridge,
which, by the way, is under some serious construction right now.
This is how to handle those first 10 Ks.
It impressed me within the first 200 meters about what it would do.
And then you sort of the light bulb goes on.
You're like, this is not like any other vehicle.
And so coming up, I don't know if you know North Sydney well,
but we're near the corner of near Blues Point Road there.
And it pulled out of the street.
And you think, Waco, and it comes to a stop and it stops at the intersection.
You think, all right, yeah, we're working.
But coming up, the car in front of me put on its right turn indicator.
And so that model three moved around it.
It went left to go because we were going straight ahead.
So we moved to the left to avoid the car that had stopped to turn right
at the at the lights.
And it's that that you go, OK, this is this is actually making active decisions.
And it's doing things.
And I look, I'm going to preface all of this because we'll have a bit of a laugh.
But it did absolutely nothing at any point that made me feel nervous,
unsafe, at risk, anything. Wow.
It did a whole journey of things, the whole time, the whole journey.
So it is incredibly risk averse.
It did plenty of things that frustrated me because it was like,
she's, I would have changed lanes before now, I would have.
I would be over there right now.
And it certainly got lost a couple of times from a navigation perspective
because it sits in the left lane and there's a couple of points in Sydney
tunnels where you've got to be in the right lane to take the the tunnel merge.
So it got lost and made a couple of weird kind of navigation decisions.
But it never did.
It didn't go the wrong way down on one way street.
It didn't pull out into it.
It did absolutely nothing that required a safety intervention.
So on that side of things, massive tick.
Yeah, right.
And look, I was laughing because I don't know if you've ever written
anything about Tesla in your life, it's like it's like there's a
there's a global kind of media awareness, awareness network.
Thousands of monkeys on their typewriter in cable somewhere,
all just will leap upon you.
And yeah, the Tesla fandom, which is a group of people
I haven't had a lot of nice things to say about in the past.
I think I I wrote an op-ed saying I want to drive a Tesla,
but I don't want to be a Tesla driver helps.
And you don't think they don't do the whole trip.
So I went for zero intervention.
I went, OK, if you I know we're going straight ahead here.
But if you decide to turn left, that's your choice.
Let's see where we go.
So I let the car make its decisions and put itself in the lane that it wanted
to and kind of went, OK, well, it's been in the wrong lane.
It's made a navigation decision.
It's how is it going to recover from this?
That's right. So I wanted to see what it would do.
And of course, all the Tesla morons are there going,
oh, you're supposed to.
You could put your indicator on it will change lanes or you can do this
and speed up. And I'm like, yeah, but you was.
That's the point.
Drive the damn car.
If you're going to press all your buttons, just drive the bloody car.
Just on that, James, you're a car guy, right?
So you enjoy driving.
Right. Was this a little boring?
Just sitting there and letting the car go this.
Well, this is this is my this is my big thing.
And as as tech guys, you'll get this when the iPad came out and we all went,
wow, that's so cool.
I want one, but I don't actually know why or what I'm going to use it for
because it's not portable like a phone and it's not flexible like a laptop.
And so this is the same as an experienced driver.
This is slower.
It makes decisions that probably are more risk averse than you would
or less aggressive than you would.
It may get lost.
It may do things a bit weird and you've got to concentrate the whole time.
So why not just drive?
If you are a nervous driver, it's probably not the best thing
for you to be doing at this point because you you do need to be ready
to to intervene each could you should you feel unsafe?
And so it's not an experience.
Not a cheap option.
So at what point?
Who is this for?
And I suppose it's an amazing toy like it's like when the iPad came out.
If you have this and you go check this out, it's it is remarkable.
And and I am genuinely, genuinely impressed with how clever this is.
And really, look, I think as as adults talking, we could say,
this is the doorway to the future.
This is a showcase of what can be done.
And even though our rules are capped at level two and you've got to have
the supervision, this is opening up the door to what is the next generation
of autonomy on Australian roads.
So we can see the future pathway for this.
But right now it's a cool toy.
And it is. It's unless you unless you're going to talk about it
on Twitter or YouTube about it.
What's what's the point of it?
Because if I as a Tesla driver, you will talk about it on Twitter.
That's pretty much where I was going with that.
Yeah. And you know, I think I'm with you.
I I think I would be frustrated.
I'm I respect the fact that you did zero intervention because I'd be first.
I'm frustrated when Waze tells me to go a different way.
And I'm like, dude, that's silly.
So I would get I can't imagine you would be frustrated.
I'd be if the car just went a different way.
I'm like, what are we doing here?
So I'd probably be into the point where I just may as well drive.
You might as well drive.
And that's it. Like the idea that it's going to do
it like it did everything that you would.
And so probably the most clever thing that I was impressed by at one point
on the Hume, it went into a contraflow for road work.
So it's slow to 40 cross over the center median.
