0:00 / 0:00
This Dealer Got Burned on a $8,000 Trade-In. Here's How He Now Catches Every Hidden Repair | Industry Spotlight

This Dealer Got Burned on a $8,000 Trade-In. Here's How He Now Catches Every Hidden Repair | Industry Spotlight

Car Dealership Guy Podcast Jun 13, 2026 22 min
0:00
0:00

About this episode

After getting burned on an $8,000 trade-in miss, the dealer guest explains how hidden repairs slip through when inspections rely on a quick walk-around and short test drive. The fix is a scan-first workflow: sales plug in an appraisal tool, pull OBD-II data, and look for issues like lifter problems that only show up on cold start. The hosts also highlight how often codes get cleared right before sale and how the tool helps quantify reconditioning costs for more transparent negotiations.

Filter:
|
|
Technical Too Afraid to Ask
Concept

dishonest trade ins

"I'm your host, Sam Dark dishonest trade ins. They're nothing new, but when they start hitting your inventory in waves, you have to find"

It means some trade-in cars are being sold to the dealer with problems hidden or not fully disclosed. The dealer ends up losing money because the car isn’t as described.

Concept

appraisal process

"That's exactly what happened to today's dealer guest who went looking for a faster, more accurate appraisal process after getting burned one too many times. The solution, a tool that delivers a full vehicle appraisal in under a minute right"

An appraisal process is how the dealer decides what a trade-in is worth. If they miss problems, they may pay too much and lose money later.

Term

codes cleared

"20% of your appraisal trade ins have recently had their codes cleared. That means the car sitting in your service lane for an appraisal may be hiding exactly what you think it's hiding."

Cars store warning codes when something is wrong. Clearing the codes can make the car look fine during inspection, even if there’s a real problem underneath.

Concept

lemon

"And we talk about how dealers can protect themselves before that lemon makes its way into your inventory. Joining me today are Danny Galott, General Sales Manager at Luthier Chrysler Dodge"

In automotive usage, a “lemon” is a vehicle that has serious recurring problems that the manufacturer or seller can’t fix after a reasonable attempt. The phrase is used here to describe a bad car that could enter inventory if issues aren’t caught early.

Company

Luthier Chrysler Dodge

"Joining me today are Danny Galott, General Sales Manager at Luthier Chrysler Dodge G-Bram of Bend and Frederick Grimm, co-founder and COO of Fixed Automotive."

Luthier Chrysler Dodge is the dealership where the guest works. They’re talking about how trade-in appraisals impact the dealer’s money.

Company

Fixed Automotive

"Joining me today are Danny Galott, General Sales Manager at Luthier Chrysler Dodge G-Bram of Bend and Frederick Grimm, co-founder and COO of Fixed Automotive. [78.3s] Props to appraisal pro for sponsoring today's episode now, let's get into it."

Fixed Automotive is the company behind the appraisal tool being discussed in the episode. The idea is that it helps dealers find problems faster and more accurately.

Company

CDJR

"And you're at a CDJR store and it's interesting because in the CDJR world now, we've got multiple stores here at Ziggler, it is a game of capitalizing the used car side of the world."

CDJR is a shorthand for the car brands Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, and Ram. It tells you what kinds of vehicles that dealership sells and therefore what trade-ins they tend to see.

Concept

recon data

"So you've talked in places about the importance of having good data on those trade-ins. When you think about your old appraisal process, what was the standard process before you got access to good recon data?"

“Recon data” means the dealership’s detailed inspection/repair notes about a used car. Having that information helps them avoid overpaying for a trade-in when there are hidden problems.

Concept

walk-around

"Yeah, you know, it's the standard walk-around, running your fingers through all the seams, seeing if you have, you know, paint work, looking at all the tires and going for a short test drive."

A “walk-around” is the basic in-person inspection step used to evaluate a trade-in’s condition. In this segment, it’s contrasted with having recon data, and it’s described as relying on visual checks like seams, paint work, tires, and a short drive.

Car

Ford Model Ford

"...t. I remember this day, Clear's Day, I had a late model Ford Raptor that came in. It came in warm."

The Ford Model A is an old Ford car that was made many decades ago. It’s often mentioned because it’s a well-known classic and people use it as a reference when talking about older cars and their history.

Car

Ford Raptor

"I remember this day, Clear's Day, I had a late model Ford Raptor that came in. It came in warm."

The Ford Raptor is a tough, off-road version of the F-150 pickup. Here it’s the example truck that showed up as a trade-in and later turned out to have a problem they didn’t catch at first.

Term

lifters

"It wasn't until a couple days later, when it made it through shop, that we discovered it needed lifters, and it was an $8,000 miss."

Lifters are parts inside the engine that help open and close the valves. If they’re worn out, the engine can run poorly or make noise, and fixing them can be expensive because it may require major labor.

Term

cold start

"He came in from about an hour away knowing that it would be warm enough, non-detectable, until we do the cold start on it at that point."

