0:00 / 0:00
The Feds are after dealers who break advertising laws and here is what it means for you

The Feds are after dealers who break advertising laws and here is what it means for you

My Car Guru Podcast Apr 21, 2026 23 min
0:00
0:00

About this episode

Lenny Lawson breaks down how the FTC is cracking down on car dealers for deceptive online pricing—especially “bait” discounts that require add-on fees, plus misleading financing requirements. He explains how to sanity-check deals using MSRP, invoice/holdback, and the real impact of fees and monthly-payment games. He also discusses Nissan’s CEO calling for Japanese automaker consolidation to compete with fast-rising Hyundai/Kia. The episode ends with a poignant story about buying a meticulously documented 1965 Alfa Romeo Spider from an ailing collector, and advice on selling older cars before demand softens.

Filter:
|
Technical Too Afraid to Ask
Concept

deceptive advertising

"...my interpretation of the law, that their advertising was illegal... a discount, well, involved a discount that was unobtainable... Now, is that deceptive? Yeah, I think so."

Sometimes dealers advertise a great deal online, but it turns out you can’t actually get that price. If the ad makes it sound like you’ll pay one thing, but you end up paying more once you’re there, that can be deceptive.

Concept

unobtainable discount

"...offering a sell price online that was a discount, well, involved a discount that was unobtainable."

An “unobtainable” discount means the deal advertised online isn’t really what you can get in practice. It’s a warning sign that the final price may be higher once you’re negotiating in person.

Term

monthly payment

"...What kind of monthly payment you're looking for? ... Oh, we're looking about $4.50 a month... The payments are actually $5.75 a month."

Dealers sometimes focus on what you’ll pay each month rather than the full price of the car. A lower monthly number can be misleading if it’s achieved by stretching the loan or adding costs.

Concept

MSRP

"First, you have to understand what is the MSRP on this vehicle? What is MSRP? That's manufacturers suggested retail price."

MSRP is the price the manufacturer says the car should cost. When you’re shopping, it helps you judge whether a dealer’s deal is actually a discount or just marketing language.

Concept

invoice price

"...find out what the dealer paid for the vehicle, what the invoice price is. Now, is that his actual cost? See, this gets confusing too."

Invoice price is the amount a dealer is typically charged by the manufacturer for the vehicle. The host notes that people look up invoice price to estimate the dealer’s “real cost,” but it can get confusing because invoice isn’t the same as the dealer’s total out-the-door economics (holdbacks, incentives, and fees can matter).

Concept

hold back

"What a dealer pays for a vehicle from the factory is initially their cost, but the factory has something called hold back, which means they hold back a little bit of a discount that they pass on to the dealer."

When a dealer buys a car from the factory, the factory may hold back a small part of the price. Later, the factory sends that money to the dealer, which helps the dealer make more profit.

Company

Chevrolet

"And when I was a Chevrolet dealer, it was 3% of the MSRP minus freight. That was the hold back."

The host mentions Chevrolet to give a real-world example of how dealer incentives like holdback used to be calculated. It’s an example, not a specific car model.

Concept

floor plan assistance

"And we do get some floor plan assistance. The manufacturer helps us carry our inventory or helps pay our carrying cost for about 90 days."

Dealers usually borrow money to buy cars for their lot. Floor plan assistance is help from the manufacturer to reduce the interest cost while the cars are waiting to be sold.

Term

co-op

"And then we get some advertising assistance as well. It's called co-op. And so you could consider that money as part of the discount, but really it's really to offset expenses that we have."

Co-op is advertising help from the automaker. It reimburses or offsets part of what the dealer spends on local ads, so the dealer doesn’t have to pay everything out of pocket.

Company

Grasshopper

"which in our case would be Ferris and Grasshopper and TYM is our tractor line, they pay the interest to the bank for our floor plan."

Grasshopper is another example brand used to show how manufacturers may help pay interest on inventory. It’s not the focus of the episode’s car-dealer discussion.

Company

Ferris

"Now, tractors and lawn mowers, we also get free floor planning for up to a year, which means that the manufacturer, which in our case would be Ferris and Grasshopper and TYM is our tractor line,"

Ferris is mentioned as an example brand in the dealer’s other product lines. It’s used to explain how financing help can work for inventory in general.

Company

TYM

"Ferris and Grasshopper and TYM is our tractor line, they pay the interest to the bank for our floor plan."

TYM is mentioned as the tractor line the dealer carries, used to illustrate how floor planning can be supported by manufacturers. The host’s point is about financing inventory costs rather than a specific automotive technology.

Company

Federal Trade Commission

"So I was talking about the FTC and about advertising, so I called my competitor... The Federal Trade Commission just came out with new guidance."