And you're going from your two up to down dual carriageway becomes
a one up one down at a managed speed limit.
And it went through that without fault.
And, you know, it did that arguably better,
better than many drivers manage that kind of thing.
But then there were points where, you know, I was sitting 10 percent under
the speed limit. So where it's 110 on the Hume,
I would have my cruise control on one 15, probably one 20.
I was going to say, yeah, do you think that was battery conservation, though?
Because, you know, those speeds can kill a battery.
Well, yes and no.
And I sort of I was quite careful not to conflate
autonomy with electrification because, yes, the Tesla is the autonomous platform,
but not all electric cars are autonomous and not all autonomous cars are electric,
like in your big Venn diagram.
You looked at this as being a test of autonomy, not a test of the electrification of the car.
But on that side, when it said, hey, we're going to Goldman
and it then drove me off the freeway to the driveway of the big supercharger site,
which apparently was a new site.
I was going to say, did you go to the new one?
Yeah, it's like 20, 20 stalls.
Yeah, the new one.
And so I had to take over and drive it in and back into a bay.
And it's very fast and all that sort of stuff.
But when I was testing it with the Tesla guys on the Monday when I picked it up,
we said, OK, to get to a charger,
put in the Alexandria one there in Sydney.
It went in the driveway and reversed itself into a bay.
So depending on the charger, it can basically be door to door, right?
Like it is incredibly clever what it will do.
And so that window to the future that you talked about, like with the iPad,
it's a great analogy because I'm hearing from you
that you really did open a door to the future where you went, OK,
so there's something in this autonomy thing.
And you can you can only imagine, right, if they can back a car into a store,
you can imagine a robotic arm putting the thing into the charge.
Like it's kind of it's only a that's right.
It's only a little step away.
So did this give you clarity on Elon's view of, say, Robo taxis, for example?
Look, absolutely.
If you look at what this can do today and again,
what what would it do?
Because the argument is always you've got your trolley problem
you know, from from the ethical mindset.
But then the argument is if you're in a utopian city that's brand new
and every single car is using, you know, autonomy,
capabilities and car to ex communication, then you've got to you've got
a utopian mobility solution there.
But you know, as I stand in the office now and look out at a beaten up VE
Commodore parked across the street, not everyone is driving
a brand new fully flash autonomous vehicle.
And so, yeah, no.
And so the idea and again, this was one of the questions that was asked after it.
And it was the, you know, I said, I think on the video, it's the it's the
does a tree fall in the forest, make a sound kind of thing.
Because they're saying, oh, what will it do if a kangaroo jumps out?
It's like, well, a kangaroo didn't jump out.
So I don't know.
And I can't say that we find because it didn't happen and even with potholes.
What I noticed is, and this is, you know, coming through New South Wales
was pretty good. As soon as you get into Victoria, holy crap.
You are the quality deteriorates immediately.
But it just sat in the road.
It sat in the center of the lane and was doing a, you know,
like it was it was lane managing very well.
Did it move around to avoid any imperfections in the road?
No, it didn't.
Were they big enough to upset the car?
No, they weren't.
And so the question really then does if you,
if the pothole was big, would it have avoided it?
And I don't know.
So there's a lot more that kind of needs to be done here.
But I suppose the test of this is not to be
well, the use of this is not to be tested in extreme cases.
So you go and find a windy unpaved
poorly surfaced country road with no line markings.
What does it do there?
Because realistically, when you're on a tier one road like the Hume,
it did a very good job.
When going around and to your point about the roadworks
and shenanigans around Sydney, it managed all of that exceptionally well.
It just got lost in those new tunnels, which I'm going to say
happens to humans every single day.
You find them working there, you lose your map.
Absolutely. Now, James.
That's it, right?
Like, yeah.
And it says turn left to Dremoyne and you go, I don't know what Dremoyne is.
Send me to Newcastle, man.
Now, James, you'd have to.
I think you've admitted that Tesla's like way out in front
with the self driving for among the car manufacturers.
Who is anyone else anywhere near Tesla in this area?
Or are the other car manufacturers just thinking, well,
we really don't need to worry about this right now?
No, look, I would say that, yes, they are.
Look, brands like Mercedes Benz, right?
If you want to look at them as a good case,
they have level three systems that operate in some markets
and they but they are a more they're a very risk averse company
when you think about it.
And look, they've actually come out and said if you are in one of our
autonomous drive modes and our car causes an accident,
we will take the blame.
It can be involved in an accident,
like if it's something out of nowhere, it's OK.
But if it causes, they will take the blame.
But this is the thing.
You've got a traditional brand like Mercedes Benz
that will operate in a more conservative layer,
going a little bit slowly, slowly,
catchy monkey before this comes out to consumers.
Because, you know, you could go back decades
and see when when Benz would show those videos of cars
following like a centipede along an auto barn
because they could all map the car in front and blah, blah, blah.
