0:00 / 0:00
#2635: Knock, Knock...

#2635: Knock, Knock...

The Best of Car Talk May 02, 2026 33 min
0:00
0:00

About this episode

The hosts bounce from joke warnings to a string of diagnosis calls, including a Honda Accord that races, a Miata with clutch trouble, and a truck engine that likely needs a full rebuild. They also solve the week’s puzzler, then help a GMC Sierra owner track down a mysterious knocking sound that seems to come from the HVAC area under the glove compartment. Along the way, the show leans on classic mechanical reasoning and a few very specific parts.

Filter:
|
Technical Too Afraid to Ask
Car

89 Accord LXI

"[215.7s] I've got an 89 Accord LXI, about 145,000 miles on it. [221.7s] And for the last couple of years, I've had a problem, [225.1s] very sporadic problem, where the throttle sticks."

They’re talking about a 1989 Honda Accord (LX I trim). It’s an older Honda, and the problem they’re having involves the car’s throttle/engine speed control.

Term

throttle sticks

"[221.7s] And for the last couple of years, I've had a problem, [225.1s] very sporadic problem, where the throttle sticks. [228.7s] Not a good problem to have."

“Throttle sticks” means the gas control doesn’t come back to idle like it should. So the engine may keep revving instead of slowing down.

Term

computer module

"[242.1s] It's either that we need to replace the throttle cable for 500 bucks [247.6s] or you need a new computer module for 500 bucks. [253.8s] And we don't know which one."

They’re talking about the car’s computer that controls how the engine runs. If it’s not working right, it can cause weird throttle or idle behavior even if the pedal and cable seem fine.

Term

throttle cable

"[236.8s] So I took it to the dealer and they said, well, it's one of two things. [242.1s] It's either that we need to replace the throttle cable for 500 bucks [247.6s] or you need a new computer module for 500 bucks."

A throttle cable is the physical cable that connects your gas pedal to the engine’s air/throttle valve. If it gets sticky or damaged, the car can feel like it’s stuck on the gas.

Part

throttle body

"Okay. That is the actual part of the car that bolts to the intake manifold that is actuated by the throttle cable because the throttle cable is cheap."

The throttle body is a part that controls how much air the engine can breathe. When you press the gas, it opens a valve; when you let off, it closes so less air goes in.

Term

intake manifold

"That is the actual part of the car that bolts to the intake manifold that is actuated by the throttle cable because the throttle cable is cheap."

The intake manifold is the passage that carries air from the air intake to the engine. The throttle body sits at the entrance so it can control how much air gets through.

Concept

carburetor

"Yeah, the throttle body is sort of part of what would have been the throat of the carburetor. Right. It's the flap that gets moved as you step on the gas pedal so that when the gas pedal,"

A carburetor is an older way cars used to mix fuel and air. The discussion is comparing how the throttle flap controls airflow in today’s setup versus how the carburetor’s throat worked.

Term

flap

"It's the flap that gets moved as you step on the gas pedal so that when the gas pedal, when your foot is off the gas pedal, the flap is essentially closed. And then as you step on the gas, that gradually opens to allow more air to enter the engine."

Inside the throttle body there’s a small valve (the flap) that opens and closes. If it sticks, the engine may not get the air it needs when you press the gas.

Term

carbon

"And make sure they get all the carbon and varnish build up out of the throttle area. [356.8s] And that might help too."

Carbon is a sticky black residue that can build up from engine combustion. Too much of it can make the throttle area dirty and affect how the car runs.

Term

varnish build up

"And make sure they get all the carbon and varnish build up out of the throttle area. [356.8s] And that might help too."

“Varnish” is a sticky film that can form from engine vapors and residue. It can coat the throttle area and make the throttle response worse.

Concept

mechanical thing and not an electrical

"If you can fix it by punching the pedal, it's a mechanical thing and not an electrical. [365.3s] Yeah."

They’re saying the cause is likely something physical—like a sticky throttle or cable—rather than an electronic problem. If the car acts up but improves when you press the gas, that often suggests a mechanical sticking issue.

Car

Mazda MX-5 / Miata

"I was on the upper east side. I have a little Mazda Miata. And it's a 94. And I've never had any trouble with it at all."