A cold start means starting the car after it’s been parked long enough to cool down. Certain problems only show up at that moment, so checking a cold start can help you catch issues that disappear once the car warms up.

Term

test drive

"And there are things that we can't find in a 5, 10-minute appraisal that makes it tough, right? No, absolutely. Especially on the variable side, we are not the trained technicians to know everything there is to know about these. And a test drive does not necessarily give you all the data that you need in that short period of time."

A test drive is a short, controlled road evaluation meant to check how a car behaves under typical conditions. The key point here is that a brief test drive may not expose intermittent or temperature-dependent faults, so it can miss issues that show up only after a cold start or over longer use.

Term

Raptor miss

"So after the Raptor miss, did you go out and try to find a better solution? [294.4s] Did you say, hey, there's got to be a way for me to better appraise these vehicles and not be surprised?"

A “miss” means they didn’t catch a problem during inspection, and it ended up costing a lot later. “Raptor” is the name of the vehicle they’re talking about, but this clip doesn’t say exactly which one.

Concept

better visibility into issues

"Danny called up and said, hey, I need better visibility into issues like this Raptor."

They’re talking about finding car problems earlier and more reliably. That way, the dealership can estimate repairs better instead of getting hit with unexpected costs later.

Term

OBD2 port

"we were just pulling data from the OBD2 port and helping to be able to give an idea of what the actual repair is needed"

The OBD2 port is a built-in diagnostic plug in the car. Mechanics can connect a scanner to read warning codes so they can figure out what’s going on.

Term

EGR problems

"There was a time where we had a street purchase come in and it was an eco diesel of some sort. I'm not sure the brand that it was, but they're known to have EGR problems and"

EGR is a system that helps the engine burn cleaner by sending some exhaust gas back into the engine. If it’s not working right, the car can throw warning codes and the engine may run poorly or fail emissions checks.

Term

reconditioning costs

"There's additional costs associated when you're taking in a vehicle. [531.5s] We have reconditioning costs, so we have to look at these things. [542.6s] from. If we're looking at something that the Appraisal Pro shows us, it needs $2,500 additional to"

Reconditioning costs are the money a dealer estimates it will need to fix up a used car before selling it. If the car needs things like brakes or tires, those costs get counted in the trade-in offer.

Concept

trade figure

"When we're presenting the trade figure to these customers, it just solidifies where we're coming [542.6s] from. If we're looking at something that the Appraisal Pro shows us, it needs $2,500 additional to"

Your trade figure is the price the dealer offers you for your current car. The point here is that the dealer should explain how they got that number, especially if the car needs repairs.

Term

tires or brakes

"it needs $2,500 additional to [548.8s] tires or brakes or whatever it may be. There's a reason why we came to this number. [554.4s] It's not that we just pulled this number out of the sky"

Tires and brakes are parts that wear out over time. If a trade-in needs new tires or brake work, the dealer may reduce the trade value because it has to pay to fix those items.

Concept

shop bills

"It just gave [596.3s] an all-around better understanding for shop bills and things like that that typically sales people [601.2s] don't understand."

Shop bills are the repair invoices—basically, what it costs to fix the car. The segment is saying salespeople may not always understand those repair costs, even though they matter for trade-in pricing.

Term

generic codes

"This includes all standard or generic codes, but then all the additional enhanced codes."

Generic codes are common error messages that many cars use. A basic scanner can read them, but they might not show the full, brand-specific story.

Term

enhanced codes

"This includes all standard or generic codes, but then all the additional enhanced codes."

Enhanced codes are more detailed error information than the basic ones. They can help identify the exact problem instead of just a general warning.

Term

control modules

"Looking at all different control modules of the vehicle to identify problems, some of which may be illuminated by a light on the dash, some of which may be hidden and not clear or easy to see."

Control modules are the car’s computers that run different systems. A scan can check several of them to find problems that might be “hidden.”

Concept

percent probability of the most likely repair

"We'll do the scan... to be able to give you a percent probability of the most likely repair and then giving you the cost of that."

Rather than only showing error codes, the system estimates what repair is most likely. It uses past data to give a confidence-style guess so dealers can estimate costs faster.

Term

IMS

"We'll do the scan. It'll populate to your IMS, and in about a minute you should have an email that tells you exactly what the mechanical reconditioning costs are."

IMS is the dealer’s internal computer system where the scan results get sent. The goal is to make the diagnostic info usable for estimating repairs.

Term

check engine light

"Danny shared the story about this clear check engine light. That to me is crazy. A consumer or anyone, us included at a dealership, can just go clear that light."

The check engine light is a warning that something in the engine or emissions system needs attention. You can sometimes clear it, but the problem may still be there and the light can come back.

Term

scan

"It's a conversation starter, but again, it makes sure that you're not getting [800.3s] taken advantage of and that you use data to make an informed decision. [805.8s] With that much data, are you able to quantify the impact or the number of repairs that you're"

A scan is when a shop plugs in a tool to read the car’s computer for problem codes. It helps you see what the car has been complaining about, even if the warning light was turned off.