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is the U.S. agency responsible for enforcing consumer protection laws, including rules around deceptive advertising. In this segment, the host frames the FTC as actively issuing guidance and pursuing penalties for misleading vehicle pricing online.

Term

dealer fees

"But in reality, that's not our price because you have to add $4,000 in fees to it."

Dealer fees are extra costs added on top of the car’s advertised price. The warning here is that if a dealer advertises a price that doesn’t include those mandatory fees, it can be seen as deceptive advertising.

Concept

FTC advertising guidance

"The Federal Trade Commission just came out with new guidance. They sent, I think it was 97 different dealer groups... said, okay, guys, stop deceiving customers. When you put something on the page that says our price, that better be your price"

The FTC is a U.S. government agency that watches how businesses advertise. This guidance is about making sure the price you see online is the real price you’ll have to pay, not a number that only becomes higher after extra charges.

Company

AutoNation

"That is a basically an organization that owns multiple dealerships like 30 or 40 or 100 and some different stores like AutoNation and the Hudson Group and different dealer groups like that."

AutoNation is a big dealership company in the U.S. The host mentions it to show that even large national dealers are being targeted with advertising-pricing rules.

Company

the Hudson Group

"...and some different stores like AutoNation and the Hudson Group and different dealer groups like that."

The Hudson Group is another large dealership organization. The host brings it up to show that the FTC’s message is aimed at big groups with lots of cars listed online.

Concept

fine per occurrence

"But the FTC is the big dog and the fine per occurrence... if you go into their website and they've got 300 cars on their website and all of them are priced in an illegal way, it's 300 times 51,000."

Instead of one penalty for the whole website, regulators can charge a penalty for each individual violation. So if many cars are advertised in the same misleading way, the total fine can grow very quickly.

Concept

state vs federal pricing rules (Tennessee vs FTC)

"So what's frustrating is the rules for our particular state, state of Tennessee is different than the federal rules in that you can charge a dock fee and you don't have"

Different levels of government can have different rules. The host is saying Tennessee’s rules about fees and pricing can be different from the FTC’s federal rules, so dealers have to follow both.

Concept

dock fee

"state of Tennessee is different than the federal rules in that you can charge a dock fee and you don't have"

A dock fee is an extra charge dealers add for getting the car from where it arrives to the dealership. The point being made is that some states treat these fees differently than federal advertising rules.

Concept

dealer price bait-and-switch via financing requirements

"and I see this all over the Tri-Cities here, where the dealership says the only way to them, that's also illegal according to the Federal Trade Commission. You know, you can't offer to sell something to somebody on the car business for a certain price and say, oh, if you don't finance it, it's $1,000 more."

This is when a dealer advertises one price, but then says you only get that price if you finance with them. It can trick you into thinking the deal is available to everyone.

Concept

captive finance (Ford Motor Credit / Toyota Motor Credit)

"because they make more profit when they finance a car for you because the bank or the credit union pays them a little bit of money to finance the car through that particular bank or credit union or captive like Ford Motor Credit or Toyota Motor Credit, whatever."

Some car brands have their own financing arm. If you finance through that brand’s lender, the dealer may make more money, so the deal can be less favorable than it looks.

Term

extended warranties

"And plus, the dealership has a better opportunity to sell aftermarket products such as extended warranties, gap insurance, and so on and so on."

An extended warranty is extra coverage you buy to help pay for repairs after the original warranty ends. Dealers often try to sell it during the sales process, especially when financing is involved.

Term

gap insurance

"such as extended warranties, gap insurance, and so on and so on."

Gap insurance helps if your car is totaled and the insurance payout doesn’t cover what you still owe on the loan. It’s often offered when you’re financing because it can be added to the overall purchase.

Concept

negotiate a car deal

"Send me your email address and I will send you a PDF of the My Car Guru guidebook, [714.2s] which breaks down how to negotiate a car deal, that and many other things."

They’re talking about how to negotiate when buying a car. The goal is to avoid getting rushed or pressured into accepting a bad deal.

Concept

show all your cards

"It's just like the negotiating that we're doing right now with [743.3s] those jobs in Iran. You can't show all your cards and you can't act too, [752.5s] I don't know, excited about making a deal because your adversary can see that."

It’s a way of saying don’t give away your strategy. If the other side knows how eager you are, they can push harder on you.

Brand

Nissan

"Okay, let's talk about what's going on in Japan right now. This is interesting. So I was reading [792.2s] an article about Nissan. And Nissan's had some struggles in recent years, not product struggles, [800.7s] just sales struggles in many markets."

They’re talking about Nissan and how its car sales have been struggling. The host says part of the issue was how Nissan planned for electric and hybrid cars.

Concept

hybrids

"they bet too early on EVs and they miss the hybrid thing. Whereas Toyota, [816.3s] they don't usually miss much anything. And they guessed right on the hybrid and they had all [821.7s] kinds of hybrids."