A Mazda Miata is a small two-seat sports car that’s popular because it’s light and easy to drive. Here, the speaker says theirs is a 1994, so it’s an older car and more likely to have normal wear-and-tear issues.

Term

clutch

"So cruising along. And I put my clutch starts to feel spongy. And of course, my first reaction is, oh, it's the heels."

The clutch is what you press when you want to change gears in a manual car. If it starts to feel “spongy,” it can mean the fluid system isn’t working right—often because of air or a worn-out part.

Term

shift it at a first

"Like I can barely shift it at a first. Now, mind you, it's like, like the, it's like 630. Traffic is like not moving."

First gear is the gear you use to get moving from a stop. If something’s wrong with the clutch, it can be hard to put the car into first gear.

Term

stall

"And the last thing you want to do is like stall on the Harlem River Drive. Oh, man. Height of rush hour."

A stall is when the engine suddenly turns off. It often happens when you’re trying to move but the car isn’t getting enough power to keep running.

Topic

Harlem River Drive

"And the last thing you want to do is like stall on the Harlem River Drive. Oh, man. Height of rush hour."

This is a road in New York City. The speaker mentions it to explain how stressful it was—traffic was heavy and stalling would be a big problem.

Term

drive anywhere in third

"And then I get hit with this inspiration that you can drive anywhere in third. So I, oh man, Alex, you are right on top of the situation. I shove it into third."

Third gear is a gear above first. If you can’t get into first, you can sometimes start and move using third instead—just carefully so you don’t stall.

Topic

George Washington Bridge

"And, and, and, you know, I, once I get past the George Washington Bridge, I can start going like 45 miles. And I get to this retirement party."

This is a major bridge in New York. The speaker uses it as a point where traffic clears up, so they can drive faster.

Term

differential

"And they said, oh, one guy said, oh, no, it's differential. No problem. Just pump your clutch."

A differential is a part in the drivetrain that lets the wheels spin at different speeds when you turn. If someone thinks it’s the differential, they’re usually worried about a drivetrain noise or problem near the axle.

Term

pops out of gear

"So I get in my little car and I pump my clutch and it pops out of gear. And I drive home and I'm able to shift and my clutch is no longer spongy."

“Popping out of gear” means the car won’t stay in the gear you selected. That can be caused by clutch problems or other issues that prevent the transmission from staying engaged.

Term

spongy

"And I drive home and I'm able to shift and my clutch is no longer spongy. Now it still feels a little bit rough."

A “spongy” clutch pedal usually means the clutch doesn’t feel firm and responsive. That often happens when there’s an issue with the clutch fluid or air in the hydraulic system.

Part

slave cylinder

"And, and the slave cylinder is actually what disengages the clutch. But if the master cylinder, because it's leaking, cannot produce enough pressure, then you push your pedal to the floor..."

In many cars, the clutch is controlled by fluid pressure. The slave cylinder is the part that uses that pressure to push the clutch mechanism so the clutch can release.

Part

master cylinder

"But if the master cylinder, because it's leaking, cannot produce enough pressure, then you push your pedal to the floor and it doesn't disengage the clutch or you can't shift it."

The master cylinder is the part that creates the hydraulic pressure used to operate the clutch. If it’s leaking, the clutch won’t release properly, so shifting becomes difficult.

Term

rubber seals

"It isn't pumping because the, the rubber seals in it have worn out. And it's been worsened by the fact that the hot weather has made the bore..."

Those rubber seals help keep the hydraulic fluid inside the clutch system. If they wear out, the system can lose pressure and the clutch won’t work right.

Term

bore

"...the hot weather has made the bore. That is the cylinder in which the piston moves bigger in diameter."

The bore is the inside wall of the cylinder that the piston slides in. If it changes (for example with heat), it can make the seals not seal as well, so the clutch system loses pressure.

Term

brake fluid

"[651.1s] And, and, and the air that was in there didn't become such a big factor [654.7s] and pumping it did compress the air somewhat. [657.8s] So that you have air in the system,"

Brake fluid is the special liquid that helps your brake system work. If there’s a leak, you can lose fluid and the brakes may not work as well.