And I've been in in current Mercedes models that do the car to X
warning where, you know, another car hits a pothole
or has to break for an animal.
It will warn other cars in that area that there is an obstacle ahead.
That's that's live now.
But no other company, regardless of how advanced they are,
is putting it in the hands of consumers, except for Tesla.
And so part of that is like, you know,
and look, I'm on 60 Minutes this weekend talking about this.
And I kind of use the it's a terrible, nerdy thing.
But I use the Spider-Man quote.
It's with great power comes great responsibility.
The full self driving capability of that car is remarkable.
It is great power.
But that responsibility lies in the hands
of the people behind the wheel still.
And the three of us can do it.
We're we're cognizant of what this technology is, what is happening.
And we are ready to take over.
But what if Joe Public sees a shiny new Model Y ticks the box
and goes, this is amazing for self driving.
I'm going to tune out or I'm not going to pay attention.
Even though that camera is looking at me,
I'm just going to stare off blankly into the distance.
What happens if something goes wrong?
And it's like all these things.
It's brilliant until it isn't like it hasn't been tested in Australia
with with a with a terrible outcome.
The very fact that Tesla said to you that they don't know
because they haven't tested a long drive.
Troubled me so greatly at the very start of this call.
I mean, my question at this point,
based on everything you've seen and done and said here is,
should this be allowed right now?
Like genuinely, should Tesla have been allowed
to release this in Australia, do you think they look?
It lets and again, I'm I'm not a I'm not a massive advocate
of the brand's approach to things, but they do have.
You look at what they're doing.
They were a non-legacy brand for this.
They started Clean Sheet of Paper and this was their goal.
They're they're a long game player.
This idea of of autonomy is not something that they've got.
Oh, let's slap that into the car that's, you know,
maybe three years into its lifespan.
This is something they've been developing.
And you look at what they've done in the US
and how much it's evolved.
Like there was obviously, you know, plenty of things
that have happened that haven't gone well for it,
but they're constantly updating and evolving and improving this.
But then giving it to consumers to live test,
which arguably gives them the best data
because you're dealing with real world randomness.
And it's like we've seen with with ADAS systems
on some of the new Chinese cars because you'll get in one
and it'll be like, oh, my God, what is going on?
And they'll show you this facility
that got built in the last 18 months
and it's got perfect line markings
and billiard table smooth asphalt.
And they go, look, it performs brilliantly there.
But in the real world, where there are potholes
and kangaroos and missing line markings, the systems fall down.
And so Tesla, while, yeah, OK, we could sort of go,
oh, I don't know, do we really trust humanity
with this technology?
You know, you mentioned line markings, right?
I was watching the video and there was a point where I think it's
when you've left the gold and supercharger
onto the big roundabout over there.
Oh, yeah, crosses the roadside.
You're in the wrong lane.
The lane you're in is the left turn lane.
Yeah. And it goes, no, no, I'm going to go straight here.
Now, I'm assuming, and I think I'd give it full credit
if there was another car next to it,
it wouldn't have just gone over there because it would detect that.
Correct. You should have got a fine for that.
If there was a policeman there, you would have absolutely got a fine.
You can't blame Tesla.
That kind of stuff, I don't know, I just feel like that kind of stuff
is the thin edge of the wedge.
And that's it.
You, so if I had done that and Johnny Hopper had been there
and gone, mate, what are you doing?
You're in the wrong line.
That's just, you know, whatever the fine is.
I can't go, bloody Elon.
No, I am responsible and I am.
And that's it. You behind the wheel, you are responsible.
And yeah, I was letting the car make decisions.
And yeah, I saw that going, I don't know, bro.
We all say we're going straight ahead here
and you're in the left turn lane.
You do you, though.
And it's and even actually the funniest one is when it parks
at McDonald's when I stop for a coffee
and it's come off the freeway and it's slowed down.
It's gone around the servo and it's pulled into the car park.
You think this is magnificent?
And then it has parked in the middle of two spots
like like a Tesla driver.
And I'm like, yeah, you know, it's it's kind of kind of leaning
into the brand a little bit too much there.
But you think it's done all of this so brilliantly
and then yet screws up at that last second.
And, you know, it's again, we can laugh about that.
Never was I in danger.
I certainly I never felt unsafe in it.
And it was remarkable.
And even the the camera that's looking at you,
like you actually have to concentrate.
And so in a way, it's more exhausting
than just bloody driving the car yourself.
But it is. Yeah, look, OK.
So big picture here.
I think I don't necessarily agree with this approach
with what Tesla is doing to get live market data.
But it's obviously working for them.
My question then is, who's they've opened the door?
They've gone and it's like Apple, when they dropped that first iPad
within a few months, every other year, hey, we can do these things as well.