Term

ROI

"An average dealership, we're helping them to discover between $15,000 to $20,000 in [833.1s] hidden mechanical reconditioning costs. So it's very easy to provide a clear ROI for our customers."

ROI means “did this investment pay off?” In this context, it’s whether using their process saves enough money to be worth it.

Term

fraud detection

"We've added a lot of functionality too. Big one is fraud detection. So looking at different control [893.2s] modules in the vehicle to be able to determine if a customer has rolled back the odometer or if"

Fraud detection means looking for signs that someone tried to cheat the car’s history. In this case, they’re talking about catching things like odometer tampering using the car’s own data.

Term

rolled back the odometer

"So looking at different control [893.2s] modules in the vehicle to be able to determine if a customer has rolled back the odometer or if [898.0s] there's been fraud more on that vehicle."

Rolling back the odometer means someone changes the mileage reading to make the car look like it has been driven less. That can hide how much wear the car really has.

Term

vin fraud

"So how do you sense vin fraud? That's a big issue, particularly in the Midwest, [913.3s] I would say."

VIN fraud is when a car’s unique ID number is tampered with. That can make a bad or stolen car look like a different, more valuable one.

Term

man in the middle device

"there's a little man in the middle device that someone may install behind the [928.4s] OBD2 port that it presents a different vin"

This is a gadget that sits between the scan tool and the car’s computer. It can trick the scanner into seeing a fake VIN or other misleading info.

Term

OBD2 sensor

"So if you're going and you're plugging in an OBD2 sensor, [939.1s] it's going to give you the fake vin"

When people say “OBD2 sensor” here, they mean the scan/diagnostic process through the OBD2 port. A scammer can trick what the scanner reports back to the shop.

Concept

data driven decisions

"This is a different approach using the data. What would you say to somebody who's slow to adopt, [984.1s] embracing data to make data driven decisions"

“Data-driven decisions” means using measurable information (like vehicle history, condition reports, and market pricing data) instead of relying mainly on intuition. In used-car appraisal, it’s meant to reduce losses from hidden issues and pricing mistakes.

Concept

service lane

"could use your product to acquire vehicles from the service lane? ... acquire roughly 20 to 30 appraisals from the service lane."

The service lane is where cars go when they’re being worked on—like repairs or maintenance. In this discussion, they’re using what they find there to help the dealership price and evaluate cars more accurately.

Term

appraisals

"we can help dealers acquire roughly 20 to 30 appraisals from the service lane. So that's something that we're planning on releasing later this year."

An appraisal is the dealer’s estimate of what a car is worth. It’s what they use to decide how much money they’ll offer you for your trade-in or buy a used car for.

Concept

hidden mechanical reconditioning cost

"we guarantee that you're going to see at least five, probably closer to $10,000 in hidden mechanical reconditioning cost"

This means the car needs repairs or fixing that you might not notice right away. If the dealer doesn’t catch it early, it can cost them a lot of money after they’ve already agreed on a trade-in price.

Term

gross

"“I see how we're not going to get burned. I see how we're going to protect our gross.”"

In dealership talk, “gross” usually refers to gross profit from the deal—how much money the store makes before expenses. The speaker frames the appraisal/trial as a way to avoid being “burned,” protecting that gross by catching issues early.

Term

sensors

"“We'll include all the sensors to you for free.”"

Here, “sensors” are the devices the dealership plugs in to check the car’s condition. They help find issues that you might not notice by just looking.

Term

DMS

"“Are there integrations? Does it integrate in with DMS with CRM?”"

DMS is the dealership’s main computer system for managing cars and paperwork. The host is asking if the tool can connect to it.

Term

CRM

"“Are there integrations? Does it integrate in with DMS with CRM?”"

CRM is the software dealerships use to keep track of customers and sales leads. The question is whether the appraisal info can connect to that system too.

Term

repair cost

"“in about 15 and 30 seconds, we'll generate the… we'll see the codes, we'll generate the repair cost.”"

“Repair cost” is the estimated price to fix whatever problems the car’s checks find. The tool calculates it and puts it into the dealer’s report.

Brand

viato

"“that'll populate directly in line in viato.”"

Viato is the software the dealer uses to manage the car’s report. The tool described here fills the results into that system.

Car

Jeep Recon

"... best practice of scanning vehicles to understand recon costs during the use car appraisal process. And F..."

A “Recon” in dealership talk usually means the work done to prepare a used vehicle for sale. When someone mentions a Jeep Recon, they’re typically talking about the reconditioning steps and costs needed to get that Jeep ready.

2 cars featured

Request an Explanation

Heard something you'd like explained? We'll add it to this episode.

Sign in to request explanations for terms you heard.

Want to learn more?

Browse our glossary for plain-English explanations of automotive terms, jargon, and concepts.

Explore Terms

Help improve this episode

See something that's not quite right? Our annotations are AI-generated and can sometimes miss the mark. Click the flag icon on any annotation to suggest a correction.

Report incorrect info
Suggest better explanations
Flag missing cars