Term

air in the system

"[654.7s] and pumping it did compress the air somewhat. [657.8s] So that you have air in the system, [659.5s] but it's because the thing has begun to fail."

Sometimes air gets into the hydraulic lines. Air is squishy, so instead of pushing the brakes/clutch right away, it compresses first—making the pedal feel soft or delayed.

Concept

quadratic equation

"And what you do that, you wind up with something called a quadratic equation. [995.6s] Is that right?"

A quadratic equation is a math equation that has a squared term, like x². It’s used when the relationship you’re modeling curves instead of being straight.

Term

head gasket problem

"And a week later, he called up and said that he thought I had a problem with my truck. He thought I had a head gasket problem."

The head gasket is like a tight seal inside your engine. If it goes bad, the engine can start mixing fluids that shouldn’t mix, which can lead to overheating and rough running.

Part

piston rings

"And when I walked around outside, I found some piston rings lying around. [1198.2s] And now I got a real problem with what mechanic describes as piston slap."

Piston rings are parts on the piston that help it seal tightly in the cylinder and keep oil under control. If they get overheated or damaged, the engine can start making bad noises and may burn oil.

Term

piston slap

"And when I walked around outside, I found some piston rings lying around. [1198.2s] And now I got a real problem with what mechanic describes as piston slap."

Piston slap is a knocking/tapping sound from inside the engine. It usually means the piston isn’t fitting as tightly as it should, often due to wear or damage.

Term

exhaust manifold

"And when I first started up the truck, all I heard was a little leak from the exhaust manifold. [1208.4s] I figured that's not a big deal."

The exhaust manifold is the part that gathers the engine’s exhaust gases and sends them down the exhaust pipe. If it leaks, you can hear noise and sometimes smell exhaust.

Concept

overheated

"It's 86's. [1223.6s] He must have said he was driving this thing. [1226.8s] He overheated like serious."

Overheating is when the engine gets too hot. If it happens badly or for too long, it can damage the engine’s internal parts.

Term

cracked the head

"[1241.3s] He cracked the head. [1243.5s] So how much did this end off costing you?"

This means the top part of the engine (the cylinder head) has a crack. That can let fluids leak or stop the engine from working properly, so the car may need major repair.

Concept

rebuild

"Anyway, should I just keep driving this truck or should I get it rebuilt? [1264.5s] I mean, it sounds like it's beaten itself to death."

“Rebuild” means fixing the car by taking the important parts apart and replacing the worn pieces. People do it when the car is starting to fail but they want to keep using it.

Concept

put the grill on upside down

"And I realized there was something wrong with the grill and I couldn't read the grill. And it's because he put the grill on upside down. That says something, doesn't it?"

Putting the grille on upside down is a clear mistake during reassembly. Here, they’re using that mistake as evidence that something else may have been assembled wrong too.

Term

connecting rod

"Well, he could easily have put, if he took the pistons off, I think what's likely to have happened is he put a connecting rod on backwards. Really? Because there is a preferred direction for the connecting rods and only one direction works."

A connecting rod is the metal link between the piston and the crankshaft. It helps turn the engine’s motion into rotation, and it usually has to be installed the right way so everything lines up correctly.

Concept

junkyard engine

"[1371.9s] That's what I was thinking, yeah. [1373.4s] Or a junkyard engine. [1375.7s] And if you are determined to take it on vacation and the like,"

A junkyard engine is a used engine pulled from a wrecked or totaled car. It can save money, but you don’t really know how healthy it is until it’s installed and tested.

Concept

uncertainty of when it's going to break down

"[1382.0s] Well, you're going to have to do it sooner or later. [1384.2s] Can you live with the uncertainty of when it's going to break down [1387.1s] or not knowing when it's going to break down?"

They’re talking about the risk of waiting to fix something when you don’t know when it will fail. If you keep driving, it could break at an inconvenient time or cause more damage.

Car

Gmc Sierra

"Well, I have a GMC Sierra pickup. It's a 1994. When I first noticed this, I was just driving along, and it was hot, and I needed to use my air conditioner."

A GMC Sierra is a pickup truck made by GMC. Here, the caller says it’s a 1994 model, which helps narrow down what could be making the knocking sound.