Hybrids use both gas and electricity to help save fuel. The host is saying Toyota did a better job offering hybrids that people wanted.

Concept

consolidation of all the Japanese car companies

"What interested me was the fact that this CEO of Nissan is talking about a consolidation of all the Japanese car [846.3s] companies so that they can compete."

They’re talking about Japanese car companies possibly combining efforts. The idea is to share work and spend less money so they can compete better worldwide.

Brand

Honda

"Now there are seven Japanese automakers. And, you know, [854.6s] you're familiar with Toyota, Honda, Nissan and Mitsubishi."

Honda is named as one of the big Japanese car brands. It’s part of the list the host uses to explain how many automakers are competing.

Brand

Mitsubishi

"you're familiar with Toyota, Honda, Nissan and Mitsubishi. [863.7s] They're the big ones."

Mitsubishi is mentioned as another Japanese car brand. The host is using it to show which companies are part of the bigger industry picture.

Brand

Korea

"And so they're [869.3s] saying that the only way they can effectively compete in the global market, especially against Korea, see Korea was a non factor, but they're not anymore."

The host is saying Korean car brands are becoming tougher competition. It’s part of why Japanese automakers might need to change how they compete.

Concept

control from raw materials...until their shipping cars across the ocean

"They also consolidated their supplier base, which means they can control from when the raw materials come out of the ground until their shipping cars across the ocean."

They’re describing a company controlling more steps of the process, not just building cars. If you control shipping too, you can often deliver cars faster and with fewer surprises.

Concept

consolidated their supplier base

"They also consolidated their supplier base, which means they can control from when the raw materials come out of the ground until their shipping cars across the ocean."

This is about a company choosing fewer suppliers and managing them more tightly. The idea is that it can get parts more reliably and at better prices, which helps the cars compete.

Concept

own the ships

"They even own the ships. And they are very powerful."

Instead of paying someone else to move cars by sea, the company owns the boats. That can make shipping more predictable and sometimes cheaper.

Concept

potential consolidation

"But they're talking about a potential consolidation, not that there'll be one company, but there'll still be four major companies that are working real closely together as far as technology is concerned."

The host is talking about companies working together more than before. Even if they stay separate brands, they might share parts or technology to save money and move faster.

Concept

four major companies working real closely together as far as technology is concerned

"But they're talking about a potential consolidation, not that there'll be one company, but there'll still be four major companies that are working real closely together as far as technology is concerned."

They’re saying companies may team up on the “how” of making cars, like shared tech or parts. But you’d still see different brand names and styles.

Concept

big three, General Motors, Ford and Chrysler Corporation

"It was just the big three, General Motors, Ford and Chrysler Corporation. And then this was back in when I got into the car business in 1978."

For a long time, most cars in the U.S. came from three big companies: General Motors, Ford, and Chrysler. The host is explaining that later, other brands started taking more of the market.

Car

Honda Accord

"...just when Honda was, you know, came out with the Accord and the Civic and, you know, Toyota had been goin..."

The Honda Accord is a regular-size family car (a sedan) made by Honda. People talk about it because it’s meant to be dependable and easy to live with for daily driving. It may come up when the podcast is describing how Honda became more popular with common, practical cars.

Car

Honda Civic

"... was, you know, came out with the Accord and the Civic and, you know, Toyota had been going for a long t..."

The Honda Civic is a smaller, everyday car made by Honda. It’s known for being practical and usually not too expensive to run. The podcast may mention it when talking about how Honda gained popularity with cars that fit daily life.

Brand

Mercedes

"And then you had BMW and Mercedes and Audi. And, you know, they all tried to make inroads into this country."

Mercedes is a well-known luxury car brand. The host is mentioning it as another company that tried to win U.S. customers during the same period. It’s more about brand competition than car mechanics.

Brand

BMW

"And then you had BMW and Mercedes and Audi. And, you know, they all tried to make inroads into this country. BMW has been very successful."

BMW is mentioned as a European automaker that successfully gained ground in the U.S. market after Japanese brands became popular. The point is about competitive market shifts—how different brands “made inroads” with buyers. It’s not a technical discussion, but it frames the broader auto-industry landscape.

Brand

Audi

"BMW has been very successful. Mercedes has as well. Audi, not so much."

Audi is another major German car brand. The host is saying it didn’t gain as much ground as some other European brands in the U.S. at the time. It’s a general competition story, not a specific car review.

Brand

Hyundai and Kia

"But they've got a heck of a competitor with Hyundai and Kia right now. Okay, I'll be right back."

Hyundai and Kia are mentioned as current competitors to the Japanese automakers. The host frames them as a “heck of a competitor,” implying they’ve improved enough to pressure traditional players. This is a market-competition point rather than a technical explanation.