So who's going to be next to come out with a level three system
that's level two, you know, or a level two system that's level three?
But who's to say it's going to be as good as what Tesla have in market?
Because I having done, like I said,
with a new brand, Adas, not all, not all Adas is the same.
You get into them, Sadie's Benz, it handles it very well.
You get into some new brands and they're not that good, right?
And so who's to say we're not going to see the second
full self driving dash S system
come into Australia under another marketing moniker from another brand
that hasn't put the R and D level in as much as Tesla has.
Where does that lead us then?
And this is the thing.
So that's the that's the sixty four thousand dollar question
because it is the what comes next.
Absolutely. Yeah.
Look, as much as I want to go, oh, no, it's actually no, I don't.
I didn't want it to fail.
I really wanted to see what it was.
But it is it is remarkable and it is incredibly clever.
And it did everything arguably, you know, with a far
safer level of attention than other drivers like you would have seen on the video.
I caught two cars running red lights.
I saw, you know, cars expecting things to
have it's it's concentrating all of the time.
So it's safe to say humans joining out.
It's safe to say that it exceeded your expectations then, didn't it?
It did. It did.
And and I look again to to just say take me to city or take me to Melbourne
from from a car like it's kind of not really the like it's an outside use case.
But again, what is the what is the inside use case?
Because if I say, oh, just drive me to the shops, I know where the shops are.
I'm just going to drive myself there.
So what what is it other than, like I said, it's the keyhole.
It's the doorway to the future.
Keeping that crystal ball on for a minute.
Have you ridden in a way, Mark?
No, and it is it's one of those things that a number of people
who I've spoken to about this have said it's just wild, because it is the coolest
thing you will ever do in the world of tech.
Like it's it's unbelievable to that a car comes up with your initials
highlighted on the roof that you press a button to open it, to start it,
to get it running and then you just get out and it drives away.
Mate, to me, I've done it three or four times with my kids earlier in the year.
It is the wildest thing.
And I think you should do that next time you're in either LA or San Francisco
because compare that with what you've done in an autonomous style vehicle.
And you start to really see.
I mean, again, hate Elon.
I just don't like the bloke at all.
But I believe he's a genius of our generation that will be long remembered
for things like SpaceX and potentially electrification of cars.
And when you when you realise that just that one vision,
he's got two visions get to Mars and robot taxis like you really do get it.
And I think the Waymo experience is just a future ready version
of what he's got in his mind.
A well worth looking at, James, a hundred percent.
And even the idea, I think he put a he put a tweet up the other day.
I'm still going to call him tweets.
Sorry, I'm just not getting the whole ex branding thing like, come on.
The he put a thing up, which, interestingly,
was the same thing Volvo said about ten years ago that they had the technology.
But obviously, it hasn't had the legality.
But soon your car can drop you go to the shopping mall,
you get out and your car goes and finds a park and parks itself.
And then when you finish your shop, you just go, OK, car, I'm ready.
And it comes and picks you up.
That is that is that is a viable, sensible, consumer friendly
use case for this technology, because everyone hates park.
God, I was at Melbourne Airport the other day, ready to just leave my car
in the middle of a lane, you know, and just go have at it.
I'm sick of trolling for car spots.
Imagine how much nicer Chadston would be at Christmas when you can simply roll up
or hop out of your car and it goes and parks itself.
They're certainly at a time.
I had I've had it had a Tesla years ago and that summon feature
was was a beta when I had my Tesla back in 2018.
I got my taking that into multi level car parks and all that kind of stuff
becomes super exciting.
James, mate, what an awesome thing to do for research, for journalistic purpose.
And it's a one hour plus video that you've done at drive.com.
That are you can look it up on YouTube.
Kenneth Tesla Drive itself from Sydney,
into Melbourne, and you can see all the things that James talked about
in our conversation here and much more.
Mate, great, great job.
Loved it. Great chat.
And yeah, really, really fascinated by the whole experience.
But I really, really appreciate you joining us.
No, thanks, guys.
Always happy to talk cars and put my life on the line for the
you know, the greater good and you know, the amount of jelly snakes
that that went down the hatch.
Because I tell you what, though, I've got to I've got to get some
better podcasts queued up because, you know, this is just a few for you.
I reckon you could. I reckon you could.
We only make six a week.
So we'll see what else we can find you, buddy.
We'll get you to Melbourne now on it just on our own, buddy.
Cheers, James. Good to talk to you, mate.
Thank you. Excellent. Thanks, guys.
Awesome stuff.
James Ward from drive.com.au.
Two like story electric cars.
Always great to have your company and always love to hear from you as well.
See something that's not quite right? Our annotations are AI-generated and can sometimes miss the mark.
Click the flag icon on any annotation to suggest a correction.
Report incorrect info
Suggest better explanations
Flag missing cars
More from Two Blokes Talking Electric Cars - The EV Podcast