Term

turn the key on

"[1745.5s] and I turned the key on, [1747.7s] and the knock happened before I even got my truck started."

“Turn the key on” means you power up the car before it’s really running. If you hear a knock right then, it can mean the noise is tied to start-up conditions rather than normal driving.

Concept

knock

"and I turned the key on, [1747.7s] and the knock happened before I even got my truck started. [1752.5s] Get out."

A “knock” is a sharp, tapping/banging sound from the car. When it happens right when you turn the key on or off, it usually means something mechanical is making noise during start-up or shutdown, not just while you’re driving.

Term

automatic

"[1783.4s] So I pull up to wherever it is I'm going, [1786.6s] and it's an automatic. [1788.1s] So I put it in park, and I turn it off."

“Automatic” means the car shifts gears by itself. That’s relevant because some noises only show up when you put the car in Park or when you shut it off.

Term

park

"[1786.6s] and it's an automatic. [1788.1s] So I put it in park, and I turn it off. [1790.9s] I take the key out, and it knocks again."

“Park” is the gear position that locks the car so it stays still. If the knocking happens when you put it in Park or right after turning it off, it can point to where the problem is coming from.

Term

glove compartment

"It sounds like it's coming from inside the glove compartment. [1825.3s] So I open that up, and it's not, [1828.4s] I think it's under the glove compartment."

The glove compartment is the little storage box in the front of the car, usually on the passenger side. If the noise seems to come from that area, it often means the problem is behind the dashboard.

Term

fuel pump

"But when you described this problem, I heard fuel pump. [1852.4s] Really? [1853.2s] Now, it can't be the fuel pump."

The fuel pump is the part that sends gas from the gas tank to the engine. If it’s going bad, it can make strange noises and can also cause the car to run poorly or not start.

Part

heater core

"Well, the heater core is under there. The heater in the air conditioner evaporator and all that stuff is under there."

The heater core is what helps make the car’s heat. Hot coolant goes through it, and air blowing over it warms the cabin.

Part

air conditioner evaporator

"The heater in the air conditioner evaporator and all that stuff is under there."

The AC evaporator is where the air conditioner cools the air inside the car. It’s usually hidden under the dashboard, so problems there can cause odd noises.

Term

fan

"Well, then we'd have to go with the idea of the fan, because there's a fan under there, too... More likely, something stuck in there. There's a twig or something in there."

The “fan” is a spinning part in the car that moves air. If something gets stuck in it or it’s not mounted tightly, it can rattle or bang as it spins.

Term

housing

"...one ought to kilter and started banging against the housing. More likely, something stuck in there."

The “housing” is the cover/casing that surrounds a moving part. If the fan touches that casing, it can make loud knocking sounds.

Part

power antenna

"No, I'm sticking with the power antenna. ... Hey, maybe they were going to give her the power antenna. They started to install it, and it was Friday afternoon."

A power antenna is an antenna that moves in and out using a small electric motor. Instead of you manually extending it, the car does it for you.

Term

water sheet

"Oh, and somebody read the water sheet and said, hey, wait a minute, this isn't getting a power antenna."

A “water sheet” sounds like a paper checklist the shop uses to make sure the right parts go on the right car. They’re checking it because the wrong antenna type seems to be getting installed.

Part

regular antenna

"Well, I've already put in, just stick the regular antenna in there. No one will notice the motor underneath."

A regular antenna is the simpler kind that doesn’t move in and out. It’s being contrasted with the power antenna that uses a motor.

Concept

motor underneath

"No one will notice the motor underneath. Have someone take off that box and take a look at the fan, if it's not really impossible to do..."

They’re saying there’s a motor hidden behind the parts you can see. Even if the antenna looks right, that hidden motor could still be making noise.

3 cars featured

Request an Explanation

Heard something you'd like explained? We'll add it to this episode.

Sign in to request explanations for terms you heard.

Want to learn more?

Browse our glossary for plain-English explanations of automotive terms, jargon, and concepts.

Explore Terms

Help improve this episode

See something that's not quite right? Our annotations are AI-generated and can sometimes miss the mark. Click the flag icon on any annotation to suggest a correction.

Report incorrect info
Suggest better explanations
Flag missing cars