Car

Alfa Romeo Spider 1600 Veloce

"I went and picked up a 1965 Alfa Romeo, Spider 1600 Veloce. That's a long name, but it's a special car. It's, it's an $80,000 to $100,000 car."

This is a classic Alfa Romeo roadster from the 1960s. “1600 Veloce” basically means it has a 1.6-liter engine and a more performance-focused setup. These older cars can be worth a lot more when they’ve been cared for and you can prove it with paperwork.

Car

Alfa Romeo Spider

"...sterday. I went and picked up a 1965 Alfa Romeo, Spider 1600 Veloce. That's a long name, but it's a speci..."

The Alfa Romeo Spider is a small two-seat convertible (a roadster) made by Alfa Romeo. The “1600 Veloce” part refers to a particular engine and trim level for that year. It’s the kind of car people talk about because it’s a classic open-top sports car.

Concept

National Register of Historic Places

"he lives in a, I think I mentioned this the other day, but he lives in a house. It was, it's on the National Register of Historic Places built in 1847, way out in the country in Greenback, Tennessee."

This is a U.S. list for places that are considered historically important. The host brings it up to show the owner’s environment and mindset are focused on preservation. It’s meant to connect that careful approach to how he maintains his cars.

Concept

keeping records of your oil changes and saving bills

"I talked to folks about the importance of keeping records of your oil changes and keep that in your car. You know, anytime, anytime you spending money on the car, just get a copy of the bill and fold it up, put it in your glove box. And then when you go trade the car, you've got all this great evidence that you took care of your vehicle."

The host is emphasizing “paper trail” maintenance—keeping receipts and service records (like oil change bills) to prove the car’s history. For classic and enthusiast cars, detailed documentation can increase buyer confidence, support resale value, and help justify condition claims. It also helps establish that maintenance was done consistently rather than “on faith.”

Concept

documentation (original documents, records)

"I've never seen anything like it all the original documents for when the vehicle was purchased. And all of that adds tremendous value to this vehicle... a lot of people... don't have any records whatsoever. And that really hurts the value of it."

They’re saying that keeping paperwork—like when you bought the car and what work was done—matters a lot. Buyers trust the car more when the history is documented, so the car can be worth more.

Concept

car collectors aging out

"But this is what's happening to a lot of folks. You know, we're just aging out. You know, we're car collectors and we've kept these vehicles in our basements or in our garages."

A lot of car owners who’ve kept their cars for decades are getting older. Eventually they have to sell, and that can affect how much those cars are worth and how easy they are to find.

Concept

market is getting softer

"But if you have an old car and know somebody that does and they're getting older, now's the time to think about getting rid of it because the market is getting softer."

When the market is “softer,” it usually means people are buying less and prices can drop. The host thinks it’s partly because younger generations aren’t as interested in some older car types.

Topic

collector car segments (50s/60s) dropping

"Because, like I say, for certain car segments, 50s, 60s, these cars are starting to drop because the people who love those cars are dying."

They’re saying some older cars from the 1950s and 1960s are starting to lose value. That’s because fewer people who grew up loving them are around or passing the interest on.

Car

Ford Mustang

"Now, there are some cars that are, I guess, that are always going to have some degree of interest, you know, like Mustangs, vintage Mustangs and Broncos and Corvettes and BMWs."

They’re using Mustangs as an example of a car people still want. When a model has a lot of fans, it usually holds value better than cars that only a small group cares about.

Car

Chevrolet Corvette

"...Mustangs, vintage Mustangs and Broncos and Corvettes and BMWs."

Corvettes are another example they give of a car that keeps interest. If lots of people still want them, prices tend to be less fragile.

Concept

vehicle becomes an antique

"It's hard to believe that a vehicle built in 2003 would be an antique. But it absolutely does qualify. I mean, 25, well, in some states, in 20 years, but 25 years is generally accepted as the point where a vehicle becomes an antique."

Many places have a special status for very old cars. Once a car is old enough (often around 25 years), it may qualify for “antique” rules that can change how you register it and how you can use it.

Concept

antique vehicle registration

"So if you've got one, you better be thinking about what you're going to do with it. Well, thanks for listening to this edition of our car guru."

If your car qualifies as an antique, you may need to change how you register it. The rules can vary by state, so it’s smart to figure out what’s required before you assume anything.

5 cars featured

Request an Explanation

Heard something you'd like explained? We'll add it to this episode.

Sign in to request explanations for terms you heard.

Want to learn more?

Browse our glossary for plain-English explanations of automotive terms, jargon, and concepts.

Explore Terms

Help improve this episode

See something that's not quite right? Our annotations are AI-generated and can sometimes miss the mark. Click the flag icon on any annotation to suggest a correction.

Report incorrect info
Suggest better explanations
Flag missing cars